This study aims to examine the impact of cooperative learning (CL) on learning outcomes, including academic achievement, high-order thinking skills, and affective behavior. In this regard, 15 first-order meta-analyses (FOM) studies were accessed using various inclusion criteria through Web of Science, Scopus, EBSCO, and Google Academic databases. The findings of FOM studies were synthesized through second order meta-analysis method. Statistical analyses were conducted under the random effects model. Heterogeneity and moderator analyses of the data set and examination of publication bias of effect sizes were performed. The results of this study reveal that CL has a moderate effect on learning outcomes (ES = 0.71 [CI = 0.55-0.87]). The impact of CL on learning outcomes was observed to statistically differ according to CL techniques, academic field, and the experimental design type of basic studies covered by FOM research.
15 January 2025 in MANAS Sosyal Araştırmalar Dergisi
The purpose of this study is to examine the impact of peer learning (PL) on student outcomes. To this end, 11 first-order meta-analysis (FOM) studies were reviewed. FOMs were accessed from the Web of Science, Scopus, Medline, Eric, Academic Search Ultimate, PsycNet, and Google Academic databases. The searches cover the years between 2000 and 2024. FOM (Factoring-Out Misconceptions) research encompasses both K-12 and higher education levels. While k=5 studies reported Cohen’s d effect size indexes (d), k=11 studies reported Hedge’s g effect size indexes (g).İn this analyses totals sixteen effect size (k=16) values obtained from FOM studies have been statistically analyzed. The research method used was second-order meta-analysis. Statistical analyses were conducted under the random model. Publication bias of effect sizes was examined. The study concluded that the impact of PL on student outcomes is weak (ES= .40 [CI= .33-0.47], p < .01). It was found that the effect sizes between PL and student outcomes have low levels of publication bias. It has been observed that PL has a higher impact on academic achievement compared to affective, professional skills, and social skills. It was also found that the effect sizes vary according to the languages of primary studies and the publication bias status of FOM studies. The group of FOMs exhibiting publication bias has a high-level effect size (while other groups have produced low-level effect sizes.
30 September 2024 in Bayburt Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi
The aim of this research is to examine the relationship between teacher leadership and academic achievement of students through meta-analysis. For this purpose, an analysis of the effect sizes of 47 independent samples obtained from a total of 54 primary studies was carried out according to the inclusion criteria. Findings revealed that there is a positive yet weak association between teacher leadership and academic achievement. The distribution of effect sizes does not differ statistically with respect to the leadership type, academic field, education level, analysis unit, participant, location, and publication type. However, the size of effects significantly differs by the education levels. Accordingly, the effect size value in terms of the relationship between teacher leadership and students' academic achievement is weak for the elementary school, with Fz = .12, while it is moderate for the university, high school, and middle school with values of Fz = .26, Fz = .38, and Fz = .30 respectively.
The aim of this study is to examine the impact of peer learning in higher education on student outcomes in the context of Turkey. For this purpose, databases such as Web of Science, Scopus, EBSCOHOST, and TR Index were used to access research focused on peer learning in the Turkish context. Additionally, to access grey literature, searches were conducted in the YÖK Thesis database, DergiPark, and Google Scholar databases in both English and Turkish. Various inclusion and exclusion criteria were developed for this study. Based on these criteria, 12 primary studies were included in the analysis. A meta-analysis was conducted to combine the statistical findings of the primary studies. This meta-analysis was conducted under the random effects model. It was found that the overall impact of peer learning on student outcomes in higher education in Turkey is at a low level with ES = .33 [CI = .19-.48]. Furthermore, it was observed that the average effect sizes statistically differed according to the types of peer learning.
25 February 2025 in Innovations in Education and Teaching International