Whereas streamwise effective slope ( $ES_{x}$ ) is accepted as a key topographical parameter in the context of rough-wall turbulent flows, the significance of its spanwise counterpart ( $ES_{y}$ ) remains largely unexplored. Here, the response of turbulent channel flow over irregular, three-dimensional rough walls with systematically varied values of $ES_{y}$ is studied using direct numerical simulation. All simulations were performed at a fixed friction Reynolds number 395, corresponding to a viscous-scaled roughness height $k^{+}\approx 65.8$ (where $k$ is the mean peak-to-valley height). A surface generation algorithm is used to synthesise a set of ten irregular surfaces with specified $ES_{y}$ for three different values of $ES_{x}$ . All surfaces share a common mean peak-to-valley height and are near-Gaussian, which allows this study to focus on the impact of varying $ES_{y}$ , since roughness amplitude, skewness and $ES_{x}$ can be eliminated simultaneously as parameters. Based on an analysis of first- and second-order velocity statistics, as well as turbulence co-spectra and the fractional contribution of pressure and viscous drag, the study shows that $ES_{y}$ can strongly affect the roughness drag penalty – particularly for low- $ES_{x}$ surfaces. A secondary observation is that particular low- $ES_{y}$ surfaces in this study can lead to diminished levels of outer-layer similarity in both mean flow and turbulence statistics, which is attributed to insufficient scale separation between the outer length scale and the in-plane spanwise roughness wavelength.
A surface roughness from a recently cleaned and painted ship's hull was scanned, scaled and replicated for laboratory testing to systematically investigate the influence of the ratio of in-plane roughness wavelength, -type behaviour can occur in situations where the in-plane roughness wavelength approaches the boundary layer thickness. This finding has important implications to how we scale small-scale roughness from high Reynolds number (Re) large-scale applications for testing in low Re small-scale laboratory facilities or simulations.
Although the hull of a recently dry-docked large ship is expected to be relatively smooth, surface scanning and experimentation reveal that it can exhibit an “orange-peel” roughness pattern with an equivalent sand-grain roughness height = 0. 101 mm. Using the known value and integral boundary layer evolution, a recently cleaned and coated full-scale ship was predicted to experience a significant increase in the average coefficient of friction and total hydrodynamic resistance during operation. Here the report also discusses two recently reported empirical estimations that can estimate ks directly from measured surface topographical parameters, by-passing the need for experiments on replicated surfaces. The empirical estimations are found to have an accuracy of 4.5 − 5 percentage points in
Full-scale drag penalty predictions of flows over rough walls require surface roughness characterisation from laboratory experiments or numerical simulations. In either approach, it is necessary to determine the so-called equivalent sand-grain roughness height ( $$k_s$$ ). There are several steps involved in determining this aerodynamic roughness lengthscale, but its procedure typically includes a combination of measurement of wall-shear stress ( $$\tau _w$$ ) using direct or indirect methods as well as analysis of velocity profiles. Indirect methods usually rely on assumptions made about flow and its scaling including the validity of universal outer-layer similarity. However, the implications of the underlying assumptions involved in full-scale drag prediction are unclear. In this work, we carry out wind tunnel measurements over a realistic rough surface (from a fouled ship-hull) to evaluate the impact of different methods with an emphasis on using the outer-layer similarity hypothesis for full-scale drag predictions. Wall-shear stress is measured using an in-house floating-element drag balance (DB), and velocity profiles are obtained using particle image velocimetry (PIV), allowing the evaluation of $$k_s$$ , and the associated wake parameters through several methods. The aerodynamic roughness parameters hence obtained are used for full-scale drag penalty calculations. It is observed that the predicted drag penalty can vary by over 15 $$\%$$ among the different methods highlighting the care that should be taken when employing such methods.