The aim of this study was to analyze the concept of a smart city through the lens of urban comfort dimensions and to identify problem areas in the development of the metropolis of Almaty. Based on content analysis of scientific publications, official documents, and international index data, key dimensions of urban comfort were defined. The empirical part of the research was implemented through a survey of 167 Almaty residents, whose responses revealed areas of high satisfaction (education, leisure, emergency healthcare) as well as problematic aspects (housing affordability, environmental conditions, cybersecurity). The results demonstrated discrepancies between objective statistical data and residents’ subjective perceptions, highlighting the necessity for a comprehensive approach to smart city development. The conclusions of this research may serve as guidance for enhancing urban strategies aimed at improving the quality and sustainability of the urban environment. Keywords: smart city, urban environment comfort, Almaty, quality of life indices, urban planning, urban studies, citizen perception
Rapid advances in artificial intelligence (AI), the Internet of Things (IoT), and digital government platforms are accelerating the transformation of urban systems toward smart and sustainable cities, creating new challenges for managing complex urban development projects. This study proposes an integrated project management framework that aligns digital transformation technologies with sustainability principles to enhance smart city implementation in emerging economies. A qualitative research design combining systematic literature analysis and comparative case study evaluation was employed, examining smart city initiatives in Aqkol, Nur-Sultan (Astana), and Almaty, Kazakhstan. The analysis investigates how technological integration, governance mechanisms, stakeholder collaboration, and sustainability objectives interact within adaptive project management environments. Results indicate that successful smart city development depends on coordinated alignment across these four dimensions, supported by flexible governance models and data-driven decision processes. The findings further demonstrate that AI-enabled digital twin technologies and participatory digital governance significantly improve infrastructure optimization, urban decision-making efficiency, and resilience outcomes. The proposed framework contributes a structured evaluation and implementation model that bridges project management theory with smart city digitalization practices. The novelty of this research lies in integrating sustainability-driven project governance with emerging digital technologies into a unified operational framework, providing practical guidance for policymakers, urban planners, and project managers seeking scalable and resilient smart city solutions in rapidly evolving technological contexts.
The article discusses the problems and opportunities of introducing smart city technologies in Kazakhstan through the prism of project management. Key aspects such as infrastructure quality, sustainable development, data protection, citizen participation, government support and the introduction of innovative technologies are analyzed. Examples of successful projects in Kazakhstan, such as transport and lighting management systems, as well as the experience of international practices, including Singapore and Germany, are given. The study highlights the importance of integrating sustainable solutions, reducing digital inequality, and ensuring citizen participation in digitalization processes. In addition, the need to adapt international models of project management to the socio-economic and cultural characteristics of Kazakhstan is noted. Quantitative and qualitative analysis methods are used, including surveys, expert interviews and data visualization, which allows us to identify the interrelationships between various aspects of the implementation of smart city projects. The practical significance of the article lies in the development of recommendations for public and private organizations aimed at improving the effectiveness of stakeholder interaction, stimulating citizen participation in digital transformation and creating conditions for sustainable urban development. The findings of the study can serve as a basis for strategic planning and decision-making in the field of smart city project management in Kazakhstan.