As a result of rising global food and energy insecurity, investors are increasingly seeking new opportunities in tropical developing countries endowed with comparatively cheap and abundant land resources. Predominantly targeting the agriculture and forestry sectors, these investments could make valuable contributions to the economies of developing countries. However, with most investors opting for plantation-oriented business models, in the context of weak governance regimes within many host countries, many fear that these investments may instead exacerbate socio-economic vulnerabilities and processes of environmental degradation. Therefore, there is a need to explore alternative upstream business models that are more inclusive of the poor and are more aligned with emergent green growth objectives. This systematic map aims to contribute to this debate by cataloging empirical studies conducted on the sustainability of different upstream business models in the agriculture and forestry sector (e.g. involving the cultivation of raw materials). The mapping will offer an overview of the type and quantity of research conducted to date, remaining knowledge gaps, and areas warranting a systematic review.
This chapter explores the dynamics of smallholder inclusion in contract farming arrangements. Existing literature dominantly evaluates benefits of contract farming for those who have already entered the contract. The literature tends to assume that the participating farmers are likely to possess more assets and access to labor and resources, in comparison to non-participating farmers, in the same geography. However, specific conditions through which less well-off smallholder farmers could participate and benefit from the contract farming remain elusive. Drawing from a case study of the sugarcane sector in Mozambique, this chapter reveals that landholding size, household labor availability and gender have significantly influenced smallholder participation in contracted sugar production over time, confirming the literature that relatively better-off farmers tend to participate and benefit from contract farming. At the same time, the case study also highlights that a sugar mill’s production model called block farming has benefited female and less well-off farmers, as it worked to alleviate risks for smallholders to enter the contract farming model. The chapter underscores the need for more attention to be paid to block farming and similar production models in different contexts to promote inclusion of smallholders in contract farming policies and research.