Health-oriented food choices are increasingly important to health economics, public health policy, and preventive health management because dietary markets influence individual well-being, access to healthier products, and the societal costs of unsustainable consumption. Existing scholarship provides insufficient evidence on whether private health motives, ecological attitudes, ingredient scrutiny, expectations of responsible producers, and perceived market constraints play different roles in the adoption and regularity of organic consumption. The study evaluates the behavioral and market factors associated with becoming an organic-food consumer and moving towards more frequent consumption. Evidence was obtained from a Polish-language internet questionnaire administered during May 2024 to 91 participants, comprising 71 consumers, 19 non-consumers, and one unclassified respondent; women represented 62.6%, and 60.4% were aged 19–25 years. The empirical design integrated frequency summaries, multiple-response assessment, scale reliability diagnostics, a paired Wilcoxon signed-rank procedure, Spearman rank associations, cumulative ordinal logistic modeling, binary logistic modeling, Firth bias-reduced estimation, and 5,000 case-resampling replications, implemented in RStudio using R version 4.4.0 (4.4.0). Organic products were consumed at least several times monthly by 65.6% of respondents with valid classifications, whereas 21.1% reported no consumption; health motivation averaged 4.32 compared with 3.55 for ecological motivation, and the paired test yielded 767.5, a statistical probability below one-thousandth and a rank-biserial correlation of 0.783. Affordability emerged as the principal market-access concern: 76.4% identified high prices as a barrier; the price-reduction measure averaged 4.51 points; and promotion, labeling, availability, and assortment formed a coherent facilitation scale with a reliability coefficient of 0.76. In the main ordinal specification, support for environmentally responsible producer conduct multiplied the likelihood of entering a higher consumption category by 3.30; confidence limits at 95 per cent extended between 1.30 and 8.37, with statistical probability equal to 0.012, while the bias-reduced binary model additionally linked ingredient scrutiny to consumer status by a factor of 1.85, bounded between 1.08 and 3.36 at the 95 per cent level, with statistical probability equal to 0.025. These results support health-policy and health-management initiatives that combine affordability, credible certification, accessible retail provision, and producer accountability, while future inquiry using larger probability-based panels should assess whether such interventions reduce barriers to healthier, environmentally sustainable diets.