26 June 2017 in IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics, and Frequency Control
The attenuation coefficient slope (ACS) has the potential to be used for tissue characterization and as a diagnostic ultrasound tool, hence complementing B-mode images. The ACS can be valuable for the estimation of other ultrasound parameters such as the backscatter coefficient. There is a well-known tradeoff between the precision of the estimated ACS values and the data block size used in the spectral-based techniques such as the spectral-log difference (SLD). This tradeoff limits the practical usefulness of the spectral-based attenuation imaging techniques. In this paper, the regularized SLD (RSLD) technique is presented in detail, and evaluated with simulations and experiments with physical phantoms, ex vivo and in vivo. The RSLD technique allowed decreasing estimation variance when using small data block sizes, i.e., fivefold reduction in the standard deviation of percentage error when using data block sizes larger than 20λ × 20λ and more than a tenfold reduction when using 10λ × 10λ data blocks. The precision improvement was obtained without sacrificing estimation accuracy (i.e., estimation bias improved in 70% of the cases by 10% of the ground truth-value on average while degraded in 30% of the cases by 3% of the ground truth-value on average). The improvements in precision allowed for better differentiation of inclusions especially when using small data blocks (i.e., smaller than 20λ × 20λ) where the contrast-to-noise ratio improved by an order of magnitude on average. The results suggest that the RSLD allows for the reconstruction of attenuation coefficient images with an improved tradeoff between spatial resolution and estimation precision.
1 July 2019 in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
The backscatter coefficient (BSC) is a fundamental property of tissues and can be used to classify tissues. Two BSC calibration methods are the planar reflector method and the reference phantom method. In both methods, linear acoustic propagation is assumed. In this study, the calibration methods were evaluated when acoustic nonlinear distortion was present. Radio frequency data were acquired from two physical phantoms using a 5 MHz single-element transducer and low power (one excitation level) and high power (six increasing excitation levels) excitation signals. BSCs estimated from the high power settings were compared to the BSCs estimated using the low power by calculating the root mean square error (RMSE). The BSCs were parameterized by fitting the BSC curve to a power law and estimating the power law exponent and by estimating the effective scatterer diameter (ESD). When using the planar reflector method, estimates of the exponent were observed to monotonically increase in value versus increasing excitation level and the ESD decreased with increasing excitation level. The RMSE increased monotonically versus excitation level using the planar reflector method but did not increase using the reference phantom method. The results suggest that the effects of nonlinear distortion are minimized using the reference phantom method.
27 January 2021 in Ultrasonics
1 June 2022 in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
Tissue characterization based on the backscatter coefficient (BSC) can be degraded by acoustic nonlinearity. Often, this degradation is due to the method used for obtaining a reference spectrum, i.e., using a planar reference in water compared to a reference phantom approach resulted in more degradation. We hypothesize that an in situ calibration approach can improve BSC estimates in the nonlinear regime compared to using the reference phantom approach. The in situ calibration target provides a reference within the medium being interrogated and, therefore, nonlinear effects would already be contained in the in situ reference signal. Simulations and experiments in phantoms and in vivo were performed. A 2 mm diameter titanium bead was embedded in the interrogated media. An L9-4/38 probe (BK Ultrasound, Peabody, MA) and an analysis bandwidth from 4.5 to 7.4 MHz were used in experiments. Radiofrequency data from the sample, bead, and reference phantoms were acquired at a quasi-linear baseline power level and at further increments of output power. Better agreement between the BSC obtained at low power compared to high power was observed for the in situ calibration compared to the reference phantom approach.
1 August 2020 in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
The ultrasonic attenuation coefficient (ACE) can be used to classify tissue state. Pulse-echo spectral-based attenuation estimation techniques, such as the spectral-log-difference method (SLD), account for beam diffraction effects using a reference phantom having a sound speed close to the sound speed of the sample. Methods like SLD assume linear propagation of ultrasound and do not account for potential acoustic nonlinear distortion of the backscattered power spectra in both sample and reference. In this study, the ACE of a sample was computed and compared using the SLD with two independent references (high attenuating and low attenuating phantoms but with similar B/A values) and over several pressure levels. Both numerical and physical tissue-mimicking phantoms were used in the study. The results indicated that the biases in ACE increased when using a reference having low attenuation, whereas the high attenuating reference produced more consistent ACE. Furthermore, increments in ACE vs input pressure were correlated to the log-ratio of Gol'dberg numbers between the sample and reference ( in simulations and in experiments). Therefore, the results suggest that to reduce bias in ACE using spectral-based methods, both the sound speed and the Gol'dberg number of the reference phantom should be matched to the sample.