While Internet voting is argued to have the potential to improve election processes, concerns about security risks remain one of its main adoption barriers. These concerns are furthermore aggravated by the lack oftransparencyof Internet voting systems that are often perceived as a “black box”. Moreover, there is a research gap in conceptualizing the idea of transparency and in studying voters’ attitudes towards transparency in Internet voting. In this work, we aim to address this gap by (1) Conducting a systematic literature review, from which we identified five dimensions of transparency; (2) Developing a questionnaire (Transparency Dimensions of Internet Voting, TDIV) to assess voters’ attitudes regarding the correlation of these dimensions with transparency; and (3) Conducting an online study (N = 500) to investigate voters’ attitudes towards transparency in Internet voting. We conclude that providing information about the security of the Internet voting system; testing it by independent experts for security vulnerabilities prior to the election; monitoring the election process and verifying its integrity; and providing a remedy for security breaches while holding the responsible parties accountable, are perceived by voters as important, and enhance transparency in Internet voting systems.
A lack of transparency in internet voting systems – in particular, how the integrity of the election result is ensured – has been commonly mentioned as one of the main barriers to its adoption. We conduct an empirical study (N = 940) evaluating the factors affecting the voters’ perception of transparency and trust in an internet voting system. Thereby, we adopt a proposal from prior research that conceptualizes transparency as consisting of several individual dimensions. Our study shows that the transparency dimensions of information availability, understandability, and verifiability have a significant positive effect on voters’ perception towards the general transparency of the voting system, and also that transparency has a positive effect on trust in the system. In addition, we investigate how the information presented about the system and the procedures available to voters for verifying the integrity of their cast vote affects voters’ perception of transparency and trust in the system. We find that providing technical documentation about the system significantly increases perceived transparency and trust. We conclude that while such information is unlikely to be understood by most voters, it effectively signals the possibility of expert audits of the system.