Energy production by nuclear fusion can be the breakthrough in the decarbonization process, and high temperature superconductors (HTSs) represent a game changer for the design of compact reactors. However, reduced size implies that the superconducting tapes will be exposed to an intense flux of neutrons and of secondary particles while carrying a high current; in order to employ HTS in compact fusion reactors it is therefore crucial to precisely assess the effects of irradiation on HTS tapes at the working conditions. To achieve this goal, researchers from different fields met at the irradiation effects on HTS for (IREF) fusion workshop to discuss all the aspects of this topic. This roadmap paper, that reflects the common view of the participants, aims at condensing the outcome of the intense and thorough discussion that took place during the conference, providing a path for the investigation of irradiation effects in HTS to assess their limits of operation in a fusion radiation environment.
1 April 2025 in Superconductor Science and Technology
The study of irradiation effects in cuprate high temperature superconductors (HTS) has been a topic of interest since their discovery. Enormous progress in the understanding of vortex physics and pinning mechanisms was made in the early 1990s through the irradiation of HTS single crystals with a variety of particles over broad ranges of energies. For YBa2Cu3O7 (YBCO), the overall conclusion was that irradiation could increase the critical current density (Jc) by orders of magnitude. The interpretation of the results was simplified by the fact that the pristine crystals were very clean, with few pinning centers and quite low Jc, thus essentially all pinning in the irradiated crystals could be attributed to the controllably added disorder. The case of the ReBa2Cu3O7 (ReBCO, where Re = Y, a Rare Earth, or combinations of them) epitaxial thin films and coated conductors (CC) is more complex, because the pre-irradiation samples already have high Jc due to the presence of large densities of strong pinning centers, which are fabrication-method and processing dependent. The most popular and efficient method to further increase Jc in CC has been the incorporation of artificial pinning centers (APC) by chemical incorporation of second phases. Efforts by many groups worldwide demonstrated that a diversity of APC can be effective, and it is now clear that mixed pinning landscapes, nanoengineered by the combination of defects of various shapes and sizes, produce the best results. In some cases, particle irradiation is still effective at enhancing Jc in CC, by more modest factors than in the single crystals. Interaction with pre-existing defects cannot be ignored, resulting in both cooperating and competing effects. In this work, I review the vortex pinning generated in YBCO by defects of various geometries (point defects, randomly distributed nanoparticles, aligned or splayed columnar) created either by particle irradiation, incorporation of second phases, or combinations of both routes, and discuss some implications of those results for the design of fusion reactors CC magnets.