21 April 2021 in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
In this experimental study, multiscale rough surfaces with regular (cuboid) elements are used to examine the effects of roughness-scale hierarchy on turbulent boundary layers. Three iterations have been used with a first iteration of large-scale cuboids onto which subsequent smaller cuboids are uniformly added, with their size decreasing with a power-law as the number increases. The drag is directly measured through a floating-element drag balance, while particle image velocimetry allowed the assessment of the flow field. The drag measurements revealed the smallest roughness iteration can contribute to nearly 7 (at the highest Reynolds number tested). It is shown that the aerodynamic roughness length scale between subsequent iterations varies linearly, and can be described with a geometrical parameter proportional to the frontal solidity. Mean and turbulent statistics are evaluated using the drag information, and highlighted substantial changes within the canopy region as well as in the outer flow, with modifications to the inertial sublayer (ISL) and the wake region. These changes are shown to be caused by the presence of large-scale secondary motions in the cross-plane, which itself is believed to be a consequence of the largest multiscale roughness phase (spacing between largest cuboids), shown to be of the same order of magnitude as the boundary-layer thickness. Implications on the classical similarity laws are additionally discussed.
1 April 2020 in Renewable Energy
30 March 2024 in Experiments in Fluids
The floating-element (FE) principle, introduced nearly a century ago, remains one of the most versatile direct wall shear stress measurement methods. Yet, its intrinsic sources of systematic error, associated with the flow-exposed gap, off-axis load sensitivity, and calibration, have thus far limited its widespread application. In combination with the lack of standard designs and testing procedures, measurement reliability still hinges heavily on individual judgement and expertise. This paper presents a framework to curb these limitations, whereby the design and operation of a FE balance are leveraged by an analytical model that attempts to capture the behaviour and predict the relative contribution of the systematic sources of error. The design is based on a parallel-shift linkage and a zero-displacement force-feedback system. The FE has a surface area of $$200\times 200\,$$ mm, and measurement sensitivity is adjustable depending on the surface condition and the Reynolds number. It is thus suitable for application in a wide range of low-speed, boundary-layer wind tunnels, small or large scale. Measurements of the skin friction coefficient over a smooth wall show a remarkable agreement with oil-film interferometry, especially for $${\rm Re}_{\theta } > 1.3 \times 10^4$$ . The discrepancy relative to the empirical Coles–Fernholz relation ( $$\kappa = 0.39$$ and $$C = 4.352$$ ) is within $$0.5\,$$ %, and the level of uncertainty is below $$1\,$$ % for a confidence interval of $$95\,$$ %.
13 October 2023 in Experiments in Fluids
Full-scale drag penalty predictions of flows over rough walls require surface roughness characterisation from laboratory experiments or numerical simulations. In either approach, it is necessary to determine the so-called equivalent sand-grain roughness height ( $$k_s$$ ). There are several steps involved in determining this aerodynamic roughness lengthscale, but its procedure typically includes a combination of measurement of wall-shear stress ( $$\tau _w$$ ) using direct or indirect methods as well as analysis of velocity profiles. Indirect methods usually rely on assumptions made about flow and its scaling including the validity of universal outer-layer similarity. However, the implications of the underlying assumptions involved in full-scale drag prediction are unclear. In this work, we carry out wind tunnel measurements over a realistic rough surface (from a fouled ship-hull) to evaluate the impact of different methods with an emphasis on using the outer-layer similarity hypothesis for full-scale drag predictions. Wall-shear stress is measured using an in-house floating-element drag balance (DB), and velocity profiles are obtained using particle image velocimetry (PIV), allowing the evaluation of $$k_s$$ , and the associated wake parameters through several methods. The aerodynamic roughness parameters hence obtained are used for full-scale drag penalty calculations. It is observed that the predicted drag penalty can vary by over 15 $$\%$$ among the different methods highlighting the care that should be taken when employing such methods.
21 January 2021 in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
We experimentally investigate the surface drag characteristics of a staggered-distributed cube array and its interaction with the turbulent structure of the overlying flow. Instantaneous maps of the pressure field, inferred from in-plane velocity data are used to estimate the forces acting on a target roughness element. Coupled statistics of the force in combination with conditional flow analysis and extended proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) of the pressure field, based on the velocity POD modes, elucidate the relevant mechanisms responsible for surface drag generation. The results show that turbulent motions, at different scales, leave an imprint on the pressure field. Specifically, positive and negative fluctuations are generally associated with flow regions experiencing a local deceleration and acceleration, respectively. Although large-scale motions were found to be the single greatest contributor to the fluctuating pressure field, their direct influence on the surface drag fluctuations appears to be mitigated by the relative size of the considerably smaller roughness obstacles. We hypothesise that a pressure wave induced by the passage of alternating high- and low-momentum regions evenly affects the flow field over a broad region, coupling the forces on the windward and leeward sides of the cube, which, in turn, partially cancel each other out. Uncorrelated, intermediate and small-scale pressure events are thus more important to the overall drag fluctuations. While the direct influence of the large-scale structures on the surface drag may be smaller than expected, the results suggest that they are still significant for the role they play in modulating the small-scale pressure events in the canopy region.
3 February 2026 in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
The present study experimentally investigates the onset of ventilation of surface-piercing hydrofoils. Under steady-state conditions, the depth-based Froude number $\textit{Fr}$ and the angle of attack $\alpha$ define regions in which distinct flow regimes are either locally or globally stable. To map the boundary between these stability regions, the parameter space $(\alpha , \textit{Fr})$ was systematically surveyed by increasing $\alpha$ until the onset of ventilation while maintaining a constant $\textit{Fr}$ . Two simplified model hydrofoils were examined: a semi-ogive with a blunt trailing edge and a modified NACA 0010-34. Tests were conducted in a towing tank under quasi-steady-state conditions for aspect ratios of $1.0$ and $1.5$ , and for $\textit{Fr}$ ranging from $0.5$ to $2.5$ . Ventilation occurred spontaneously for all test conditions as $\alpha$ increased. Three distinct trigger mechanisms were identified: nose, tail and base ventilation. Nose ventilation is prevalent at $\textit{Fr} \lt 1.0$ and $\textit{Fr} \lt 1.25$ for aspect ratios of $1.0$ and $1.5$ , respectively, and is associated with an increase in the inception angle of attack. Tail ventilation becomes prevalent at higher $\textit{Fr}$ , and the inception angle of attack exhibits a negative trend. Base ventilation was only observed for the semi-ogive profile, but it did not lead to the development of a stable ventilated cavity. Notably, the measurements indicate that the boundary between bistable and globally stable regions is not uniform and extends to significantly higher $\alpha$ than previously estimated. A revised stability map is proposed to reconcile previously published and current data, demonstrating how two alternative paths to a steady-state condition can lead to different flow regimes.