David Axford Neave

David Axford Neave

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

David Axford Neave

Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

15Years (2012-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
3 April 2017 in American Mineralogist: Journal of Earth and Planetary Materials
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
DNDavid A. Neave
David A. Neave
KPKeith D. Putirka
Keith D. Putirka
Pressure is one of the key variables that controls magmatic phase equilibria. However, estimating magma storage pressures from erupted products can be challenging. Various barometers have been developed over the past two decades that exploit the pressure-sensitive incorporation of jadeite (Jd) into clinopyroxene. These Jd-in-clinopyroxene barometers have been applied to rift zone magmas from Iceland, where published estimates of magma storage depths span the full thickness of the crust, and extend into the mantle. However, tests performed on commonly used clinopyroxene-liquid barometers with data from experiments on H2O-poor tholeiites in the 1 atm to 10 kbar range reveal substantial pressure-dependent inaccuracies, with some models overestimating pressures of experimental products equilibrated at 1 atm by up to 3 kbar. The pressures of closed-capsule experiments in the 1–5 kbar range are also overestimated, and such errors cannot be attributed to Na loss, as is the case in open furnace experiments. The following barometer was calibrated from experimental data in the 1 atm to 20 kbar range to improve the accuracy of Jd-in-clinopyroxene barometry at pressures relevant to magma storage in the crust: P(kbar)=−26.27+39.16T(K)104ln[XJdCpxXNaO0.5liqXAlO1.5liq(XSiO2liq)2]−4.22ln(XDiHdCpx)+78.43XAlO1.5liq+393.81(XNaO0.5liqXKO0.5liq)2 This new barometer accurately reproduces its calibration data with a standard error of estimate (SEE) of ±1.4 kbar, and is suitable for use on hydrous and anhydrous samples that are ultramafic to intermediate in composition, but should be used with caution below 1100 °C and at oxygen fugacities greater than one log unit above the QFM buffer. Tests performed using with data from experiments on H2O-poor tholeiites reveal that 1 atm runs were overestimated by less than the model precision (1.2 kbar); the new calibration is significantly more accurate than previous formulations. Many current estimates of magma storage pressures may therefore need to be reassessed. To this end, the new barometer was applied to numerous published clinopyroxene analyses from Icelandic rift zone tholeiites that were filtered to exclude compositions affected by poor analytical precision or collected from disequilibrium sector zones. Pressures and temperatures were then calculated using the new barometer in concert with Equation 33 from Putirka (2008). Putative equilibrium liquids were selected from a large database of Icelandic glass and whole-rock compositions using an iterative scheme because most clinopyroxene analyses were too primitive to be in equilibrium with their host glasses. High-Mg# clinopyroxenes from the highly primitive Borgarhraun eruption in north Iceland record a mean storage pressure in the lower crust (5.7 kbar). All other eruptions considered record mean pressures in the mid-crust, with primitive clinopyroxene populations recording slightly higher pressures (3.1–3.6 kbar) than evolved populations (2.6–2.8 kbar). Thus, while some magma processing takes place in the shallow crust immediately beneath Iceland’s central volcanoes, magma evolution under the island’s neovolcanic rift zones is dominated by mid-crustal processes.

11 May 2013 in Journal of Petrology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
DNDavid A. Neave
David A. Neave
EPEmma Passmore
Emma Passmore
JMJohn Maclennan
John Maclennan
GFGodfrey Fitton
Godfrey Fitton
TTThorvaldur Thordarson
Thorvaldur Thordarson
Concurrent mixing and crystallization of magmas has been identified in the plumbing of Icelandic magmatic systems from investigation of their erupted products. Thermobarometric calculations constrain the depth of these processes to the mid- to lower crust. It is currently unknown whether similar processes also occur in the magmas that feed the large fissure eruptions characteristic of the Eastern Volcanic Zone (EVZ). We therefore present the results of an investigation of crystal–melt relationships in the ad 1783 Laki (Skaftár Fires) eruption. The trace element composition of olivine-hosted melt inclusions indicates that concurrent mixing and crystallization of variable mantle melts has occurred in the deep parts of the Laki plumbing system. Magmatic evolution is also recorded in crystal zonation patterns. Zoned plagioclase macrocrysts are made up of three distinct domains: high-anorthite cores, oscillatory zoned mantles and low-anorthite rims. Published mineral–melt equilibrium partition coefficients indicate that macrocryst rims are in equilibrium with the carrier liquid erupted at the surface. High-anorthite cores are more primitive than any other crystal or melt inclusion composition in the magma and are never in equilibrium with melts generated by fractional crystallization models that assume a single liquid line of descent related to the carrier liquid. High-anorthite crystals may have grown from depleted, high-Ca/Na melts of the shallow mantle, which may have been mixed into melts parental to the carrier liquid early in magmatic evolution. The crystal size distribution (CSD) of plagioclase macrocrysts suggests that plagioclase cores represent an assimilated or accumulated crystal population. Cores have acted as nuclei for the growth of oscillatory zoned plagioclase mantles. It is possible to relate the range of plagioclase mantle compositions to the carrier liquid using fractional crystallization models involving eutectic co-crystallization with clinopyroxene and olivine macrocrysts. Negative correlation of titanium and anorthite content in plagioclase mantles confirms that oscillatory zoning is driven by variations in melt composition, most probably the result of repeated recharge and fractionation events. Melt barometry indicates that the melt last equilibrated with olivine, plagioclase and clinopyroxene in the shallow crust at 1–2 kbar, whereas clinopyroxene–melt barometry suggests that the bulk of macrocryst growth occurred within the mid-crust at 2–5·4 kbar. Much of the macrocryst content of the Laki magma occurs as glomerocrysts, of which only rims in contact with the groundmass are in equilibrium with the carrier liquid. This indicates that the formation of glomerocrysts occurred before rim growth, during deposition of crystal mushes in the mid-crust, which subsequently disaggregated upon transport to the shallow crust.

