17 August 2022 in Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering
This paper provides an overview and introduction to the development of non-ergodic ground-motion models, GMMs. It is intended for a reader who is familiar with the standard approach for developing ergodic GMMs. It starts with a brief summary of the development of ergodic GMMs and then describes different methods that are used in the development of non-ergodic GMMs with an emphasis on Gaussian process (GP) regression, as that is currently the method preferred by most researchers contributing to this special issue. Non-ergodic modeling requires the definition of locations for the source and site characterizing the systematic source and site effects; the non-ergodic domain is divided into cells for describing the systematic path effects. Modeling the cell-specific anelastic attenuation as a GP, and considerations on constraints for extrapolation of the non-ergodic GMMs are also discussed. An updated unifying notation for non-ergodic GMMs is also presented, which has been adopted by the authors of this issue.
17 May 2022 in Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering
16 February 2024 in Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America
We investigate the nonergodic behavior of ground motions from subduction zone earthquakes and crustal earthquakes in Japan using the National Research Institute for Earth Science and Disaster Resilience strong‐motion flatfile together with various reference ergodic ground‐motion models (GMMs). For the nonergodic path effects, our nonergodic GMM has two path effects terms: a cell‐specific linear‐distance scaling, denoted as , that mimics the effects of a 3D Q structure, and a source‐ and site‐specific term related to the effects of the 3D velocity structure, denoted . The resulting model provides spatially varying nonergodic source, site, and path terms. The GMM smoothly interpolates and extrapolates the nonergodic terms in space so that the GMM can be applied to any combination of source and site locations in the region. In regions where data are sparse, the median nonergodic terms will approach zero but with large epistemic uncertainty. Over the period range of 0–10 s, the ranges of the standard deviations of the nonergodic source, path, and site terms are 0.2–0.65, 0.25–0.40, and 0.15–0.40 natural log units, respectively. The fully nonergodic models lead to a 40%–55% decrease in the aleatory standard deviation compared to the reference ergodic GMMs. This large reduction in the aleatory standard deviation combined with the change in the median given by the nonergodic terms can exert a significant impact on the computed seismic hazard for the Japan region.
7 June 2023 in Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America
A new approach is developed to incorporate the anisotropic path effects in ground motions due to the 3D velocity structure into nonergodic ground‐motion models (GMMs) using the varying coefficient model (VCM) in a two‐step process. The first step uses the VCM to estimate the spatially varying path term for each site separately with the spatial correlation based on the separation between earthquakes. The model for the correlation length varies as a function of rupture distance to reflect that, for a given separation between events, the path effects are more similar for longer path lengths. The second step uses the step‐1 VCM results as the input to estimate path terms for a specific source location for any site location. The final model is a smooth spatially varying nonergodic path term that can be applied to any source–site pair. An example application of the proposed method using a subset of 600 scenarios of the v15.4 CyberShake simulation for T = 3 s response spectral values shows that nonergodic path terms can be significant, ranging from −0.8 to 0.8 ln units, which corresponds to factors of 0.45–2.23 in the median ground motion compared to the ergodic approach. With nonergodic path terms, the single‐path aleatory variability for the nonergodic GMM is reduced to 0.34 ln units as compared to 0.52 ln units for single‐station sigma without systematic path effects. A comparison of probabilistic hazards shows that the proposed approach leads to a nonergodic GMM that can capture the path effects seen in the CyberShake simulations in terms of both the median and the aleatory standard deviation. The resulting nonergodic GMM extends the applicability of the 3D simulation results to site–source pairs in the region and not limited to the locations of the simulations, making the simulation results more practical to use in seismic hazard studies.
15 July 2022 in Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America
The Abrahamson and Gulerce (2020) ground‐motion model (GMM), called AG20, is modified to include the nonergodic effects from the suite of 3D numerical simulations of long‐period ground motions from M 9 megathrust earthquakes on the Cascadia subduction zone developed by the M 9 project (Frankel et al., 2018). Three modifications are made to the AG20 model. First, the scaling of the basin effects as a function of the depth to a shear‐wave velocity of 2.5 km/s ( ) is modified to be consistent with the scaling from the 3D simulations. Second, the spatial distribution of the nonergodic site terms is estimated using the varying coefficient model for the region covered by the 3D velocity model. The change in the median ground motion due to the nonergodic site terms ranges from factors of 0.25 to 5 at a period of 3 s. Third, a reduction in the aleatory variability for single‐station sigma is estimated. On average, including the nonergodic site terms reduces the sigma by 15%–25% compared with an ergodic sigma for Cascadia. In addition, a spatially varying single‐station sigma model is developed, showing the highest variability for sites near the basin edges. Application of nonergodic GMMs requires an estimate of the epistemic uncertainty in the nonergodic terms. Without simulation results for different 3D velocity models, we assumed that the epistemic uncertainty due to uncertainty in the 3D velocity model is half of the between‐site standard deviation from the simulations. As an example, the seismic hazard for interface events using the nonergodic GMM is compared with the hazard using the original AG20 GMM.
26 April 2024 in Seismological Research Letters
New global source-scaling relations for the aspect ratio and rupture area for crustal earthquakes that include the width-limited effect and a possible free-surface effect are derived using a global dataset of finite-fault rupture models. In contrast to the commonly used scaling relations between moment magnitude (M), fault length (L), width (W), and area, we built self-consistent scaling relations by relating M to the aspect ratio (L/W) and to the fault area to model the change in the aspect ratio once the rupture width reaches the down-dip width limit of the fault. The width-limited effect of large-magnitude earthquakes depends on the fault dip and a regional term for the seismogenic thickness. The magnitude scaling of the aspect ratio includes a break in the magnitude scaling that is dip angle dependent. This dip angle-dependent magnitude scaling in the magnitude–area relation is modeled by a trilinear relation incorporating a dip-related transition range. The effect of the free surface was observed using a normalized depth term and parameterizing the source by the depth of the top of the fault rupture; it is more apparent in the area scaling relation. The scaling differences are related to the fault geometry, not to the rake angle, as commonly assumed. Finally, the corresponding L and W scaling relations obtained by converting the area and aspect ratio models to L and W models not only show good agreement with the previous regional scaling laws on average but also provide better fault-specific application due to the inclusion of a fault-specific dip angle and seismogenic thickness.