1 January 2022 in Russian Annals of Ophthalmology
Most foreign authors currently recommend the protocol and charts developed for the Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study (ETDRS) as the gold standard for evaluation of visual acuity (VA) in clinical trials and studies. Not every medical facility has equipment required for performing visometry by that method, while Sivtsev tables are found universally. To compare ETDRS and the more common Sivtsev visometry methods. The study included 100 volunteers - students of the Sechenov University. All participants were examined for VA in both eyes without correction using ETDRS "R" chart and Sivtsev table. Visometry with "R" ETDRS chart involved calculation of the number of named letters, then the number was translated into logarithmic notation by the conventional method. Sivtsev visometry findings were translated into logarithmic notation by two methods: first - standard, line-by-line, second - experimental, letter-by-letter. Subjects were divided into two groups: high VA (higher than 0.4 in decimal scale) and low VA - everyone else. The best agreement with ETDRS was found in letter-by-letter method of Sivtsev table interpretation, especially in the group with high VA with the lowest 95% limits of agreement (LoA) of ±0.157 logMAR, or 8 letters on ETDRS. Clinically significant were also LoA in comparison of ETDRS with line-by-line calculation method in the group with high VA and in letter-by-letter method without dividing groups by VA. The use of Sivtsev table in standardized multicenter studies is only reasonable when the ETDRS charts are unavailable.
1 January 2022 in Russian Annals of Ophthalmology
23 April 2024 in Russian Annals of Ophthalmology
ETDRS charts with logarithmic notation are widely used for measuring visual acuity in clinical studies worldwide. However, the distribution of measurement results often deviates from normal, limiting the applicability of parametric statistical methods, which are more powerful than the non-parametric ones. In cases of significant skewness, raw data can undergo power transformation with varying exponents (λ), as described by J.W. Tukey. The optimal transformation is considered the one that best normalizes the data. The formulas for common visual acuity notations coincide with specific members of Tukey’s power function family to within a sign (decimal: λ=–1.0; logarithmic: λ=0). Purpose. This study uses Tukey’s power transformations to identify the visual acuity notation most suitable for parametric statistical methods. Material and methods. The study analyzed both original measurement results and reconstructed visual acuity data from several large multicenter studies: the Central India Eye and Medical Study (CIEMS) — 4711 participants; the Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study (ETDRS) — 3710 participants; the Age-related Eye Disease Study 2 (AREDS2) — 4203 participants. Original data were obtained by measuring visual acuity in both eyes of 100 healthy volunteers using the ETDRS protocol. Visual acuity distribution for each multicenter study was reconstructed from histograms in the corresponding publications. Results. In all cases, the exponent for the optimal transformation was closer to that for decimal notation (–1.0) than logarithmic notation (0): CIEMS — λ=–1.31; ETDRS — λ=–0.8; AREDS2 — λ=–0.88; original data — λ=–1.66. The optimal transformation did not pass the Shapiro-Wilk test for normality in any of the cases. The distribution closest to normal was obtained when analyzing the original data, likely due to the Shapiro-Wilk test’s sensitivity to repeating values. Conclusion. The authors recommend using decimal notation for the statistical processing and presentation of visual acuity data, as it is more appropriate for parametric statistical methods.