Forest restoration is being scaled up globally to deliver critical ecosystem services and biodiversity benefits; however, there is a lack of rigorous comparison of cobenefit delivery across different restoration approaches. Through global synthesis, we used 25,950 matched data pairs from 264 studies in 53 countries to assess how delivery of climate, soil, water, and wood production services, in addition to biodiversity, compares across a range of tree plantations and native forests. Benefits of aboveground carbon storage, water provisioning, and especially soil erosion control and biodiversity are better delivered by native forests, with compositionally simpler, younger plantations in drier regions performing particularly poorly. However, plantations exhibit an advantage in wood production. These results underscore important trade-offs among environmental and production goals that policy-makers must navigate in meeting forest restoration commitments.
25 September 2022 in Agricultural and Forest Meteorology
Asbjornsen, H., R. Manson, J. Scullion, F. Holwerda, L. E. Munoz-Villers, M. Alvarado-Barrientos, D. Geissert, T. E. Dawson, J. J. McDonnell, and L. Adrian Bruijnzeel. 2017. Interactions between payments for hydrologic services, landowner decisions, and ecohydrological consequences: synergies and disconnection in the cloud forest zone of central Veracruz, Mexico. Ecology and Society 22(2):25. https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-09144-220225
Reforestation of degraded grasslands can increase the soil hydraulic conductivity and number of preferential flow pathways. However, it is not clear to what extent these changes affect streamflow responses and whether this depends on the event size. We, therefore, studied the hydrological response of two small catchments near Tacloban, Leyte (the Philippines): a degraded Imperata grassland catchment and a catchment that was reforested 23 years prior to our study. Precipitation, stream stage, and electrical conductivity were measured continuously from June to November 2013. Samples were taken from streamflow, precipitation, groundwater, and soil water for geochemical and stable isotope analyses. Streamflow and electrical conductivity changed rapidly during almost every event in the grassland catchment, but in the reforested catchment, these responses were much smaller and only occurred during large events. Streamflow was a mixture of groundwater and precipitation for both catchments, but the maximum event water contributions to streamflow were much larger for the degraded grassland than for the reforested catchment. The differences in the event water contributions and timing of the streamflow responses were observed across all event sizes, including a large tropical storm. Together with the low saturated hydraulic conductivity in the degraded catchment, these results suggest that overland flow occurred more frequently and was much more widespread in the degraded grassland than in the reforested catchment. We, therefore, conclude that reforestation of a degraded grassland can change the dominant flow pathways and restore the hydrological functioning if the forest soil is allowed to develop over a sufficiently long period.
Predicting catchment stormflow responses after tropical deforestation remains difficult. We used 5‐min rainfall and storm runoff data for 30 events to calibrate the Green–Ampt (GA) and the Spatially Variable Infiltration (SVI) models and predict runoff responses for a small, degraded grassland catchment on Leyte Island (the Philippines), where infiltration‐excess overland flow (IOF) is considered the dominant runoff process. SVI replicated individual stormflow hydrographs better than GA, particularly for events with small runoff responses or multiple peaks. Calibrated parameter values of the SVI model (i.e., spatially averaged maximum infiltration capacity, Im and initial abstraction, F0) varied markedly between events, but were statistically significant and negatively correlated with (mid‐slope) soil moisture content at 10 cm (SWC10)—as did the “catchment‐wide effective” hydraulic conductivity (Ke) of the GA model. Using SWC10‐based estimates of F0 and Im in SVI yielded satisfactory to good simulations for 11 out of 17 events with runoff coefficients ≥15%, but failed to reproduce the hydrographs for events with very small runoff amounts (0.25–1 mm) and low runoff coefficients (3%–6%). The median field‐measured near‐surface Ksat (2 mm hr−1) was distinctly lower than the median Im (32 mm hr−1) and, to a lesser extent, Ke (∼8 mm hr−1), suggesting an underestimation of the spatially averaged Ksat by the field measurements. Application of SVI is expected to give the most realistic results for situations where IOF is dominant, that is, where surface conditions are degraded and rainfall intensities high.
Slash‐and‐burn agriculture is an important driver of tropical forest loss and typically results in a mosaic of land uses. However, there is little quantitative information about the hydrological effects of long‐term slash‐and‐burn agriculture and how such mosaics affect the rainfall‐runoff response at the catchment scale. We monitored streamflow responses at two points along a perennial stream in a 31.7 ha catchment in eastern Madagascar that was monitored previously between 1963 and 1972. Land cover in 2015 consisted of degraded grasslands, shrub and tree fallows at various stages of regrowth (64%), eucalypt stands for charcoal production (30%), and rice paddies and wetlands in the valley‐bottom (3%). For the majority (60%) of the events during the study period, the ratio between the total amount of stormflow and rainfall was <3%, suggesting that for these events runoff was generated in the valley‐bottom only. Events for which an antecedent soil moisture storage plus rainfall (ASI + P) threshold was exceeded had much higher stormflow ratios (up to 50%), indicating that a certain wetness was required for the hillslopes to contribute to stormflow. Stable isotope sampling for four small to moderate events indicated that stormflow was dominated by pre‐event water. Total stormflow and annual water yield in 2015 were higher than in the 1960s, despite much lower rainfall in 2015. We attribute these differences to changes in soil physical properties caused by the repeated burning and loss of top‐soil, which has resulted in a reduction in the depth to the impeding layer. The changed runoff‐processes (less infiltration, more saturation‐excess overland flow) thus affect local water resources.