Tidal energy conversion systems (TECS) operate under nonlinear hydrodynamics, bidirectional and often low-velocity currents, parameter variation, and restrictive marine sensing conditions, making maximum power point tracking (MPPT) both a control and deployment challenge. This review provides a control-centred critical synthesis of TECS MPPT across analytical, intelligent, metaheuristic, adaptive, and hybrid strategies. Rather than comparing algorithms solely by tracking efficiency, the literature is assessed in terms of sensing requirements, convergence behaviour, steady-state oscillation, parameter dependence, computational burden, operating-range suitability, and validation maturity. Analytical methods offer transparency and implementation simplicity but remain constrained by sensing needs or predefined relationships. Intelligent and metaheuristic approaches improve adaptation and search capability but require additional tuning, training, or computation. Hybrid architectures can balance some of these trade-offs, although their practical advantage remains insufficiently demonstrated. A key finding is that algorithmic sophistication has advanced faster than experimental maturity, with many studies still dominated by simulation and limited hardware, embedded, or long-term marine validation. Future progress should therefore prioritise robust sensor-reduced control, adaptive parameter updating, predictive operation, standardised benchmarking, reproducibility, and array-level coordination. This review establishes a validation-oriented framework for assessing MPPT strategies and supporting their transition toward deployable tidal-energy systems under realistic and variable marine operating conditions.