1 August 2019 in Journal of Petrology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
DNDavid A Neave
David A Neave
EBEnikő Bali
Enikő Bali
GGGuðmundur H. Guðfinnsson
Guðmundur H. Guðfinnsson
SHSæmundur A Halldórsson
Sæmundur A Halldórsson
MKMaren Kahl
Maren Kahl
FHFrançois Holtz
François Holtz
Clinopyroxene–liquid geothermobarometry is a widely used tool for estimating the conditions under which mafic magmas are stored before they erupt. However, redox variability, sector zoning and disequilibrium crystallization present major challenges to the robust estimation of magma storage conditions. Moreover, most recent studies seeking to address these challenges have focused on clinopyroxenes from alkalic systems and are thus of limited use for understanding clinopyroxenes from the tholeiitic systems that dominate global magma budgets. Here we combine observations on natural clinopyroxenes from the 2014–2015 Holuhraun lava in Iceland with observations on experimental clinopyroxenes synthesized during high-pressure, high-temperature experiments on the same lava in order to investigate clinopyroxene–liquid equilibria in tholeiitic systems and optimize of geothermobarometric strategies. Natural clinopyroxenes from the 2014–2015 Holuhraun lava are sector zoned, with {1-11} hourglass sectors being enriched in the enstatite–ferrosillite component at the expense of all other components with respect to {hk0} prism sectors. In contrast with observations on clinopyroxenes from alkalic systems, sector zoning in clinopyroxenes from the 2014–2015 Holuhraun lava is characterized by differences in Ca and Na contents as well as in Ti and Al contents. The products of crystallization experiments performed at 100–600 MPa and 1140–1220 °C on a powdered starting glass at two sets of melt H2O content–oxygen fugacity conditions (∼0·1 wt % H2O and close to the graphite-oxygen redox buffer, and 0·5–1·0 wt % H2O and approximately one and half log units above the quartz–fayalite–magnetite redox buffer) demonstrate that clinopyroxene crystals from nominally equilibrium experiments can preserve strongly disequilibrium compositions. The compositional systematics of experimental clinopyroxenes are consistent with the presence of sector zoning. Furthermore, the magnitude of compositional variability increases with decreasing melt H2O content and increasing deviations of experimental temperatures below clinopyroxene liquidus temperatures (i.e. degrees of undercooling sensu lato), indicating that kinetic processes play a key role in controlling clinopyroxene compositions, even under notionally equilibrium conditions. Few published analyses of experimental clinopyroxene crystals may thus represent truly equilibrium compositions. Stoichiometric calculations on natural and experimental clinopyroxenes show that Fe3+ is a major constituent of clinopyroxenes from tholeiitic magmas under naturally relevant oxygen fugacity conditions. They also show that Fe3+ is most likely incorporated as Ca- and Al- bearing Ca–Fe-Tschermak’s component rather than Na-bearing aegirine component at oxygen fugacities up to one and a half log units above the quartz–fayalite–magnetite buffer. Elevated oxygen fugacities are thus less likely to compromise clinopyroxene–liquid geothermobarometry than previously thought. Guided by our experimental results, we combined published descriptions of clinopyroxene–liquid equilibria with geothermobarometric equations to develop an internally consistent and widely applicable method for performing geothermobarometry on tholeiitic magmas that does not require equilibrium zones to be selected a priori. Applying this method to natural clinopyroxene crystals from the 2014–2015 Holuhraun lava that formed under low but variable degrees of undercooling (perhaps 25 °C or less) returns values in excellent agreement with those from independent methods (232 ± 86 MPa, 1161 ± 11 °C). Robust estimates of magma storage conditions can thus be obtained by performing clinopyroxene–liquid geothermobarometry on tholeiitic magmas when disequilibrium is suitably accounted for.

