26 March 2025 in Zeszyty Teoretyczne Rachunkowości
Purpose: By linking verified non-compliance of financial outcomes disclosures with non-verified disclosures of information related to social and environmental outcomes, we can assess their relationship and gain insight into the potential incentives driving Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) disclosures. The aim of this study is to assess the credibility of non-financial reporting by examining whether companies that demonstrate greater compliance with ESG disclosure requirements also place more emphasis on "true and fair" or "fair" financial reporting. Methodology/approach: The study analyzed a sample of listed companies for the peri-od from 2019 to 2022, using a logistic regression with a modified audit opinion as the outcome variable and the ESG score as the primary explanatory variable. Findings: The results show a negative relationship between ESG disclosure scores and modified audit opinions, suggesting that companies with lower ESG disclosure scores are more likely to receive a modified audit opinion. Companies with higher ESG scores are less likely to receive a modified audit opinion than other companies. In addition to ESG scores, a modified audit opinion is also significantly related to the Big Four, profitability and solvency. Research limitations/implications: Our research sample is limited to the Croatian capital market with a relatively small number of observations, and the ESG score measurement is based on the methodology of the Croatian Financial Services Supervisory Authority, which is applicable to the Croatian environment. The generalization of our results should, therefore, be taken with caution. Originality/value: Given the relatively high frequency of modified audit opinions in our institutional setting, we are able to estimate the association between ESG performance and modified audit opinion more accurately than in alternative settings where modified audit opinions related to non-compliance with accounting standards are ra-ther rare. In addition, this study contributes to the existing literature by examining how ESG disclosure compliance is related to the audit opinion in an environment where firms do not face potentially severe financial consequences of a modified audit opinion.
3 December 2020 in SSRN Electronic Journal
The aim of this paper is to analyze how effective internal audit of cyber security assurance is. To address this question we develop a Cyber Security Assurance (CSA) Index, composed of three dimensions (planning, performing and reporting). We hypothesize that the three phases of CS assurance are associated, that cyber security assurance is positively related to cyber risk management maturity of an organization and negatively to the probability of a successful cyber-attack. To test our hypotheses, we conducted a survey with 183 IT auditors and Chief Audit Executives from various countries and industries. We find that cyber security assurance is moderately effective, with a median CSA Index score of 61 on the scale from 0 to 100. While planning and performing CS assurance are strongly positively correlated, each of them is less related to reporting on CS risk management effectiveness to the Board of Directors. CSA Index is positively related to cyber security risk maturity but not to the probability of a cyber-attack. Our paper advances the literature on cyber security risk management and internal audit of that area and has several theoretical contributions and practical implications.
1 January 2024 in SSRN Electronic Journal
Regularization machine learning (ML) methods are becoming increasingly used in accounting research, offering new possibilities in predictive modelling. Their forte lies in the effective regularization methods for resolving the biggest concern of generalization, which is the risk of overfitting the training data. While these sophisticated methods are known to outperform traditional regression approaches in large and balanced datasets, this may not be the case when facing imbalanced and small datasets. Moreover, model validation is also challenging in such settings because traditional performance measures, such as prediction accuracy, may be misleading. We address this problem by comparing two traditional and five regularization-based methods in predicting going concern uncertainty (GCU) on the sample of listed companies in Croatia. We take caution when evaluating the models due to class-imbalanced problems and include different classification performance measures as well as calibration of the models to account for their uncertainty. As expected, we find that no model performs best across all evaluation criteria, but regularization methods are better calibrated. Given our results, we suggest that model selection should consider the results of the model calibration, a combination of different performance metrics, and the economic impact of the statistical performance of the model, if feasible.
30 June 2023 in SSRN Electronic Journal
This paper investigates whether the differences in audit quality between Big 4 and non-Big 4 auditors can be attributed to the client’s pre-audit financial reporting quality or to the differences in audit treatment via audit adjustments. Hand-collected pre-audit and audited financial statement data of Croatian listed companies enables us to determine the pre-audit client financial characteristics as well as the frequency and the magnitude of audit adjustments on each specific line item of financial statements. Even though Big 4 and non-Big 4 auditors generally make similar adjustments to financial statements, we find that the Big 4 auditors make larger audit adjustments on fixed assets, revaluation reserves, impairment and net income. Also, they more frequently adjust provisions compared to the non-Big 4 auditors. We find that Big 4 clients have significantly higher pre-audit and audited accrual quality. However, after applying regression analysis, propensity-score matching and difference-in-differences technique to control for pre-audit earnings quality, our results indicate that the Big 4 effect on audited earnings quality is not significant.
17 February 2026 in Ekonomska Misao i Praksa
Cilj je ovog rada ispitati percepcije internih revizora u Hrvatskoj o njihovoj uključenosti u izvještavanje o održivosti. Istraživanje je provedeno anketom među članovima Hrvatskog instituta interne revizije te Sekcije interne revizije Hrvatske zajednice računovođa i financijskih djelatnika. Rezultati pokazuju da interni revizori još uvijek nisu intenzivno uključeni u aktivnosti povezane s izvještavanjem o ESG-u, bilo pružanjem uvjerenja ili savjetodavnim aktivnostima. Procjena postojećih kompetencija u području ESG-a kreće se oko sredine Likertove ljestvice, bez značajnih odstupanja, što upućuje na nesigurnost u pogledu adekvatnosti revizorske uloge u ovom području unatoč visokoj percepciji važnosti ESG rizika i izvještavanja o ESG-u. Podrška revizijskog odbora pozitivno je povezana s uključenošću interne revizije, osobito u pružanju uvjerenja nad ESG izvještavanjem. Istraživanje ističe potrebu za jačanjem uloge interne revizije u ESG izvještavanju razvojem specifičnih znanja i vještina te kontinuiranom podrškom revizijskog odbora, osobito u kontekstu novih regulatornih zahtjeva i rastuće važnosti održivosti za organizacije u Hrvatskoj.