We have resolved long-standing discrepancies between the theoretical and experimental crystal structures of boron carbide . Theoretical studies predict that should be stoichiometric and have the highest symmetry of the boron carbides. Experimentally, is a semiconductor and many defect states have been reported, particularly in the CBC chain. Reconciling the disordered states of the chain, the chemical composition, and the lowest-energy state is problematic. We have solved this problem by constructing a structural model where approximately three-quarters of the unit cells contain (CBC) and one-quarter of them contain . This structural model explains many experimental results, such as the large thermal factors in x-ray diffraction and the broadening of the Raman spectra, without introducing unstable CBB chains. The model also solves the energy-gap problem. We show that there are many arrangements of these two types of unit cells, which are energetically almost degenerate. This demonstrates that boron carbides are well described by a geometrically frustrated system, similar to that proposed for -rhombohedral boron.
Recent discoveries of supposedly pure -tetragonal boron require to revisit its structure. The system is also interesting with respect to a new type of geometrical frustration in elemental crystals, which was found in -rhombohedral boron. Based on density functional theory calculations, the present study has resolved the structural and thermodynamic characteristics of pure -tetragonal boron. Different from -rhombohedral boron, the conditions for stable covalent bonding (a band gap and completely filled valence bands) are almost fulfilled at a composition with two interstitial sites occupied. This indicates that the ground state of pure -tetragonal boron is stoichiometric. However, the covalent condition is not perfectly fulfilled because nonbonding in-gap states exist that cannot be eliminated. The half occupation of the sites yields a macroscopic amount of residual entropy, which is as large as that of -rhombohedral boron. Therefore -tetragonal boron can be classified as an elemental crystal with geometrical frustration. Deviations from stoichiometry can occur only at finite temperatures. Thermodynamic considerations show that deviations from the stoichiometric composition () are small and positive. For the reported high-pressure syntheses conditions is predicted to be about 0.1 to 0.2. An important difference between pure and C- or N-containing -tetragonal boron is found in the occupation of interstitial sites: the pure form prefers to occupy the sites, whereas in C- or N-containing forms, a mixture of , , and sites are occupied. The present article provides relations of site occupation, values, and lattice parameters, which enable us to identify pure -tetragonal boron and distinguish the pure form from other ones.
Boron bulk crystals are marked by exceptional structural complexity and unusual related physical phenomena. Recent reports of hydrogenated α-tetragonal and a new δ-orthorhombic boron B52 phase have raised many fundamental questions.
Using density functional theory calculations it is shown that hydrogenated α-tetragonal boron has at least two stable stoichiometric compositions, B51H7 and B51H3. Thermodynamic modeling was used to qualitatively reproduce the two-step phase transition reported by Ekimov et al. [J. Mater. Res. 31, 2773 (2016)] upon annealing, which corresponds to successive transitions from B51H7 to B51H3 to pure B52. The so obtained δ-orthorhombic boron is an ordered, low-temperature phase and α-tetragonal boron is a disordered, high-temperature phase of B52. The two phases are connected by an order-disorder transition, that is associated with the migration of interstitial boron atoms. Atom migration is usually suppressed in strongly bound, covalent crystals. It is shown that the migration of boron atoms is likely to be assisted by the migration of hydrogen atoms upon annealing. These results are in excellent agreement with the above mentioned experiment and they represent an important step forward for the understanding of boron and hydrogenated boron crystals. They further open a new avenue to control or remove the intrinsic defects of covalently bound crystals by utilizing volatile, foreign atoms.
12 April 2017 in Japanese Journal of Applied Physics
Pseudo-cubic tetragonal boron, which may be another form of boron allotropes, has recently been discovered under high pressure and high temperature conditions. In this paper, the structure of pseudo-cubic tetragonal boron is studied by density-functional-theory (DFT) calculation. The structure is abnormal compared with other boron allotropes in many respects, making it difficult to comprehend. The lattice is very close to a cubic lattice, such that the icosahedra are largely distorted along the c -axis. Such distortions are normally not favorable for boron crystals; in fact, the present calculations supported this. The reported positions of partially occupied interstitial sites render the inter icosahedral bonds unusually long or short, which were again not supported by the present calculations. Furthermore, the potential of involving impurities is unlikely in terms of the formation energy and lattice parameters. Therefore, the structure of pseudo-cubic tetragonal boron was not proven by calculation, despite this extensive study. Something may be overlooked in the present structural model, or something unusual may have happened in this structure, the solution of which is left as an open question.