31 October 2014 in Journal of Petrology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
DNDavid A. Neave
David A. Neave
JMJohn Maclennan
John Maclennan
MHMargaret E. Hartley
Margaret E. Hartley
MEMarie Edmonds
Marie Edmonds
TTThorvaldur Thordarson
Thorvaldur Thordarson
Magma mixing and crystal mush disaggregation are important processes in basaltic magma reservoirs. We carried out a detailed petrological and geochemical study on a highly plagioclase-phyric eruption within the Eastern Volcanic Zone of Iceland—the Skuggafjöll eruption—to investigate crystal storage and transport processes within a single magmatic system. Crystal content and phase proportions vary between samples: the least phyric samples have phase proportions similar to the low-pressure, three-phase gabbro eutectic (plg:cpx:ol ∼ 11:6:3), whereas highly phyric samples are strongly enriched in plagioclase (plg:cpx:ol ∼ 8:1:1). Statistically significant geochemical variability in 28 whole-rock samples collected across the eruption can be accounted for by variable accumulation of a troctolitic assemblage containing plagioclase and olivine in an approximately 9:1 ratio. Two macrocryst assemblages are defined using compositional and textural information recorded in QEMSCAN® images: a primitive assemblage of high-anorthite plagioclase (An>83) and high-forsterite olivine (Fo>84), and an evolved assemblage of low-anorthite plagioclase (An<79), low-forsterite olivine (Fo<82) and clinopyroxene (Mg# ∼ 82). Plagioclase and olivine have strongly bimodal composition distributions whereas the composition distribution of clinopyroxene is unimodal. The mean trace element composition of melt inclusions hosted within high-forsterite olivine and high-anorthite plagioclase macrocrysts is the same (mean Ce/Y ∼ 0·47–0·48), confirming that both primitive macrocryst phases crystallized from the same distribution of melts. Clinopyroxene macrocrysts and matrix glasses are in Ce/Yb equilibrium with each other, indicating that the evolved assemblage crystallized from melts with a more incompatible trace element-enriched composition (mean Ce/Y ∼ 0·65–71) than the primitive assemblage. Variability in whole-rock, macrocryst and melt inclusion compositions suggests that the Skuggafjöll magma experienced two stages of crystallization. Primitive macrocrysts crystallized first from incompatible trace element-depleted melts within a shallow crustal magma reservoir. These primitive macrocrysts were subsequently stored in crystal mushes that ultimately disaggregated into an evolved and incompatible trace element-enriched magma from which the evolved assemblage crystallized. On average, ∼17% of the erupted magma at Skuggafjöll is composed of accumulated macrocrysts entrained from crystal mushes. The timescale between mush disaggregation and eruption, during which crystal accumulation occurred, was short—of the order of years—according to simple diffusion calculations. Striking petrological similarities between Skuggafjöll and other highly phyric eruptions both in Iceland and along mid-ocean ridges indicate that crystal accumulation by mush disaggregation is likely to be an important mechanism for generating highly phyric magmas in basaltic plumbing systems.

29 December 2022 in Journal of Petrology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
PWPenny E Wieser
Penny E Wieser
AKAdam J R Kent
Adam J R Kent
CTChristy B Till
Christy B Till
JDJohn Donovan
John Donovan
DNDavid A Neave
David A Neave
MKMichael J Krawczynski
Michael J Krawczynski
The composition of clinopyroxene and Clinopyroxene-Liquid (Cpx-Liq) pairs are frequently used to calculate crystallization/equilibration pressures in igneous systems. While canonical uncertainties are often assigned to calculated pressures based on fits to calibration or test datasets, the sources of these uncertainties (and thus ways to reduce them) have not been rigorously assessed. We show that considerable uncertainties in calculated pressures arise from analytical error associated with Electron Probe Microanalyser (EPMA) measurements of Cpx. Specifically, low X-ray counts during analysis of elements with concentrations <1 wt% resulting from insufficient count times and/or low beam currents yield highly imprecise measurements (1σ errors of 10–40% for Na2O). Low analytical precision propagates into the calculation of pressure-sensitive mineral components such as jadeite. Using Monte Carlo approaches, we demonstrate that elemental variation resulting from analytical precision alone generates pressures spanning ~4 kbar (~15 km) for a single Cpx and ~6 kbar for a single Cpx-Liq pair using popular barometry expressions. In addition, analytical uncertainties in mineral compositions produce highly correlated arrays between pressure and temperature that have been previously attributed to transcrustal magma storage. Before invoking such geological interpretations, the more mundane origin from analytical imprecision must be ruled out. Most importantly, low analytical precision does not just affect the application of barometers to natural systems; it has also affected characterization of Cpx in experimental products used to calibrate and test barometers. The impact of poor precision on each individual measurement is also often magnified by the small number of measurements made within experimental charges, meaning that low analytical precision and true variability in mineral compositions have not been sufficiently mediated by averaging multiple EPMA analyses. We compile the number of Cpx measurements performed in N=295 experiments used to calibrate existing barometers, and N=459 new experiments, finding ~40% of experiment charges were characterized by ≤5 individual Cpx analyses. Insufficient characterization of the true composition of experimental phases likely accounts for the fact that all Cpx-based barometers exhibit large errors (± 3 kbar) when tested using global experimental datasets. We suggest specific changes to analytical and experimental protocols, such as increased count times and/or higher beam currents when measuring low concentration elements in relatively beam resistant Cpx in experiments and natural samples. We also advocate for increasing the number of analyses per experimental charge, resolving interlaboratory analytical offsets and improving data reporting. Implementing these changes is essential to produce a more robust dataset to calibrate and test the next generation of more precise and accurate Cpx-based barometers. In turn, this will enable more rigorous investigation of magma storage geometries in a variety of tectonic settings (e.g., distinguishing true transcrustal storage vs. storage in discrete reservoirs).

