Intensification of U.S. livestock production, generating an estimated 1.4 billion tons per year of manure from nearly 10 billion animals, presents both a nutrient resource and an environmental challenge. This technical review synthesizes current knowledge on manure’s agronomic and soil health benefits versus its environmental risks. Examining conventional management practices, land application, stockpiling, lagoons, and critically assess advanced treatment and valorization technologies, including anaerobic digestion, solid–liquid separation, nutrient recovery (struvite precipitation, ammonia stripping), biochar co-composting, and precision application tools (injection, variable-rate spreading, real-time nutrient sensors). Adoption drivers such as regulatory frameworks (Clean Water Act CAFO permits, California SB 1383), economic incentives (EQIP cost-share, carbon and nutrient credit markets), and digital innovations are evaluated alongside persistent barriers of high capital costs, logistical constraints in nutrient transport, knowledge gaps in emission quantification (CH₄, N₂O, NH₃), pathogen fate, and site-specific trade-offs among air, water, and soil quality. We identify critical data deficiencies in national inventories of manure management systems, farm-level nutrient composition, and long-term field-scale outcomes. The review also outlines future scenarios, from incremental technology mainstreaming to integrated circular biorefineries and highlight research priorities to optimize manure as a circular resource while safeguarding ecosystem and human health. By contextualizing manure management within a climate-resilient, circular agricultural economy, this review identifies the research gaps and informs research, extension, and policy makers on strategies to advance sustainable livestock systems in the U.S. and beyond.