Essential oils (EOs) and nature identical compounds (NICs) were investigated as potential antimicrobials. They were challenged against livestock pathogens responsible for huge economic losses and impaired animal welfare. Eight EOs (tea tree, mint, oregano, cinnamon, thyme, clove bud, lavender, and rosemary), and five NICs (carvacrol, cinnamic aldehyde, terpineol, thymol, and menthol) were tested on E. coli, S. Typhimurium, S. aureus and MRSA in association with polysorbates (Tween 20 and Tween 80) as potential emulsifiers for subsequent oral administration. Variations of their activity were also evaluated over time. Generally, EOs showed very low Minimal Inibitory Concentration (MIC; values < 0.2% for oregano and thyme oils), with even lower MIC values when combined with Tween 20 at 0.5%, while Tween 80 proved to be less effective. However, a strong reduction in EOs efficacy was observed during storage, except for cinnamon oil, which improved its antimicrobial activity over time against all the tested bacteria. Conversely, NICs displayed antimicrobial stability over time, showing very low MIC values for cinnamic aldehyde, carvacrol, and thymol. Both EOs and NICs combined with Tween 20 at different concentrations resulted in effective emulsions, which could be administrated via feed to food-producing animals. The NICs showed dose-dependent cytotoxicity, limiting their potential in vivo administration.The EOs and NICs tested are effective antimicrobials. Their combinations with Tween 20 does not impair the antimicrobial activity facilitating their dietary inclusion. Further studies on EOs and NICs application as feed additives are needed to implement their suitability in vivo on livestock animals.