23 January 2012 in Journal of Petrology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
DNDavid A. Neave
David A. Neave
GFGareth Fabbro
Gareth Fabbro
RHRichard A. Herd
Richard A. Herd
CPChiara Maria Petrone
Chiara Maria Petrone
MEMarie Edmonds
Marie Edmonds
We present the results of the first systematic study of melt compositions at Pantelleria, based on both melt inclusions and matrix glasses in pantellerites from 10 eruptions during the last eruptive cycle (<45 kyr). We present major and trace element compositions, as well as data on the volatiles sulphur (S), fluorine (F), chlorine (Cl), water (H2O), carbon dioxide (CO2) and lithium (Li) Rare earth element (REE) compositions were inverted using the program INVMEL to establish the melt fraction vs depth relationship in the Pantellerian mantle source region. Inversion indicates that melts are generated by ∼1·7% melting of a light rare earth element (LREE)-enriched mantle source. The source lies principally within the spinel–garnet transition zone, which, on the basis of trace element ratios, shows some affinity to the source of North African magmatism. Major and trace element data indicate a gap in melt compositions at intermediate compositions, consistent with previously published whole-rock data. This gap rules out the possibility of explaining chemical variability in the Pantelleria lavas merely by changes in the crystal content of the magmas. Principal component analysis of major element glass compositions shows that the liquid line of descent for mafic melt compositions is controlled by clinopyroxene, plagioclase, magnetite and olivine crystallization. Alkali feldspar, clinopyroxene, ilmenite and olivine or aenigmatite crystallization controls the liquid line of descent for the silicic melt compositions, with aenigmatite broadly replacing olivine in the most evolved magmas. Trace element modelling indicates that 96% fractional crystallization is required to generate pantellerites from alkali basalts at Pantelleria (through trachytes, generated after 76% fractional crystallization). We have measured pantellerite volatile concentrations in melt inclusions and in matrix glasses from a variety of eruptions. Melt inclusions, on average, contain 350 ppm S, 3500 ppm F and 9000 ppm Cl. We have measured up to 4·9 wt % H2O and 150 ppm CO2 in melt inclusions. Li–H2O systematics and Cl abundances in melt inclusions are consistent with partitioning of Li and Cl into a subcritical hydrosaline fluid at low pressures. The volatiles H2O and CO2 are used to estimate melt equilibration pressures, which reach a maximum of 1·5 kbar. Temperatures of 800°C are calculated for the most evolved pantellerites, using published feldspar–melt geothermometers, and up to 870°C for the least evolved samples. Low melt viscosities are calculated for the range of pantellerite compositions observed and may account for rapid differentiation by crystal settling. Stable density stratification of the magma chamber is reflected in the eruption of generally progressively more fractionated compositions after the Green Tuff eruption during the last eruptive cycle. Some anomalies in this trend may be explained by variation in the relative rates of eruption vs fractionation. The density stratification is expected to be enhanced and further stabilized by the efficient migration of a fluid phase to the roof of the magma chamber. The sulphur data are used in combination with published experimental partitioning data for peralkaline rhyolites to estimate the sulphur yield to the atmosphere for a large pantelleritic eruption similar to the Green Tuff. This is expected to be markedly higher than for a similar-sized metaluminous rhyolitic or dacitic eruption, mainly owing to the higher bulk sulphur content, lower fluid–melt partition coefficients, and rapid differentiation and vapour phase segregation in the magma chamber.