Hazard assessment for post‐wildfire debris flows, which are common in the steep terrain of the western United States, has focused on the susceptibility of upstream basins to generate debris flows. However, reducing public exposure to this hazard also requires an assessment of hazards in downstream areas that might be inundated during debris flow runout. Debris flow runout models are widely available, but their application to hazard assessment for post‐wildfire debris flows has not been extensively tested. Necessary inputs to these models include the total volume of the mobilized flow, flow properties (either inherent material properties or calibration coefficients), and site topography. Estimates of volume are possible in post‐event (“back calculation”) studies, yet before an event, volume is an uncertain quantity. We simulated debris flow runout for the well‐constrained 9 January 2018 Montecito event using three models (RAMMS, FLO2D, and D‐Claw) to determine the relative importance of volume and flow properties. We broke the impacted area into three domains, and for each model‐domain combination, we performed a numerical sampling study in which volume and flow properties varied within a wide, but plausible range. We assessed model performance based on inundation patterns and peak flow depths. We found all models could simulate the event with comparable results. Simulation performance was most sensitive to flow volume and less sensitive to flow properties. Our results emphasize the importance of reducing uncertainty in pre‐event estimates of flow volume for hazard assessment.
We characterize the local concentration dependence of segregation velocity and segregation flux in both size and density bidisperse gravity-driven free-surface granular flows as a function of the particle size ratio and density ratio, respectively, using discrete element method simulations. For a range of particle size ratios and inlet volume flow rates in size-bidisperse flows, the maximum segregation flux occurs at a small particle concentration less than 0.5, which decreases with increasing particle size ratio. The segregation flux increases up to a size ratio of 2.4 but plateaus from there to a size ratio of 3. In density bidisperse flows, the segregation flux is greatest at a heavy particle concentration less than 0.5, which decreases with increasing particle density ratio. The segregation flux increases with increasing density ratio for the extent of density ratios studied, up to 10. We further demonstrate that the simulation results for size-driven segregation are in accord with the predictions of the kinetic sieving segregation model of Savage and Lun [ J. Fluid Mech. 189, 311 (1988)].
Size-disperse mixtures of noncohesive particles segregate, or demix, during flow. For spherical particles, mixture segregation can be predicted based on the relative particle diameters. However, most particle systems in industry and geophysics involve nonspherical particles. Accounting for the immense range of particle shapes introduces additional parameters. As a proxy for nonspherical particles in general, we perform discrete element method simulations of gravity-driven free-surface flows of bidisperse mixtures of mm-sized particles that vary widely in their size and shape (disks, rods, and spheres). Remarkably, the propensity to segregate, measured in terms of a segregation length scale that characterizes the segregation velocity of the two species, can be predicted based on only the volume ratio of the two particle species. The segregation length scale increases linearly with the log of the volume ratio, as it does for bidisperse mixtures of spherical particles, independent of particle shape.
Segregation, or demixing, of flowing mixtures of size-disperse noncohesive spherical particles is well understood. However, most particle systems in industry and geophysics involve nonspherical particles. Here, the segregation of bidisperse mixtures of millimeter-sized particles having various shapes is characterized using discrete element method simulations of gravity-driven free-surface granular heap flow. As a proxy for nonspherical particles, we study mixtures of cylindrical particles that vary widely in both their length and diameter ratios, including both disks and rods, as well as mixtures of cylindrical and spherical particles. The propensity to segregate is measured with a segregation length scale that characterizes the segregation velocity of the two species for these types of mixtures, identical to the approach for mixtures of spherical particles. Surprisingly, segregation can be predicted based solely on the volume ratio of the two species, regardless of particle shape. The segregation length scale increases linearly with the log of the volume ratio for volume ratios varying from 0.1 to 10 in the same way as it does for bidisperse mixtures of spherical particles. Thus, segregation properties based on spherical particles can be directly applied to nonspherical particles.
We simulated the concurrent rapid motion of landslides on an unstable slope at Barry Arm, Alaska. Movement of landslides into the adjacent fjord displaced fjord water and generated a tsunami, which propagated out of Barry Arm. Rather than assuming an initial sea surface height, velocity, and location for the tsunami, we generated the tsunami directly using a model capable of simulating the dynamics of both water and landslide material. The fjord below most of the landslide source area was occupied by the Barry Glacier until about 2012; therefore, our direct simulation of tsunami generation by landslide motion required new topographic and bathymetric data, which was collected in 2020. The topographic data also constrained landslide geometries and volumes. We considered four scenarios based on two landslide volumes and two landslide mobilities—a more mobile, contractive landslide and a less mobile, noncontractive landslide. The larger of the two volumes is 689 × 106 cubic meters (m3)—larger than the volume estimate in a previous study—and reflects the largest plausible volume given current observational data. The considered scenario that generated the largest wave heights resulted in forecast wave heights of over 200 meters (m) in the northern part of Barry Arm, adjacent to the landslide source area and runup on the opposite fjord wall in excess of 500 m. Simulated wave heights in excess of 5 m in southern Barry Arm and in Harriman Fjord occurred within 10–15 minutes (min) of landslide motion. The simulated tsunami reached Whittier, Alaska, approximately 20 min after initial rapid landslide motion, with peak heights of just over 2 m in Passage Fjord, 500 m offshore Whittier, occurring 26 min after initial rapid motion. Time of peak wave heights was consistent with previous modeling. Although results are preliminary and can be refined with additional observations and analyses, they provide a refined assessment of the upper bound of the hazard presented by the Barry Arm landslides. The results herein support the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s National Tsunami Warning Center mission to detect, forecast, and warn for tsunamis in Alaska.
Debris flow runout poses a hazard to life and infrastructure. The expansion of human population into mountainous areas and onto alluvial fans increases the need to predict and mitigate debris flow runout hazards. Debris flows on unconfined alluvial fans can exhibit spontaneous self‐channelization through levee formation that reduces lateral spreading and extends runout distances compared to unchannelized flows. Here we modify the D‐Claw shallow flow model in two ways that are hypothesized to generate levees. We evaluate these modifications with observations from a large‐scale flume experiment. We investigate model performance when including the effect of two different friction sub‐models, as well as the inclusion of segregation effects on granular permeability. Results show that, for a wide range of plausible model input parameters, simulations including the effects of segregation promoted modeled levee formation, whereas simulations without the effects of segregation did not create levees. Further, using a forward predictive framework, simulations with the effects of segregation were more likely to better model the magnitude of debris flow depth and runout distance, whereas simulation timing of the debris flow was affected by the choice of friction sub‐model. Our results indicate that including the effects of segregation on granular permeability can improve the likelihood of better predictions of debris flow depth and runout prior to an event occurring.