20 December 2022 in Lex Scientia Law Review
The writing of this paper aims to examine the policy of the criminal justice system for children in conflict with the law and reformulation of the criminal justice system for children in conflict with the Pancasila justice. The main problem in writing this paper is that why it is considered important to reform the criminal justice system for children in conflict with the law based on Pancasila justice? This study uses secondary data by analyzing the laws of the juvenile justice system in Indonesia and comparing them to the laws and regulations regarding the juvenile justice system in Greece and Yoslavia. The results of the study found that the age requirement for criminal responsibility for children is too low, namely 12 (twelve) years and the terms of diversion, that the threat of criminal acts that can be carried out by diversion and not repetition of criminal acts is not in line with the aim of diversion, namely to prosper and achieve the best interests of children such as recommended by the Convention on the Right of the Child and The Beijing Rules. Therefore, it is important to reformulate/reformulate immediately regarding these diversion requirements. The conclusion of this paper emphasizes the importance of reformulating the criminal justice system for children in conflict with the law (the criminal child) based on Pancasila justice.
30 October 2020 in Jurnal Hukum Progresif
Tulisan ini dilatarbelakangi oleh adanya perbedaan pandangan dalam melihat kedudukan nilai moral dalam ilmu hukum. Permasalahan yang menarik dikaji adalah “bagaimanakah eksistensi nilai moral dalam ilmu hukum menurut optik paradigma Hukum Kodrat dan paradigma Positivisme? Hasil pembahasan menunjukkan bahwa aliran Hukum Kodrat melihat fakta dan nilai serta ilmu pengetahuan dan pertimbangan moral sangat berbeda dengan aliran Positivisme Hukum. Menurut optik aliran Hukum Kodrat, nilai-nilai moral memberikan ruh/jiwa bagi keabsahan norma hukum, sedangkan menurut optik aliran Positivisme Hukum, hukum harus dipisahkan dari moral, hukum tidak ada sangkut pautnya dengan moral. Simpulan artikel ini menegaskan bahwa untuk memahami eksistensi nilai moral dalam ilmu hukum sangat ditentukan oleh optik aliran hukum yang dipergunakannya.
4 May 2026 in IJCLS (Indonesian Journal of Criminal Law Studies)
The integration of community service orders into the national criminal justice system indicates a shift away from a punitive approach dominated by incarceration toward the use of non-custodial sanctions more oriented toward rehabilitation and social reintegration. Nevertheless, studies systematically linking normative constructions, institutional readiness, and the community's role in their implementation remain relatively limited. This study aims to analyze the normative construction and institutional readiness for the application of community service as a substitute for short-term imprisonment, and to assess its consistency with criminal justice reform in Indonesia. This study uses a normative juridical method with a legislative and comparative approach, through an analysis of national legal regulations and practices in several countries that have institutionalized community service orders. The results of the study show that although the normative framework is relatively comprehensive, its implementation effectiveness is greatly influenced by the consistency of judges' decisions, the readiness of the supervision and guidance system, and the level of collaboration between law enforcement officers and the community. The main challenge lies in the limitations of probation infrastructure and the tendency of a still prison-oriented penal culture. This study offers an innovation in the form of an integrative framework that links normative design, institutional capacity, and social participation as prerequisites for effective implementation. Thus, community service orders can be understood not only as an alternative to imprisonment but also as a policy instrument that can support the development of a penal system that is more proportional, rehabilitative, and oriented towards social reintegration.
6 March 2026 in Law Research Review Quarterly
IFIka Anisatul Fatma Fitria
Ika Anisatul Fatma Fitria
Bullying involving children has become an increasingly serious issue in Indonesia and poses complex legal challenges, particularly when children are positioned not only as victims but also as perpetrators. The prevailing legal framework requires a careful balance between legal accountability and the protection of children’s rights. This article aims to analyze the implementation of legal protection for child perpetrators of bullying in Indonesia and to compare it with the juvenile justice approach applied in Finland. This research employs a normative legal research method using statutory, conceptual, and comparative approaches. The study examines legislation concerning child protection and the juvenile criminal justice system in Indonesia, relevant international legal instruments, as well as policies on bullying prevention and child protection in Finland. The findings indicate that, although Indonesian law normatively emphasizes the principle of child protection, including the application of diversion and restorative justice, its implementation in cases involving child perpetrators of bullying remains inconsistent and tends to be oriented toward punitive measures. In contrast, Finland prioritizes preventive efforts, psychosocial interventions, and school-based accountability mechanisms, thereby minimizing the use of criminal sanctions against children. This study concludes that enhancing the effectiveness of legal protection for child perpetrators of bullying in Indonesia requires strengthening restorative justice mechanisms, improving inter-agency coordination, and integrating prevention models that are non-punitive in orientation and centered on the best interests of the child.
7 May 2026 in Lex Scientia Law Review
Child sexual violence remains a serious challenge in Indonesia despite the existence of various legal instruments, including the 1945 Constitution, the Child Protection Law, and Law Number 12 of 2022 concerning Sexual Violence Crimes. The increasing number of cases indicates that existing legal measures have not been fully effective in preventing and addressing child sexual violence. Previous studies have primarily focused on punishment mechanisms and specific sanctions, while limited attention has been given to the integration of penal and non-penal approaches within a comprehensive criminal policy framework. This study aims to analyze the factors contributing to child sexual violence and formulate an integrated criminal policy model to address this issue. The research employed normative juridical legal research using statutory and conceptual approaches. The analysis was conducted through a qualitative doctrinal examination of primary and secondary legal materials. The findings revealed that child sexual violence is influenced by multiple factors, including the psychological, moral, and behavioral characteristics of offenders, as well as social, cultural, economic, educational, and technological factors that create conditions conducive to such crimes. The study argues that reliance on penal measures alone is insufficient to provide effective protection for children. An integrated criminal policy combining penal and non-penal approaches is therefore required. This model incorporates law enforcement, child protection mechanisms, family and community participation, educational interventions, and offender rehabilitation. The proposed framework contributes to criminal law policy discourse by offering a more comprehensive strategy for preventing child sexual violence while promoting victim protection, offender rehabilitation, and social reintegration.
5 April 2026 in Ikatan Penulis Mahasiswa Hukum Indonesia Law Journal
The importance of applying diversion to children as perpetrators, because the application of criminal punishment to children has the potential to damage their future, especially in terms of the psychological impact on children. The main focus of this study is to examine how prosecutors at the Jepara District Attorney's Office implement diversion in handling child cases to achieve restorative justice, and to analyze the factors that explain why diversion has not yet achieved restorative justice. The research method used a qualitative approach with a sociological-legal perspective. Data collection techniques included interviews, documentation, and literature review. The results of this study show that the implementation of diversion in juvenile cases at the Jepara District Attorney's Office has been carried out in accordance with the Juvenile Criminal Justice System Law and applied from stage II through the trial process. However, its implementation has not been fully effective, as the study found that the District Attorney's Office's diversion efforts often fail. This is due to several factors that hinder diversion efforts. This study concludes that the success of diversion efforts depends on public awareness, as active participation is the key to restorative justice. Restorative justice encourages meetings between victims and perpetrators of crime to reach a fair agreement.