AI-based coding agents are increasingly integrated into software development workflows, collaborating with developers to create pull requests (PRs). Despite their growing adoption, the role of human-agent collaboration in software testing remains poorly understood. This paper presents an empirical study of 6,582 human-agent PRs (HAPRs) and 3,122 human PRs (HPRs) from the AIDev dataset. We compare HAPRs and HPRs along three dimensions: (i) testing frequency and extent, (ii) types of testing-related changes (code-and-test co-evolution vs. test-focused), and (iii) testing quality, measured by test smells. Our findings reveal that, although the likelihood of including tests is comparable (42.9% for HAPRs vs. 40.0% for HPRs), HAPRs exhibit a larger extent of testing, nearly doubling the test-to-source line ratio found in HPRs. While test-focused task distributions are comparable, HAPRs are more likely to add new tests during co-evolution (OR = 1.79), whereas HPRs prioritize modifying existing tests. Finally, although some test smell categories differ statistically, negligible effect sizes suggest no meaningful differences in quality. These insights provide the first characterization of how human-agent collaboration shapes testing practices.
QualAI is a two-year project aimed at defining a set of recommenders to continuously monitor, assess, and improve the quality of AI-based systems, with a particular focus on machine learning (ML) applications. We will develop recommenders for the quality assurance of both data and ML models to enable practitioners to mitigate technical debt. Special attention will be paid to communication challenges that may arise in hybrid teams comprising data scientists and software developers. This paper presents the project outline, provides an executive summary of the research activities, outlines the expected project outcomes, and reports the results obtained to date.
9 December 2025 in Journal of Systems and Software