Background: During the immediate outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic, burnout symptoms increased among healthcare workers. Knowledge is needed on how early symptoms developed during the persistent crisis that followed the first pandemic wave. Aims: To investigate if high levels of burnout symptoms during the first pandemic wave led to high burnout and depressive symptoms up to a year later, and if participation in psychological support was related to lower levels of symptoms. Methods: A longitudinal case–control study followed 581 healthcare workers from two Swedish hospitals. Survey data were collected with a baseline in May 2020 and three follow-up assessments until September 2021. The case group was participants reporting high burnout symptoms at baseline. Logistic regression analyses were performed separately at three follow-ups with case–control group assignment as the main predictor and burnout and depression symptoms as outcomes, controlling for frontline work, changes in work tasks and psychological support participation. Results: One out of five healthcare workers reported high burnout symptoms at baseline. The case group was more likely to have high burnout and depressive symptoms at all follow-ups. Participation in psychological support was unrelated to decreased burnout and depressive symptoms at any of the follow-ups. Conclusions: During a persistent crisis, healthcare organizations should be mindful of psychological reactions among staff and who they place in frontline work early in the crisis. To better prepare for future healthcare crises, preventive measures on burnout are needed, both at workplaces and as part of the curricula in medical and nursing education.
Objectives A range of interventions to support psychological resilience among healthcare workers were provided in hospitals during the COVID-19 pandemic. Most research has focused on the content and experience of these interventions, but less is known about their implementation. The aim of this study was to increase understanding of the development, implementation and perceived usefulness of an intervention to support psychological resilience among healthcare workers at a Swedish hospital during the pandemic. Design This study employs interviews and documents to explore the development and implementation of support activities and a survey to assess the usefulness of the activities (on a scale from 1 to 5). Qualitative content analysis was used to analyse the interview data and documents. Descriptive statistics were used to analyse the survey data. Settings A tertiary hospital in the outskirts of Region Stockholm. Participants Eight individual interviews were conducted with actors involved in developing the intervention. 286 healthcare workers answered the survey. Results Support activities were developed and implemented by an internal multidisciplinary group who continuously identified and adapted activities to the needs of staff. The strategy of involving existing resources to jointly develop and continuously adapt staff support activities was beneficial for the implementation and longevity of the intervention. Scheduling difficulties were one of the challenges. The mean ratings of the activities ranged from 2.27 for one-on-one counselling to 3.25 for physical activity. Licensed practical nurses generally valued the activities higher than other professional groups. Conclusions The provision of activities to support psychological resilience in a crisis is facilitated by the ability of an organisation to use current resources in the face of a crisis, which is a sign of organisational resilience. Leaders who act quickly and create the conditions to test and learn under uncertainty can contribute to developing effective responses to a crisis.
Objectives: This study aimed to investigate if high levels of burnout symptoms during the first wave of the Covid-19 pandemic led to high burnout and depressive symptoms up to a year later, and if participation in psychological support initiatives was related to lower levels of burnout or depressive symptoms across the first year of the pandemic.Methods: A longitudinal case-control study followed 581 healthcare workers from two Swedish hospitals. Survey data were collected with a baseline in May 2020 and three follow-up assessments until September 2021. The case group were participants reporting high burnout symptoms at baseline. Logistic regression analyses were performed separately at three follow-ups with case/control group assignment as the main predictor and burnout and depression symptoms as outcomes, controlling for frontline work, changes in work tasks, and participation in psychological support. Results: One out of five healthcare workers reported high burnout symptoms at baseline. The case group was more likely to have high burnout and depression symptoms at all follow-ups. Participation in psychological support was not related to decreased burnout and depressive symptoms at any of the follow-ups.Conclusion: Burnout symptoms early in the pandemic predicted both high burnout and depressive symptoms later in the crisis. During a persistent crisis when job demands are high, healthcare organizations should be mindful of psychological reactions among staff and who they place in frontline work early in the crisis.
14 February 2024 in Scandinavian Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology
During a crisis, there is limited time to plan support initiatives for healthcare workers and few resources available to ensure that they engage with them. Using the context of the recent COVID-19 pandemic, this study aimed to investigate help-seeking behaviors among healthcare workers in relation to psychological support initiatives offered to them. Data from a Swedish longitudinal survey following healthcare workers from early (N = 681) to mid-pandemic (N = 396) were analyzed using latent class and transition analyses. We found three patterns of healthcare workers’ help-seeking behavior that applied to both time points: (1) engaging with different forms of group-based support, (2) not participating in any kind of offered support, and (3) only having been offered information-based support. The availability of support declined during the mid-pandemic. Group support users were primarily nurses and frontline workers, with higher levels of burnout symptoms. Our findings suggest that healthcare organizations should limit their implementation of psychological support during a crisis to a few key formats based on social support. Promoting participation from all staff groups may enhance the inclusivity, effectiveness, and sustainability of the support.
Elevated psychological stress reactions among healthcare workers during the COVID‐19 pandemic necessitated a need to better understand their possible impact on sickness absence (SA). The study aimed to describe the relation between SA related to mental health problems and symptoms of psychological stress among healthcare workers during the COVID‐19 pandemic. We further aimed to identify whether latent profiles of psychological stress reactions exist within the same population. In this observational registry‐based study, survey data between May 2020 and March 2021 and SA register data between May 2019 and February 2023 were collected from 1245 Swedish healthcare workers. Differences between symptoms of burnout, depression, anxiety, PTSD, sleep disturbance, lack of detachment, and lack of recovery among groups with no, few (< 90), or many (≥ 90) SA days were analyzed with Kruskal‐Wallis tests. Interrelations between symptoms of psychological stress were identified using latent profile analysis. Compared to healthy participants, participants with SA days (in total 6.3%) reported more severe symptoms of psychological stress, were younger, and more likely to work as assistant nurses. Furthermore, they displayed a higher degree of previous SA (prior to the pandemic). No statistically significant differences between groups with few (< 90) and many (≥ 90) days of SA in symptoms were noted. Four latent profiles of psychological stress were identified, but they differed only in the level of experienced symptoms. We conclude that different symptoms of psychological stress are highly interrelated among healthcare workers during a crisis. Although many healthcare workers may experience elevated symptoms in relation to the crisis, it will not necessarily lead to serious mental health problems requiring SA.
The resource saving bias is a cognitive bias describing how resource savings from improvements of high-productivity units are overestimated compared to improvements of less productive units. Motivational reasoning describes how attitudes, here towards private/public health care, distort decisions based on numerical facts. Participants made a choice between two productivity increase options with the goal of saving doctor resources. The options described productivity increases in low-/high-productivity private/public emergency rooms. Jointly, the biases produced 78% incorrect decisions. The cognitive bias was stronger than the motivational bias. Verbal justifications of the decisions revealed elaborations of the problem beyond the information provided, biased integration of quantitative information, change of goal of decision, and motivational attitude biases. Most (83%) of the incorrect decisions were based on (incorrect) mathematical justifications illustrating the resource saving bias. Participants who had better scores on a cognitive test made poorer decisions. Women who gave qualitative justifications to a greater extent than men made more correct decision. After a first decision, participants were informed about the correct decision with a mathematical explanation. Only 6.3% of the participants corrected their decisions after information illustrating facts resistance. This could be explained by psychological sunk cost and coherence theories. Those who made the wrong choice remembered the facts of the problem better than those who made a correct choice.