Eleanor Hoverd

Eleanor Hoverd

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Eleanor Hoverd

Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

8Years (2019-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
8 January 2019 in The Journal of Headache and Pain
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
RPRachel Potter
Rachel Potter
SHSiew Wan Hee
Siew Wan Hee
FGFrances Griffiths
Frances Griffiths
KDKatherine Dodd
Katherine Dodd
EHEleanor Hoverd
Eleanor Hoverd
MMManjit Singh Matharu
Manjit Singh Matharu
For a trial of supportive self-management for people with chronic headache we needed to develop and validate a telephone classification interview that can be used by a non-headache specialist to classify common chronic headache types in primary care. We aimed to specifically: exclude secondary headaches other than medication overuse, exclude primary headache disorders other than migraine and tension type headache (TTH), distinguish between chronic migraine and chronic TTH, and identify medication overuse headache. We held a headache classification consensus conference to draw on evidence and expertise to inform the content of a logic model underpinning the classification interview. Nurses trained to use the logic model did telephone classification interviews with participants recruited from primary care. Doctors specialising in headache did a second validation interview. Twenty-six delegates attended the headache classification conference including headache specialist doctors, nurses and lay representatives (with chronic headache). We trained six nurses to do the classification interviews and completed 107 paired interviews, median days between interviews was 32 days (interquartile range 21–48 days). We measured level of agreement between the nurse and doctor interviews using proportion of concordance, simple kappa and prevalence-adjusted bias-adjusted kappa (PABAK). Proportion of concordance of agreement between nurse and doctor interviews was 0.76, simple kappa coefficient κ 0.31 (95% CI, 0.09 to 0.52), and PABAK 0.51 (95% CI, 0.35 to 0.68), a moderate agreement. In a sensitivity test following review of headache characteristics recorded, concordance was 0.91, κ = 0.53 (95% CI, 0.28 to 0.79), and PABAK = 0.81 (95% CI, 0.70 to 0.92), a very good agreement. We developed and validated a new evidence-based telephone classification interview that can be used by a non-headache specialist to classify common chronic headache types in primary care.

19 May 2022 in BMJ Open
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EHEleanor Jayne Hoverd
Eleanor Jayne Hoverd
GHGeorge Hawker-Bond
George Hawker-Bond
SSSophie Staniszewska
Sophie Staniszewska
JDJeremy Dale
Jeremy Dale
Objective To develop and refine a programme theory that explains factors that influence decisions to take part in health research by people of diverse ethnic and cultural backgrounds. Design Realist review following a sequence of five steps: (a) scoping search and identification of programme theory; (b) evidence searching; (c) critical appraisal and data extraction; (d) organisation of evidence and (e) refinement of programme theory. Eligibility criteria Documents (including peer-reviewed articles, grey literature, websites, reports and conference papers) either full text, or a section of relevance to the overarching research question were included. Data sources EMBASE, Medline, Web of Science, Psych Info, Google and Google Scholar were searched iteratively between May and August 2020. Search strategy was refined for each database providing a broad enough review for building of programme theory. Analysis Data from eligible documents was extracted to build understanding of the factors that influence decision-making. Data were mapped to create a data matrix according to context (C), mechanism (M), outcome (O), configurations (C) (CMOCs) for the process of informed consent, to aid interpretation and produce final programme theory. Results 566 documents were screened and 71 included. Final programme theory was underpinned by CMOCs on processes influencing decisions to take part in research. Key findings indicate the type of infrastructure required, for example, resources, services and policies, to support inclusion in health research, with a greater need to increase the social presence of researchers within communities, improve cultural competency of individuals and organisations, reduce the complexity of participant information, and provide additional resources to support adaptive processes and shared decision making. Conclusion The review indicates the need for a more inclusive research infrastructure that facilitates diverse participation in health research through incorporating adaptive processes that support shared decision making within the informed consent process and in the conduct of research projects.

9 April 2021 in Systematic Reviews
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EHEleanor Hoverd
Eleanor Hoverd
SSSophie Staniszewska
Sophie Staniszewska
JDJeremy Dale
Jeremy Dale
Background: The informed consent process aims to provide potential participants with information about health research that enables them to make an informed decision as to whether they choose to participate, or not. However, it remains unclear as to whether the process is effective for those who are under-served in health research. It is a pivotal issue within health research that the diversity of people who participate is broadened. The National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) pledges to support equality, diversity and inclusion, actively creating opportunities for all citizens whom are eligible, to take part in health research.Methods: In order to understand how the informed consent process for under-served populations in health research works, under what circumstances and in what respects, a realist review approach will be undertaken. Searches will be carried out using electronic databases (EMBASE, MEDLINE, Web of Science and PsycINFO), along with selected websites and grey literature. Development of initial rough programme theory(ies) will lead to a more refined programme theory that will provide an explanation of context, mechanism and outcomes. Stakeholder involvement by NIHR (Public) Research Champions, health professionals and clinical academics will provide expert opinion about concepts and programme theory.Discussion: Findings of this realist review will highlight how the informed consent process in health research affects the experience and decision-making process of potential participants from under-served populations. They will be written up in accordance with RAMESES guidelines and disseminated to patients and the public, health researchers, health professionals and policymakers through peer-reviewed publication, presentations and discussions. The review will contribute to our understanding of the mechanisms that cause both positive and negative outcomes in the informed consent process for those whom are often under-represented in health research to inform policy, study design and delivery.

