Obtaining informed consent is a fundamental ethical requirement in research involving human subjects, designed to ensure autonomy, respect, and the protection of participants. However, new technologies and research methodologies in Human–Computer Interaction (HCI) present unique challenges in maintaining ethical standards and require a deeper understanding of how consent practices are implemented. This scoping review provides a detailed examination of the frameworks, methodologies, and practices for obtaining informed consent in HCI. We present recognized universal principles while also discussing the ethical guidelines, and legal frameworks that underpin consent processes. Furthermore, we analyze the practices of disclosure, screening, consenting, and confirmation to assess how researchers ensure voluntary participation. The review addresses key criticisms and challenges identified in the literature, suggesting improvements and exploring alternative approaches. By offering comprehensive insights into the complexities of informed consent, we underscore the ongoing need for ethical awareness and continuous refinement of ethical conduct in HCI.
Planning and organizing user studies can be a challenge for novices and student researchers in human-computer interaction (HCI). We present a web-based study planning toolkit for researchers to support their planning and organization with human subjects. The free and open toolkit contains multiple interactive research applications for (1) the selection of quantitative and qualitative research methods in HCI, (2) automated study design planning for experimental user studies, (3) an automated informed consent generation for studies with human subjects, (4) calendar booking for experimental user studies in shared laboratories, and (5) automated participation confirmation certificates. The toolkit can be helpful for Ph.D. students in supervising novices and undergraduates who need support with their planning and study design choices. The toolkit was actively used over two semesters in multiple HCI lectures and formatively evaluated. We contribute with the whole toolkit and encourage other researchers to contribute and further improve the content.
Using biosignals through electromyography (EMG) and rendering them as feedback for hands-free interaction finally migrates to engaging virtual reality (VR) experiences for health and fitness-related applications. Previous work proposes various body locations as input sources and different output modalities for creating effective biofeedback loops. However, it is currently unknown which muscles and sensory modalities can provide optimal real-time interaction regarding the performance and perceived workload of the users. In two VR studies (N=18 and N=40) based on a Fitts’ law target selection task, we explored sensor placement at different body locations and investigate auditory, tactile, and visual feedback modalities. Objective and subjective results indicate that input performance can be improved by presenting muscle tension as simultaneous tactile and visual feedback. We contribute with recommendations for registration of isometric muscle contraction at different body locations and conclude that reproducing physiological feedback through multimodal channels can assist users interacting with EMG devices.
This paper presents the results of a user study examining the impact of biofeedback awareness on the effectiveness of stress management, utilizing Electrodermal Activity (EDA) as the primary metric within an immersive Virtual Reality (VR). Employing a between-subjects design (N=30), we probed whether informing individuals of their capacity to manipulate the VR environment’s weather impacts their physiological stress responses. Our results indicate lower EDA levels of participants who were informed of their biofeedback control than those participants who were not informed about their biofeedback control. Interestingly, the participants who were informed about the control over the environment also manifested variations in their EDA responses. Participants who were not informed of their ability to control the weather showed decreased EDA measures until the end of the biofeedback phase. This study enhances our comprehension of the significance of awareness in biofeedback in immersive settings and its potential to augment stress management techniques.
As our society ages and technology becomes increasingly omnipresent, the use of Mixed Reality (MR) in private and health-related domains inevitably encounters the older population. This intersection presents unique challenges and opportunities for the integration of MR technology into the lives of elderlies. We conducted a qualitative study (N=7) using think-aloud interviews to gain in-depth insights into the usage of MR devices by elderly people. Using thematic analysis we identified barriers and facilitators for elderly engagement with MR: emotional response, ergonomics and handling, utility, learning competence, and acceptance. Our findings highlight the roles of timing, responsiveness, and skepticism towards the technology, which can act as a deterrent to the participation of elderlies. We contribute with a refined understanding of the elderly’s interaction with MR and recommendations for elderly-centric MR technology adoption.
Electromyography (EMG) enables hands-free interactions by detecting muscle activity at different human body locations. Previous studies have demonstrated that input performance based on isometric contractions is muscle-dependent and can benefit from synchronous biofeedback. However, it remains unknown whether stimulation before interaction can help to localize and tense a muscle faster. In a response-based VR experiment (N=21), we investigated whether prior stimulation using visual or tactile cues at four different target muscles (biceps, triceps, upper leg, calf) can help reduce the time to perform isometric muscle contractions. The results show that prior stimulation decreases EMG reaction times with visual, vibrotactile, and electrotactile cues. Our experiment also revealed important findings regarding learning and fatigue at the different body locations. We provide qualitative insights into the participants’ perceptions and discuss potential reasons for the improved interaction. We contribute with implications and use cases for prior stimulated muscle activation.