Understory biomass plays an important role in forests, and explicit characterizations of live and dead understory vegetation are critical for wildland fuel characterization and to link understory vegetation to ecosystem processes. Current methods to accurately model understory fuel complexity in 3D rely on expensive and often inaccessible technologies. Structure-from-motion close-range photogrammetry, in which ordinary photographs or video stills are overlaid to generate point clouds, is promising as an alternative method to generate 3D models of fuels at a fraction of the cost of more traditional field surveys. In this study, we compared the performance of close-range photogrammetry with field sampling surveys to assess the utility of this alternative technique for quantifying understory fuel structure. Using a commercially available GoPro camera, we generated 3D point cloud models from video-derived image stills of 138 sampling plots across two western ponderosa pine and two southeastern slash pine sites. We directly compared structural metrics derived from the photogrammetry to those derived from field sampling, then evaluated predictive models of biomass calibrated by means of destructive sampling. Photogrammetry-derived measures of occupied volume and fuel height showed strong agreements with field sampling (Pearson’s R = 0.81 and 0.86, respectively). While we found weak relationships between photogrammetry metrics and biomass 0 to 10 cm in height, occupied volume and a novel metric to characterize the vertical profile of vegetation produced the strongest relationships with biomass above the litter layer (i.e., >10 cm) across different fuel types (R2 = 0.55–0.76). The application of this technique has the potential to provide managers with an accessible option for inexpensive data collection and can lay the groundwork for the rapid collection of input datasets to train landscape-scale fuel models.
Recent wildfires across western North America have burned with uncharacteristically high severity, representing a substantial departure from natural fire regimes. In mixed‐conifer and pine–oak ecosystems of the southern Cascade Range, widespread shifts in stand structure and composition have led to a diversity of post‐wildfire vegetation responses. When recent wildfire “footprints” reburn in subsequent fires, their recovery pathways are complex. In order to understand the effects of overlapping mixed‐severity fires, we quantified changes in overstory and midstory structure and species composition for time periods prior to and following two large overlapping wildfires in the southern Cascades: the 2000 Storrie and 2012 Chips Fires. Plots were stratified into 16 severity combinations (unburned, low, moderate, and high in the Storrie Fire combined with the same four categories in the Chips Fire: e.g., moderate Storrie/high Chips) across the 9000‐ha overlapping burned area. Following the two fires, tree quadratic mean diameter and stand density declined for most species, but changes were species‐specific. Compared with preburn values, importance values for fire‐sensitive white fir (Abies concolor) were reduced by 66%, while resprouting fire‐resilient California black oak (Quercus kelloggii) importance values increased by 37% in severity combinations that included at least one high‐severity fire. Greatest shifts were documented in sites that burned twice at high severity, where resulting vegetation was dominated by oak sprout clumps and resprouting and fire‐stimulated montane chaparral species, while unburned and low‐severity strata retained a substantial component of Douglas‐fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii) and white fir. Results suggest that repeated moderate‐ and high‐severity fires can result in ecosystem state shifting toward fire‐resilient oak‐shrub communities in this fire‐prone landscape. Managers seeking greater landscape resilience can implement treatments such as thinning and prescribed burning, while taking advantage of fire‐created patches such as these in areas where the likelihood of a hotter and drier future makes the reestablishment of continuous forest cover unrealistic.
Electromagnetic radiation at 1550 nm is highly absorbed by water and offers a novel way to collect fuel moisture data, along with 3D structures of wildland fuels/vegetation, using lidar. Two terrestrial laser scanning (TLS) units (FARO s350 (phase shift, PS) and RIEGL vz-2000 (time of flight, TOF)) were assessed in a series of laboratory experiments to determine if lidar can be used to estimate the moisture content of dead forest litter. Samples consisted of two control materials, the angle and position of which could be manipulated (pine boards and cheesecloth), and four single-species forest litter types (Douglas-fir needles, ponderosa pine needles, longleaf pine needles, and southern red oak leaves). Sixteen sample trays of each material were soaked overnight, then allowed to air dry with scanning taking place at 1 h, 2 h, 4 h, 8 h, 12 h, and then in 12 h increments until the samples reached equilibrium moisture content with the ambient relative humidity. The samples were then oven-dried for a final scanning and weighing. The spectral reflectance values of each material were also recorded over the same drying intervals using a field spectrometer. There was a strong correlation between the intensity and standard deviation of intensity per sample tray and the moisture content of the dead leaf litter. A multiple linear regression model with a break at 100% gravimetric moisture content produced the best model with R2 values as high as 0.97. This strong relationship was observed with both the TOF and PS lidar units. At fuel moisture contents greater than 100% gravimetric water content, the correlation between the pulse intensity values recorded by both scanners and the fuel moisture content was the strongest. The relationship deteriorated with distance, with the TOF scanner maintaining a stronger relationship at distance than the PS scanner. Our results demonstrate that lidar can be used to detect and quantify fuel moisture across a range of forest litter types. Based on our findings, lidar may be used to quantify fuel moisture levels in near real-time and could be used to create spatial maps of wildland fuel moisture content.
Background: We evaluated the three-dimensional (3D) structure, composition, and biomass of understory fuels common to prescribed burn programs in pine-dominated forests of the southeastern and western United States. Traditional fuel characterization in these systems has been limited to two-dimensional representations, including biomass, height, and cover estimates per unit area. The objective of this study was to compare close-range photogrammetry with terrestrial lidar scanning (TLS), validated by destructive sampling to inform gridded 3D maps of live and dead understory fuels. Results: We developed and analyzed a large dataset of calibrated plots using co-located terrestrial lidar scanning (TLS), close-range photogrammetry, and destructive biomass sampling conducted at 18 field sites across the southeastern and western US. Field sites represented vegetation commonly burned in prescribed fire programs, including southeastern mesic flatwood forests, southeastern loblolly-sweetgum forests, western ponderosa pine and mixed conifer forests, and western grasslands. Scanning methods were compared with metrics derived from fine-scale volumetric fuels sampling to determine the most effective method for mapping fuels in 3D. TLS and SfM-based point cloud metrics were variable in their accuracy dependent on vegetation type and levels of occlusion in understory vegetation, and neither was effective at predicting fuels within the lowest sampled stratum (0–10 cm). Conclusions: Modeled relationships between photogrammetry and TLS-based metrics and fuel biomass and bulk density can be used to produce unit-scale mapping for prescribed burn programs that are informed by the 3D structure and composition of understory fuels. However, point-cloud metrics may be limited in their utility in dense fuel complexes with high levels of occlusion. This work supports advances in the characterization and mapping of wildland fuel beds for use in physics-based models of fire behavior and effects that rely on gridded, 3D inputs.