Accurate fatigue-life prediction under variable-amplitude loading (VAL) is critical for damage-tolerance assessment. This study presents a systematic comparative analysis of experimental data and numerical predictions of crack propagation in SAE-AMS 7475-T7351 alloy. NASGRO, AFGROW, and CRACK 2000 were employed to simulate standardized spectra (TWIST, FALSTAFF) and an actual commercial aeronautical load history, focusing on the calibration of Wheeler, GW, and MGW retardation models. The results demonstrate that calibration parameters (e.g., Rso) are highly spectrum-dependent. Physical analysis revealed that underloads attenuate retardation in the TWIST spectrum but are ineffective in the FALSTAFF spectrum. Discrepancies between the software packages, even with identical parameters, were attributed to varying ΔKth implementations.