22 May 2025 in Health Expectations
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
EHEleanor Hoverd
Eleanor Hoverd
SSSophie Staniszewska
Sophie Staniszewska
JDJeremy Dale
Jeremy Dale
DEDawn Edge
Dawn Edge
RSRachel Spencer
Rachel Spencer
SWShane Ward
Shane Ward
Background: People from Black African Diaspora Communities (BAFDC) experience poorer health outcomes and are persistently under‐represented in health and care research. There is limited understanding about how to support their greater inclusion and participation. Objectives: Explore secondary data providing insights for the co‐development of a realist theory of inclusion and participation for people from BAFDC in health and care research in the United Kingdom. Drawing on these theories, co‐produce a realist review with a diverse range of people from BAFDC. Methods: A realist approach underpinned the study. Pawson's five steps to a realist approach were taken to shape the review, identify relevant sources, extract the data and then analyse and synthesise to inform an overarching programme theory. Initial programme theories (IPTs) were developed through context (C), mechanism (M), outcome (O) configurations (CMOCs). Main Results: The review identified 43 relevant documents. Synthesis of evidence from the documents resulted in 8 IPTs and 17 CMOCs helping to understand and explain the inclusion and participation of people from BAFDC. Four key thematic clusters emerged: (1) Health and care research as a White space, (2) Trust deficit: the expansiveness of broken trust, (3) Implicit and complicit bias and (4) Processes that affect inclusion and participation . Findings were underpinned by five existing mid‐range theories (MRTs) around central concepts of candidacy, social dominance, networks, narratives and racism that guided analysis and synthesis, supporting conceptualisation of CMOCs. An overarching programme theory was developed. Conclusion: The review identifies how the influence of perspectives, attitudes and beliefs held by individuals or groups about people from BAFDC operates in health and care research, resulting in exclusion, lack of trust and deficit thinking. The findings should be used to inform interventions aimed at increasing inclusion and participation of people from BAFDC. Patient or Public Contribution: The co‐production group comprised a diverse range of individuals from within the health and care research system with different lived experiences of being Black. They contributed to the entire review process, including the development of initial programme theories and retroductive thinking and interpretation of the evidence. Clinical Trial Registration: Not applicable.

29 March 2024 in BMJ Open
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EHEleanor Hoverd
Eleanor Hoverd
VEViolet Effiom
Violet Effiom
DGDionne Gravesande
Dionne Gravesande
LHLorna Hollowood
Lorna Hollowood
TKTony Kelly
Tony Kelly
SSSophie Staniszewska
Sophie Staniszewska
Introduction People from Black African Diaspora Communities (BAFDC) experience poorer health outcomes, have many long-term conditions and are persistently under-represented in health and care research. There is limited focus on programmes, or interventions that support inclusion and participation of people from BAFDC in research. Through coproduction, this realist review seeks to provide a programme theory explaining what context and mechanisms may be required, to produce outcomes that facilitate inclusion and participation for people from BAFDC in health and care research, in the UK. Methods and analysis A group of people from BAFDC with lived and professional experience, representing all levels of the health and care research system, will coproduce a realist review with a team of African-Caribbean, white British and white British of Polish origin health and care researchers. They will follow Pawson’s five steps: (1) shaping the scope of the review; (2) searching for evidence; (3) document selection and appraisal; (4) data extraction and (5) data synthesis. The coproduction group will help to map the current landscape, identifying key issues that may inhibit or facilitate inclusion. Data will be extracted, analysed and synthesised following realist logic analysis, identifying and explaining how context and mechanisms are conceptualised in the literature and the types of contextual factors that exist and impact on inclusion and participation. Findings will be reported in accordance with Realist and Meta-narrative Evidence Synthesis Evolving Standards . Ethics and dissemination The coproduction group will agree an ethical approach considering accountability, responsibility and power dynamics, by establishing a terms of reference, taking a reflexive approach and coproducing an ethical framework. Findings will be disseminated to BAFDC and the research community through arts-based methods, peer-reviewed publications and conference presentations, agreeing a coproduced strategy for dissemination. Ethical review is not required. PROSPERO registration number CRD42024517124.

16 February 2024 in Research Involvement and Engagement
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EHEleanor Hoverd
Eleanor Hoverd
SSSophie Staniszewska
Sophie Staniszewska
JDJeremy Dale
Jeremy Dale
RSRachel Spencer
Rachel Spencer
ADAnne Devrell
Anne Devrell
PSPam Smith
Pam Smith
Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPIE) should be embedded as part of researchers’ everyday practice. However, this can be challenging. Creating a digital presence for PPIE as part of Higher Education Institutes’ (HEIs) infrastructure may be one way of supporting this. This can support how information is made available to patients and members of the public, but relatively little is known about how HEIs can best do this. Our aim was to develop a university website for patients and members of the public to learn about ways to get actively involved in research and be able to access the results of health and social care research. This project involved working as partners with five National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Research Champions. NIHR Research Champions are volunteers who raise awareness and share experiences about health and social care research. Content of a prototype Patient Public Community Research Hub website was co-produced with the Research Champions, and then 15 NIHR Research Champions from across England were asked for their views about the website. The information collected told us that the Patient Public Community Research Hub was viewed as being beneficial for increasing visibility of PPIE opportunities and sharing the findings of studies though needs further work: to make the information more user-friendly; to improve the methods for directing people to the site and to create new ways of connecting with people. It provides a foundation for further co-development and evaluation. A set of recommendations has been developed that may be of benefit to other HEIs and organisations who are committed to working with patients and members of the public.