7 May 2026 in Lex Scientia Law Review
Child sexual violence remains a serious challenge in Indonesia despite the existence of various legal instruments, including the 1945 Constitution, the Child Protection Law, and Law Number 12 of 2022 concerning Sexual Violence Crimes. The increasing number of cases indicates that existing legal measures have not been fully effective in preventing and addressing child sexual violence. Previous studies have primarily focused on punishment mechanisms and specific sanctions, while limited attention has been given to the integration of penal and non-penal approaches within a comprehensive criminal policy framework. This study aims to analyze the factors contributing to child sexual violence and formulate an integrated criminal policy model to address this issue. The research employed normative juridical legal research using statutory and conceptual approaches. The analysis was conducted through a qualitative doctrinal examination of primary and secondary legal materials. The findings revealed that child sexual violence is influenced by multiple factors, including the psychological, moral, and behavioral characteristics of offenders, as well as social, cultural, economic, educational, and technological factors that create conditions conducive to such crimes. The study argues that reliance on penal measures alone is insufficient to provide effective protection for children. An integrated criminal policy combining penal and non-penal approaches is therefore required. This model incorporates law enforcement, child protection mechanisms, family and community participation, educational interventions, and offender rehabilitation. The proposed framework contributes to criminal law policy discourse by offering a more comprehensive strategy for preventing child sexual violence while promoting victim protection, offender rehabilitation, and social reintegration.
10 September 2026 in Journal of Law and Legal Reform
Indonesian criminal law reform through Law Number 1 of 2023 recognizes living law as a source of criminal law, as stipulated in Article 2 of the Criminal Code. This provision reflects the integration of the principles of formal and material legality and recognition of the constitutional rights of indigenous peoples. However, its implementation has been controversial, particularly because it emphasizes the positive nature of unlawfulness, while in practice, society still applies material unlawfulness in a negative function. Phenomena such as gresek/ngasak in Java and elopement in Lombok demonstrate the difference between the assessment of customary law and national criminal law regarding an act. Although existing studies have examined living law and the principle of material legality, a research gap remains in comprehensively examining the application of material unlawfulness in its negative function as a basis for excluding the unlawfulness of an act that formally constitutes a criminal offense under the Criminal Code but is not regarded as unlawful under the living law of the community. This study is among the first to examine the negative function of material unlawfulness under Article 2 of the Indonesian Criminal Code. This study uses a normative juridical method, with a qualitative approach, based on a literature review of primary and secondary legal materials. The results demonstrate the need to consider living law in society as a basis for assessing material unlawfulness. The doctrine of material unlawfulness in a negative function has been applied in Supreme Court jurisprudence, particularly in Decisions Number 42 K/Kr/1965 and Number 81 K/Kr/1973. In both cases, although the formal elements of the crime were met, the judges considered that the unlawful nature could be eliminated based on the principles of justice, unwritten law, and the concept of material justice, so that the perpetrators were not punished. In the development of judicial practice, this teaching tends to be ignored. Conversely, in the lives of rural communities in Batang and Banjarnegara, this principle remains alive, reflected in the practice of gresek/ngasak, which is seen as a form of social solidarity and is not considered an unlawful act.