Environmental DNA (eDNA) and RNA (eRNA) metabarcoding has become a popular tool for assessing biodiversity from environmental samples, but inconsistent documentation of methods, data and metadata makes results difficult to reproduce and synthesise. A working group of scientists have collaborated to produce a set of minimum reporting guidelines for the constituent steps of metabarcoding workflows, from the physical layout of laboratories through to data archiving. We emphasise how reporting the suite of data and metadata should adhere to findable, accessible, interoperable and reproducible (FAIR) data standards, thereby providing context for evaluating and understanding study results. An overview of the documentation considerations for each workflow step is presented and then summarised in a checklist that can accompany a published study or report. Ensuring workflows are transparent and documented is critical to reproducible research and should allow for more efficient uptake of metabarcoding data into management decision-making.
Marker gene sequencing (“metabarcoding”) is the primary sequencing approach currently used for molecular biodiversity surveys, but this approach is taxonomically limited and hampered by amplification biases. In contrast, shotgun metagenomes avoid extensive PCR amplification and can theoretically capture the full taxonomic breadth of the eDNA pool. However, eukaryotic DNA is often a small component of metagenomes; consequently they have seen limited use in metazoan biodiversity surveys. Here, we compare metabarcoding and shotgun metagenomes on a large (>200 sample size) set of marine water column eDNA samples and show that metagenomes can provide biodiversity information comparable to that of metabarcoding surveys. They provide more consistent and even detections of important phytoplankton like chlorophytes and haptophytes and can detect metazoan taxa of management and conservation interest, such as the humpback whale. However, genus- and species-level taxonomic assignments are often inaccurate for metagenomic data and require more manual annotation relative to metabarcoding taxonomy. Reference database gaps remain an obstacle to accurate and comprehensive biodiversity surveys for both metabarcoding and shotgun metagenomes. We provide examples of taxa that may benefit from one approach over another and highlight cases of metagenomic utility.
With the rapid uptake of environmental DNA (eDNA) metabarcoding for a wide range of conservation and management uses, there is a growing need for guidance and best practices for species identification. A range of methodological and interpretive decisions influences taxa assignment. Here we provide a review and perspective of pitfalls and issues that can impact accurate taxonomic assignment across the full eDNA metabarcoding workflow: primer selection, lab handling, bioinformatics, taxonomic assignment, and communication of results. This paper addresses the complexities and challenges of the metabarcoding-based species identification process, offering recommendations for robust workflows and effective communication of findings. Accurate interpretation and communication of eDNA metabarcoding results requires an acknowledgment of methodological limitations such as incomplete reference databases, contamination risks, ambiguous sequences, and detection biases. Thus, we argue that transparency of methods and limitations, alongside proactive alignment of decisions with project objectives are critical for the successful application of eDNA metabarcoding in conservation and management decisions. We provide guidance for developing protocols that support species identification from eDNA metabarcoding sequences, and give recommendations on communication strategies for stakeholders and end users. To support these recommendations, we outline steps in the workflow that can impact species identification, with a discussion of the strengths and weaknesses at each stage. Ultimately, this guidance can improve the accuracy, reliability, and usability of eDNA and other metabarcoding and amplicon sequencing approaches to species identification while fostering trust and understanding among diverse end users.
This sequencing protocol is intended to directly follow and use the PCR products of a primary PCR amplification protocol (e.g., 12S rRNA, 18S rRNA V9, cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) mitochondrial gene). Primary PCR products were produced at MBARI and sent to Michigan State University's (MSU) Research Technology Support Facility (RTSF) Genomics Core for indexing, pooling, and sequencing. Secondary PCR primers used: PE1-BC-CS1, PE2-BC-CS2 This indexing PCR protocol is used to uniquely index the amplified DNA products of each sample. This is necessary so the sequencing results can be demultiplexed and the reads can be properly identified and assigned to each individual sample.
This sequencing protocol is intended to directly follow and use the PCR products of the protocol: "Environmental DNA (eDNA) 12S Metabarcoding PCR Protocol (with Platinum SuperFi II Taq)" which amplifies the hypervariable region of the mitochondrial DNA 12S rRNA gene in eukaryotes. This protocol creates a pooled library which is then size selected using a Blue Pippin or Pippin HT to select for the vertebrate/fish band (~350 bp) and remove the co-amplified bacterial band (~435 bp). Then the pooled product is sequenced on an Illumina MiSeq v2 in a 2x250bp paired end format.
This protocol describes the DNA extraction process at Oregon State University (OSU) using the KingFisher Flex with the Omega Bio-Tek Mag-Bind Blood & Tissue DNA HDQ 96 Kit. Specific modifications to the original protocol are bolded for easy identification.