Sewer deterioration is a major concern for water utilities, as failures in sewer systems can have severe consequences for public health and the environment. Sewer asset management is widely used to improve long-term system performance and reduce failure risks. This approach relies heavily on data, typically derived from closed-circuit television inspections and summarized using a general pipe condition score. However, this score provides limited insight because it does not explicitly represent the individual defects observed during inspections. Recent studies have highlighted the benefits of analyzing sewer condition at the defect level rather than relying solely on aggregated condition scores. Defect-level approaches allow a more detailed representation of pipe condition and can improve the development of deterioration and prediction models. Nevertheless, several aspects remain underexplored, particularly the properties and characteristics of individual defects, which may play an important role in understanding deterioration processes. Given the challenges associated with data management and the large number of variables related to sewer deterioration, several initiatives have attempted to structure and organize these data; however, many frameworks are not publicly available and often lack a universal structure and consistent terminology. This paper proposes an open, structured data framework for defect-level sewer condition modeling, supported by an entity–relationship diagram. The framework defines data requirements through a state-of-the-art literature review of previous studies and technical guidelines on sewer deterioration. The review included 77 studies on factors influencing sewer pipe condition, three international guidelines on the identification and characterization of defects, and several studies on sewer system failures. The resulting structure provides a flexible framework that can be adapted to different contexts and data availability, offering a practical resource for researchers and water utilities seeking to model sewer pipe condition at the defect level.
Optimal sewer network design is a complex problem that has been widely studied in literature. A methodology published in the literature that has shown great potential is the proposed by Duque, Duque, Aguilar, Saldarriaga. This methodology uses Mixed Integer Programming to select the layout of the network and Dynamic Programming to select the optimal combination of diameters and depths of pipes. Although the methodology showed good performance, two improvements have been implemented in later works. The first one is to consider topographic criteria when selecting the layout. This demonstrated to reduce the sewer network design’s costs. The other improvement is the addition of drop manholes in the optimization process. This allowed the methodology to comply with maximum velocity constrains in hilly regions. The present work tested the three methodologies mentioned before in a sewer network located in Bogotá, Colombia to evaluate the contributions and disadvantages of each methodology considering the cost and the hydraulic features of the resulting designs, and the computational resources required with each methodology.
10 November 2026 in Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management
Sewer systems are essential for public health and environmental protection; however, they deteriorate over time, potentially leading to significant impacts. Although numerous models have been developed to assess pipe condition, most rely on aggregated closed-circuit television (CCTV) scores and do not incorporate detailed defect-level analysis. Although defect-based approaches have shown strong potential, they often don’t account for defect properties, leaving a gap in the comprehensive analysis of individual defect types and their characteristics. This study addresses this gap by conducting a descriptive analysis of sewer defect types and their properties across different pipe materials. The analysis is applied to CCTV data from Auckland’s sewer network, covering five pipe materials: three rigid—asbestos cement (AC), concrete (CONC), and vitrified clay (VC)—and two flexible—polyvinyl chloride (PVC) and polyethylene (PE). The analysis includes an assessment of data set representativeness and a graphical evaluation of defect patterns. The results reveal clear material-dependent patterns. Rigid pipes exhibit higher defect densities and are mainly affected by Joint Faulty and Root Intrusion defects, likely related to their short, segmented construction. In flexible pipes, PVC is also strongly affected by Joint Faulty, whereas PE is predominantly affected by Dipped Pipe. Defect property analysis further highlights distinct patterns. Cracks tend to be larger in PVC pipes, whereas Surface Damage is more pronounced in rigid pipes. Spatial analysis shows that Joint Faulty defects mainly occur at pipe ends, whereas Debris Grease and Surface Damage are typically observed near the pipe inlet and often extend along the pipe length. Circumferential analysis showed that mechanically induced defects (e.g., Joint Faulty and cracks) tend to occur near the pipe top, whereas Obstructions and Surface Damage concentrate at the pipe bottom. These findings provide new insights into sewer deterioration processes, support more informed decision-making, and offer a transferable methodology for application to other drainage systems.