18 August 2020 in Depiction of Health
Background and Objectives: Clinicians rely on clinical guidelines for decision making. Carefully formulated clinical guidelines are the result of a combination of relevant researches that links evidence to clinical practice. The purpose of this study was to determine the barriers to the use of clinical guidelines from viewpoints of residents. Material and Methods: This study is a qualitative phenomenological study that examines the experiences of the residents of Urology Department of Imam Reza Hospital in Tabriz City of Iran. The sampling method was purposive. Qualitative content analysis used to analyze this study. To validate the results, the interviews were repeatedly read and the opinions of colleagues were regularly used. External monitoring was used to increase its reliability. Results: 11 semi-structured interviews were conducted with the urology residents of Imam Reza Hospital. The results showed that the challenges and barriers to the implementation of clinical guidelines were classified into three main themes: 1. Structural challenges: doctors' distrust of clinical guidelines, Illegitimacy and lack of local clinical guidelines. 2. Executive challenges: routine processes, Lack of agreeable atmosphere, resistance to change among physicians and high number of patients and lack of facilities. 3. Educational challenges: lack of residency time and lack of practical educational structure for students. Conclusion: Given the importance of proper implementation of clinical guidelines as a link to up-to-date knowledge and practice and given the existing structural, executive and educational problems, obstacles and challenges, it is hoped that researchers, managers, policymakers and Patients should take steps to remove barriers to the proper implementation of clinical guidelines and provide high quality services to patients.
13 June 2022 in Depiction of Health
Background. Clinical guidelines are texts developed to assist both physicians and patients in deciding on the most appropriate health care. This study evaluated the compliance of emergency performance with clinical guidelines at Sina Medical Training Center in Tabriz. Methods. This descriptive-analytical study was conducted on a case study at Sina Hospital under the supervision of Tabriz University of Medical Sciences. In the first stage, as a research tool, a checklist, approved in terms of validity and reliability, was set up to evaluate clinical guidelines. The second phase of this study was cross-sectional, conducted in a period of one month. All medical records of people referring to level 1 and 2 triage were reviewed based on the checklist and the data were entered into SPSS software, and since the normality of the data was confirmed, descriptive statistics and parametric tests (t-test and ANOVA) were used to analyze the data. Results. Considering the mean (1.72 ± 0.097) in this study, the adherence to clinical guidelines seems to be higher than average. The results also showed that there was no significant relationship between any of the demographic variables and the mean score of total compliance with the guidelines (P-value> 0.05). However, among other variables, a significant relationship was found between the place of the patient's visit as well as the type and time of patient assignment on the one hand and the average score of total compliance with the guidelines (P-value<0.05). With regard to the results of the regression test, patient’s place of visit was the only appropriate variable to predict the average of the total observance of emergency clinical guidelines (P-value<0.05). Conclusion. Considering the effect of influential variables such as location of the patient's visit, the time and type of patient assignment on the observance of the guidelines and the increasing improvement of the situation of these variables, the average observance of clinical guidelines can be improved further
15 January 2021 in Research Square
Background: Clinical guidelines are a systematic collection of the latest and most authoritative scientific evidence that describes thediagnostic steps and methods of clinical treatment of a patient in a categorized manner, taking into account priorities, effectiveness, and cost-effectiveness. It is necessary to explore and categorize influencing factors in the implementation of clinical guidelines worldwide to pave the way for their implementation in medical centers.Methods: In this systematic review we will search Scopus, PubMed, Web of sciences, clinical key, Google Scholar (Search Engine as well as Iranian data bases including: Magiran, SID, Irandoc, Iranmedex. We will include all related original studies that generally cover all relevant outcomes to determine the factors influencing the success of the implementation of clinical guidelines and to identify barriers and facilitators as well.The quality of the included studies will be assessed by appropriate Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) Checklists according to the type of studies. The selection and appraisal process will be performed by two members of the research team; and in case of disagreement between the two researchers, the third person will review the articles.Discussion: Identifying the facilitators and factors affecting the implementation of clinical guidelines as well as the related obstacles is expected to pave the way for helping managers, policymakers and health planners in implementing them correctly.Systematic review registration: CRD42020201350