This research examines the impact of entrepreneurial skills on the sustainable performance of homestay businesses in Terengganu, Malaysia. Despite the recognised significance of entrepreneurial competencies for business success, research on their impact on sustainable performance in homestays remains limited. The research examines how entrepreneurs’ skills, knowledge, and attitudes contribute to their sustainable business performance. The research employed a quantitative approach and purposive sampling to analyse 102 completed questionnaires using Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modelling (PLS-SEM). The results revealed an unexpected outcome: While a positive attitude towards sustainability significantly influenced sustainable performance, entrepreneurial skills and knowledge did not directly impact it. These findings challenge the conventional understanding of entrepreneurial competencies, emphasising the critical role of attitude in driving sustainable performance. The study suggests that technical skills and knowledge are essential. However, they may not directly translate into sustainable performance. Hence, the study underscores the need for further research to explore contextual factors influencing the relationship between competencies and sustainable performance in homestays. These insights have crucial implications for entrepreneurial development programmes and policies in the tourism sector, particularly in fostering sustainable business practices.