It has been posited that US national forest administration is undergoing a governance transition characterized by an increase in the involvement and influence of non-state actors. One example of this new form of national forest governance is the use of multi-stakeholder collaborative efforts for planning and implementing projects. This has raised normative and positive questions about the value and effectiveness of such efforts and how they compare with more traditional public involvement and planning processes. This study attempts to address the latter questions by analyzing project-level planning and implementation data while comparing collaborative and traditional projects on a suite of metrics related to pace, scale, complexity, and legal outcomes. We used administrative data from the USDA Forest Service to conduct a quantitative analysis of projects over a 14-year period. We found that collaboratively developed projects were larger and more complex than traditional projects and were associated with greater planning efficiency. This analysis responds to the need to systematically assess the impact of collaborative governance and contributes to existing theories of governance, organizational learning, and policy implementation.
The number and size of wildfires in the western United States have increased dramatically in the last 30 years. The rising cost of wildfire suppression has become a significant concern for all levels of government, although most attention has been focused on the federal level. Much less is known about the financial impact of expenditures on states, which retain responsibility for suppression on over 480 million acres of state and private forests. This study collected data on state expenditures for wildfire suppression in the western United States from 2005 to 2015 to examine fiscal burdens and compare funding mechanisms used to cover those costs. Our analysis finds that western states expended $11.9 billion on wildfire suppression over the 11-year period and used own-source funds to cover 88 percent of these costs. States displayed a variety of mechanisms for covering their cost obligations with tradeoffs that may affect non-wildfire policy priorities.
This study explores the role of front-line workers in collaborative environmental management. Using an institutional work lens and actor narratives, we reveal how collaborative institutions are created, modified and disrupted amidst conflicting logics. The results indicate that government actors engage in critical institution-building and boundary spanning practices that create opportunities for citizen influence, demonstrate responsiveness, fill institutional voids and overcome organizational barriers. These findings suggest that attention to the routines and practices of street-level bureaucrats is critical for understanding and theorizing the connection between governance design and outcomes and have important implications for the study of institutional and organizational change.
Accurate information on the movement and utilization of timber sold by the USDA Forest Service (Forest Service) has historically been difficult to access. Such data have useful applications in the appraisal process, for estimating the location and size of economic impacts to people and communities and for planning management actions. There is some evidence that agency utilization definitions lag improvements in industry utilization practices leading to a discrepancy between administratively determined uses and actual uses of timber sold. Furthermore, the relationship between the origin of harvested wood and the location of processing are increasingly important in the context of climate and clean energy policies as many rely on quantification of the greenhouse gas emissions from the harvest, transport and use of wood for various end products. In this study we compare available data on timber harvested from Forest Service administrative reports with mill-reported uses of federal timber collected by USDA Forest Service Research & Development’s National Resource Use Monitoring program in order to demonstrate a method for estimating national forest timber movement and utilization “signatures”.
20 January 2026 in Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism