We report a new interlaboratory exercise to evaluate the reproducibility of apatite fission‐track (AFT) and (U‐Th)/He (AHe) data and thermal history analysis. Twelve laboratory groups participated, analyzing apatite separates from two previously studied localities. Ten groups returned AFT data from 13 analysts, five groups returned AHe data, one contributed apatite U/Pb data, and nine contributed thermal history models. Submitted AFT age data were generally consistent with the original studies and each other to within uncertainties, although there were departures, particularly among results obtained using laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry for uranium determination. AFT‐confined track‐length data showed more variation, which correlated between samples, suggesting that they may reflect analyst‐specific factors. Accounting for anisotropy using c axis projection reduced the variation and correlation. AHe ages showed more dispersion than observed in the previous studies, with one sample showing many ages consistent with prior work but also many significantly older ages, and the other roughly matching prior work but showing symmetrical scatter suggesting a 1SE uncertainty of 17–21%. Thermal history models generally agreed in their major features but showed considerable variation in detail, due to differences in data and data entry, model setup, and modeling software approach. Addressing pitfalls in data entry and model setup improved congruence, as would greater emphasis on AFT length and etch figure calibration. Because of scatter, AHe data had to be entered selectively into the models to achieve reasonable results. Although cautionary in several respects, study results point to promising avenues for improving the reproducibility of thermal history modeling.
Deformation in intraplate domains is usually considered as a consequence of tectonic events at plate boundaries. Nevertheless, the occurrence of intraplate earthquakes such as the recent Le Teil event in the south of France along the Cévennes Fault System (CFS), on 11 November 2019, Mw = 4.9, questions whether this far-field deformation only occurs during tectonic pulses at plate boundaries, or if it corresponds to low-intensity but regional continuous deformation through time. To address this question, we have coupled U–Pb geochronology of fault-related calcites with structural analysis along a major fault system (the CFS) in the South-East Basin, France. We evidence (1) an Albian activity of the CFS and (2) a continuous compressional activity of the CFS and satellite structures during the whole Eocene and probably during the Late Cretaceous – Palaeocene, including periods (e.g. Lutetian) usually considered as phases of tectonic quiescence. We thus demonstrate that the tectonic reactivation of this intraplate fault system is not restricted to periods of high rates of deformation at plate boundaries.
The preservation of reservoir quality in deeply buried sandstones largely depends on the presence of grain-coating clays that can inhibit quartz overgrowth and cementation. These grain-coating clays are the focus of today’s hydrocarbon exploration as they enable new oil and gas discoveries in sedimentary basins. However, the origin and distribution of these clays in turbidites are poorly documented in scientific literature. Our study addresses this knowledge gap by investigating the mechanisms and parameters governing the clay coat development in turbidite sandstones, with a focus on the Agat Formation (Fm) in the Norwegian North Sea. Petrographic observations, scanning electron microscopy, and X-ray diffraction analyses were used to identify the origin of clay minerals and their distribution, as well as to understand the diagenetic evolution of the sandstone and its impact on reservoir quality. Based on the sedimentary facies description, the Agat Fm comprises four principal members deposited in various depositional environments, ranging from distal lobe fringe to amalgamated proximal lobes and weakly confined channels. Chlorite and kaolinite are the main authigenic clay minerals in these sandstones, associated with a variable amount of inherited detrital clays consisting in Fe-bearing kaolinite and mixed-layer minerals composed of illite and hydroxyl-interlayered clay minerals formed in acidic soil environments. Well-developed chlorite coats are associated with the highest reservoir quality (φ > 10%), while discontinuous chlorite coats are linked to extensive quartz cementation and poor reservoir quality (φ < 5%). Samples with abundant pore-filling chlorite also exhibit poor reservoir quality (φ < 7%). Proximal lobe deposits and weakly confined channels show well-developed chlorite coats, whereas discontinuous chlorite coats are mainly found in proximal lobe deposits associated with high velocity escaping fluids during dewatering. Pore-filling chlorites are typically present in distal lobe fringes and levee deposits. Chlorite in the Agat Fm is mainly derived from the replacement of inherited detrital clays via an intermediate berthierine precursor forming during early diagenesis. The dissolution of Fe-rich grains such as biotite and ferric detrital clays under reducing conditions governed the kinetics of berthierine/chlorite growth. The late diagenesis is characterized by extensive feldspar dissolution in a closed diagenetic system, leading to the precipitation of kaolinite and quartz cement. The presence of chlorite coatings around detrital grains preserved the porosity from extensive quartz cementation during deep burial, highlighting the role of chlorite in maintaining the quality of deeply buried turbidite reservoirs.