Unlike conventional polycrystalline alloys, Cu-Al-Ni single crystals exhibit brittleness under quasi-static loading. They show no conventional plasticity and fracture after martensite reorientation. This study demonstrates that the mechanical behavior of a single-crystal Cu-Al-Ni shape memory alloy produced by the Stepanov method is highly sensitive to strain rate. High-strain-rate loading of a Cu-Al-Ni single crystal specimen, conducted using the Split Hopkinson Pressure Bar technique, activates a previously unobserved deformation mechanism that produces significant irreversible plastic-like strain, which is absent under quasi-static conditions. Despite substantial deformation, the material retains its shape memory functionality and exhibits superior recovery strain compared to a reference TiNi shape memory alloy. The formation of a scaly surface structure and internal features resembling slip bands under dynamic loading indicates the activation of a unique plasticity mechanism. Thus, Cu-Al-Ni single crystals undergo a fundamental transition from brittle to plastic-like behavior under high-strain-rate loading, while retaining a superior shape memory effect.