Significance: Blooms of cyanobacteria in lakes and reservoirs cause fish kills and pose toxicity risk for humans, livestock, and wildlife. Theory suggests that blooms may be anticipated in advance by calculating resilience indicators using high-frequency observations of pigments in lake water. However, it is not known whether management can prevent blooms once indicators are detected. We measured these indicators while gradually enriching a lake until a bloom was triggered. When indicators passed a preset threshold, nutrient input was stopped. This action reversed the bloom, showing that monitoring of resilience indicators followed by prompt action when limits are exceeded can be useful in management. However, in practice, the risk of blooms may best be prevented by reducing inputs of nutrients.