28 April 2025 in ACM Transactions on Software Engineering and Methodology
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly becoming fundamental in supporting software developers in coding tasks. The massive datasets used for training LLMs are often collected automatically, leading to the introduction of data smells. Previous work addressed this issue by using quality filters to handle some specific smells. Still, the literature lacks a systematic catalog of the data smells for coding tasks currently known. This article presents a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) focused on articles that introduce LLMs for coding tasks. We first extracted the quality filters adopted for training and testing such LLMs, inferred the root problem behind their adoption (data smells for coding tasks), and defined a taxonomy of such smells. Our results highlight discrepancies in the adoption of quality filters between pre-training and fine-tuning stages and across different coding tasks, shedding light on areas for improvement in LLM-based software development support.
11 February 2025 in arXiv
Automated code summarization is a long-standing goal for code comprehension. This task automatically generates documentation using a given method. Deep Learning (DL)-based approaches have been proven beneficial for various software engineering (SE) tasks, including this one. Most state-of-the-art datasets for code summarization are automatically mined from GitHub and, thus, might contain erroneous or sub-optimal examples. Previous work showed that using a simple rule-based approach for removing noisy instances allows for a tangible reduction of the training set size while not reducing the effectiveness of the trained models. Motivated by this finding, we conjecture that it is possible to further reduce the dataset size by removing instances that contain different issues. In this paper, we explore the extent to which code-comment coherence, a specific quality attribute of code summaries, can be used to optimize code summarization datasets. Specifically, we hypothesize that removing incoherent code-comment pairs might positively impact the effectiveness of the models. To do this, we rely on SIDE, a recently introduced metric for code-summary coherence. We examine multiple selectivity levels of training instances from two state-of-the-art datasets (TL-CodeSum and Funcom) and evaluate the resulting models on three manually curated test sets. The results show that even halving the training set sizes does not significantly affect the model's ability to generate summaries. However, when comparing the most restrictive selection strategy with a simpler one that randomly selects the training instances, we observe that the resulting accuracy of the model also does not change. This result suggests that (i) current datasets contain many irrelevant examples, and (ii) different quality attributes should be explored for optimizing code summarization datasets.