5 January 2024 in Nature Ecology & Evolution
1 June 2023 in Conservation Letters
Existing quantitative syntheses on how biodiversity responds to anthropogenic habitat change appear to sometimes mix different biodiversity metrics in drawing inferences. This “mixing metrics” practice, if prevalent, would considerably bias our understanding of biodiversity responses and render uninterpretable conclusions. However, the prevalence of this practice remains unknown, and the bias it potentially renders has not been empirically assessed. We fill this gap by conducting a systematic literature assessment of existing syntheses on biodiversity responses to habitat change, along with an analysis of a global database specifically on forest restoration. We found that the “mixing metrics” practice was used in almost a quarter of existing syntheses across a wide range of ecosystem and habitat change types. This practice predictably altered the quantitative, and frequently even the qualitative, inferences on biodiversity responses to forest restoration, in ways contingent on the composition of metrics mixed. We call on future syntheses to be cognizant of the difference in metric meaning and behaviors, and to avoid mixing different metrics in studying biodiversity responses to habitat change.
17 November 2023 in Environmental Research Letters
30 September 2026 in Nature Sustainability
Habitat restoration is a cornerstone of global climate and biodiversity policy, with over 350 million ha pledged for restoration by 2030, yet it remains unclear how restoration impacts ‘spill over’ beyond implementation areas. Restoration projects could lead to increased tree loss elsewhere (negative leakage; for example, when restoration replaces timber plantations and/or impacts landowner earnings) or reduced tree loss within project areas and surrounding landscapes (positive leakage; for example, if restoration meets timber or fuelwood resource needs or creates restoration-linked employment). Here we assembled a geospatial dataset of 129,982 restoration polygons (~6.8 million ha) across sub-Saharan Africa to evaluate changes in tree loss across space and time. Natural regeneration and active restoration reduced tree loss by up to 9.1 percentage points (pp) within restoration areas and 8.9 pp in 10 km buffers after 10 years, indicating positive leakage. By contrast, agroforestry increased tree loss by 7.9 pp within projects and 7.5 pp in surrounding landscapes. Leakage magnitude and direction varied across restoration approaches and countries (−7.8 pp to +7.1 pp), underscoring the need for context-specific strategies. Integrating leakage safeguards into restoration planning, carbon standards and incentive schemes is essential for securing landscape-scale climate and biodiversity-related benefits.