Molecular dynamics simulations model chemical reactions as continuous changes in molecular structure over time instead of static minima and transition states. This perspective argues that time-dependent structural change is a crucial, but often overlooked, mechanistic feature as many reactions simply do not follow a single, equilibrated minimum-energy path. We highlight examples where traditional transition state theory fails, typically cases involving short-lived intermediates, nonequilibrium solvation, momentum-controlled selectivity, post-transition state bifurcations, and "hidden" dynamic intermediates and show how molecular dynamics can reveal the actual sequence of structural change which governs a reaction outcome. We also discuss emerging machine learning-based molecular dynamics which have found applications in photochemistry and solvent modeling. While molecular dynamics will not replace methods based on transition state theory, it offers organic chemists a time-resolved view of molecular structure which can be crucial to understanding a given reaction. However, a central barrier for organic chemists is to understand when and why to apply an advanced computational technique such as molecular dynamics simulations. In this perspective, we aim to introduce the methodology in sufficient detail to enable organic chemists to make this assessment and gain an appreciation for the importance of time in reaction mechanisms.
25 June 2025 in The Journal of Physical Chemistry A
Photoredox catalysis enables chemical reactions under mild reaction conditions; single-electron transfer is a common key step. Quantum mechanical calculations has accelerated the increasing numbers of photoredox catalysts because of its straightforward implementation in many softwares. Unfortunately, computing the redox potentials of molecular excited states is difficult. While density functional theory (DFT) offers a cost-effective way to compute ground- and excited-state redox potentials, a benchmarking study identifying the best density functional has not yet been conducted. In this report, we evaluate 147 combinations of density functionals and basis sets (i.e., model chemistries) to compute the S0, S1, and T1 reduction and oxidation potentials for nine organic photoredox catalysts (cyanoarenes, benzophenones, xanthenes, and acridinium) with experimentally determined ground- and excited-state redox potentials. We provide recommendations for predicting ground- and excited-state reduction and oxidation potentials. We find that the best model chemistry for excited-state reduction and oxidation potentials, with PBE0-D3BJ/6-311+G(d,p) and N12-SX/6-311+G(d,p) excelling for S1 states and ωB97X/6-311+G(d,p) and BHandH/6-311+G(d,p) perform best for T1 states. Guidance is provided for balancing accuracy and CPU time, especially for T1 and S1 redox potentials.
6 October 2025 in Beilstein Journal of Organic Chemistry
Photochemical denitrogenation reactions of bicyclic azoalkanes produce strained bicyclic compounds of interest to synthetic organic chemists. We report a computational study on the mechanism of diazabicyclo[2.2.1]heptenes to address long standing mechanistic questions. Indeed, the mechanism of these reactions has been disputed for over six decades. We employed non-adiabatic molecular dynamics (NAMD) simulations combined with state-of-the-art multireference quantum mechanical calculations to understand the photophysical properties and mechanisms of these diazabicyclo[2.2.1]heptenes. The energetically accessible lowest excitations are nNN(σCN) → π* and range from 3.94–3.97 eV. From the >292 trajectories, the reaction proceeds through a dynamically concerted but asynchronous denitrogenation reaction. One σCN bond breaks along the S1 surface; the other σCN breaks after hopping to the S0. We identified two clusters of S₁/S₀ surface hopping points from these trajectories. In the first cluster, the methylene bridge is fully inverted relative to the reactant geometry. In the second cluster, the inversion is only partial, with one of the carbon atoms in the methylene bridge inverted relative to the reactant. We identified each cluster's corresponding minimum energy conical intersection (MECI), indicating at least two possible S1/S0-MECIs. Our dynamics simulations illustrate that inversion begins in the excited state immediately after the first σCN bond breaks. This inversion is driven by the atomic momenta acquired after the bond breaks. These dynamical effects promote the formation of the inverted housane, thereby explaining the observed selectivities. A minority of trajectories undergo thermal conversion in the ground state, producing the minor retained housane product from inverted housane/diradical.
The development of graph neural networks for predicting molecular properties has garnered significant attention, as it enables the correlation of quickly computable atomic and bond descriptors with overall molecular properties. With the rising interest in photochemistry and photocatalysis as sustainable alternatives to thermal reactions, curation of virtual databases of computed photophysical properties for training of machine learning models has become popular. Unfortunately, current efforts fail to consider the exciton localization onto different chromophores of the same molecule, leading to potentially large prediction errors. Here we describe a molecular fragmentation strategy that can be used to overcome this limitation, while also providing a way to compare structural diversity between different libraries. Using a newly generated database of 46 432 adiabatic S0–T1 energy gaps (ALFAST-DB), we compare its diversity with two datasets from the literature and demonstrate that a fragment-based delta learning approach improves model generalizability while achieving accuracies comparable to those of traditional message passing graph neural network architectures (MPGNN).
Molecular dynamics simulations model chemical reactions as continuous changes in molecular structure over time in-stead of static minima and transition states. This perspective argues that time-dependent structural change is a crucial, but often overlooked, mechanistic feature as many reactions simply do not follow a single, equilibrated minimum-energy path. We highlight examples where traditional transition state theory fails, typically cases involving short-lived interme-diates, non-equilibrium solvation, momentum-controlled selectivity, post-transition state bifurcations, and “hidden” dy-namic intermediates and show how molecular dynamics can reveal the actual sequence of structural change which gov-erns a reaction outcome. We also discuss emerging machine learning-based molecular dynamics which have found appli-cations in photochemistry and solvent modelling. While molecular dynamics will not replace methods based on transi-tion state theory, it offers organic chemists a time-resolved view of molecular structure which can be crucial to under-standing a given reaction. However, a central barrier for organic chemists is to understand when and why to apply an ad-vanced computational technique such as molecular dynamics simulations. In this perspective, we aim to introduce the methodology in sufficient detail to enable organic chemists to make this assessment and gain an appreciation for the im-portance of time in reaction mechanisms.