Natalia Radionova

Natalia Radionova

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Natalia Radionova

Institut für Arbeitsmedizin, Sozialmedizin und Versorgungsforschung, Universitätsklinikum Tübingen, Tübingen, Deutschland

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

5Years (2022-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
29 May 2023 in Journal of Medical Internet Research
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
NRNatalia Radionova
Natalia Radionova
EÖEylem Ög
Eylem Ög
AWAnna-Jasmin Wetzel
Anna-Jasmin Wetzel
MRMonika A. Rieger
Monika A. Rieger
CPChristine Preiser
Christine Preiser
Background: Symptom checkers (SCs) for laypersons’ self-assessment and preliminary self-diagnosis are widely used by the public. Little is known about the impact of these tools on health care professionals (HCPs) in primary care and their work. This is relevant to understanding how technological changes might affect the working world and how this is linked to work-related psychosocial demands and resources for HCPs. Objective: This scoping review aimed to systematically explore the existing publications on the impacts of SCs on HCPs in primary care and to identify knowledge gaps. Methods: We used the Arksey and O’Malley framework. We based our search string on the participant, concept, and context scheme and searched PubMed (MEDLINE) and CINAHL in January and June 2021. We performed a reference search in August 2021 and a manual search in November 2021. We included publications of peer-reviewed journals that focused on artificial intelligence- or algorithm-based self-diagnosing apps and tools for laypersons and had primary care or nonclinical settings as a relevant context. The characteristics of these studies were described numerically. We used thematic analysis to identify core themes. We followed the PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews) checklist to report the study. Results: Of the 2729 publications identified through initial and follow-up database searches, 43 full texts were screened for eligibility, of which 9 were included. Further 8 publications were included through manual search. Two publications were excluded after receiving feedback in the peer-review process. Fifteen publications were included in the final sample, which comprised 5 (33%) commentaries or nonresearch publications, 3 (20%) literature reviews, and 7 (47%) research publications. The earliest publications stemmed from 2015. We identified 5 themes. The theme finding prediagnosis comprised the comparison between SCs and physicians. We identified the performance of the diagnosis and the relevance of human factors as topics. In the theme layperson-technology relationship, we identified potentials for laypersons’ empowerment and harm through SCs. Our analysis showed potential disruptions of the physician-patient relationship and uncontested roles of HCPs in the theme (impacts on) physician-patient relationship. In the theme impacts on HCPs’ tasks, we described the reduction or increase in HCPs’ workload. We identified potential transformations of HCPs’ work and impacts on the health care system in the theme future role of SCs in health care. Conclusions: The scoping review approach was suitable for this new field of research. The heterogeneity of technologies and wordings was challenging. We identified research gaps in the literature regarding the impact of artificial intelligence– or algorithm-based self-diagnosing apps or tools on the work of HCPs in primary care. Further empirical studies on HCPs’ lived experiences are needed, as the current literature depicts expectations rather than empirical findings.

18 November 2024 in JMIR Human Factors
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
CPChristine Preiser
Christine Preiser
NRNatalia Radionova
Natalia Radionova
EÖEylem Ög
Eylem Ög
RKRoland Koch
Roland Koch
MKMalte Klemmt
Malte Klemmt
MRMonika A. Rieger
Monika A. Rieger
Background: Symptom checkers are designed for laypeople and promise to provide a preliminary diagnosis, a sense of urgency, and a suggested course of action. Objective: We used the international symptom checker app (SCA) Ada App as an example to answer the following question: How do general practitioners (GPs) experience the SCA in relation to the macro, meso, and micro level of their daily work, and how does this interact with work-related psychosocial resources and demands? Methods: We conducted 8 semistructured interviews with GPs in Germany between December 2020 and February 2022. We analyzed the data using the integrative basic method, an interpretative-reconstructive method, to identify core themes and modes of thematization. Results: Although most GPs in this study were open to digitization in health care and their practice, only one was familiar with the SCA. GPs considered the SCA as part of the “unorganized stage” of patients’ searching about their conditions. Some preferred it to popular search engines. They considered it relevant to their work as soon as the SCA would influence patients’ decisions to see a doctor. Some wanted to see the results of the SCA in advance in order to decide on the patient’s next steps. GPs described the diagnostic process as guided by shared decision-making, with the GP taking the lead and the patient deciding. They saw diagnosis as an act of making sense of data, which the SCA would not be able to do, despite the huge amounts of data. Conclusions: GPs took a techno-pragmatic view of SCA. They operate in a health care system of increasing scarcity. They saw the SCA as a potential work-related resource if it helped them to reduce administrative tasks and unnecessary patient contacts. The SCA was seen as a potential work-related demand if it increased workload, for example, if it increased patients’ anxiety, was too risk-averse, or made patients more insistent on their own opinions.

22 April 2025 in Zentralblatt für Arbeitsmedizin, Arbeitsschutz und Ergonomie
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
CPChristine Preiser
Christine Preiser
NRNatalia Radionova
Natalia Radionova
MRMonika A. Rieger
Monika A. Rieger
Zusammenfassung: Hintergrund: Arbeitsschutz und Arbeitsmedizin sind ein multidisziplinäres Feld, in dem Betriebsärzt*innen (BÄ) laut Professionstheorien die einzige Profession sind. Bisher ist wenig über das professionelle Selbstverständnis von BÄ bekannt. Diese Studie befasst sich mit der Forschungsfrage: Was lernen wir aus der Sekundäranalyse qualitativer Daten über das professionelle Selbstverständnis von BÄ? Methoden: Wir werteten qualitative Daten aus drei früheren Studien des Instituts im Zuge einer Sekundäranalyse erneut aus. Die Studien hatten verschiedene thematische Ausrichtungen: das Verhältnis von BÄ und Hausärzt*innen, die Psychosomatische Sprechstunde im Betrieb und die Zurverfügungstellung und Inanspruchnahme der arbeitsmedizinischen Vorsorge. Die Originaldaten wurden 2009–2012 erhoben. Die Sekundäranalyse basierte auf fünf Fokusgruppendiskussionen und einem Interview mit BÄ in Deutschland. 23 BÄ sind Teil der Sekundäranalyse. In allen Daten wurde das professionelle Selbstverständnis von BÄ thematisiert, stand aber nicht im Fokus der Studien. Wir wendeten das integrative Basisverfahren an, um die Daten feinsprachlich erneut auszuwerten. Ergebnisse: BÄ kritisierten das fehlende Wissen über ihre Arbeit bei anderen Stakeholder*innen. Sie beschrieben mehrere Arbeitsstile von BÄ innerhalb von Betrieben: kämpferische, aushandelnde und zurückgezogene BÄ. Sie positionierten sich zuallererst als Ärzt*innen und nutzten die ärztliche Schweigepflicht und Ethik, um sich gegen Instrumentalisierungsversuche durch Dritte abzugrenzen. Sie diskutierten die Bedenken der Beschäftigten, BÄ könnten auf Seiten der Arbeitgebenden stehen. Sie machten deutlich, dass ihre Arbeit zwar teilweise vom Willen der Arbeitgebenden abhänge in Arbeitsmedizin zu investieren. Die Weisungsfreiheit von BÄ mindere dies aber nicht. Diskussion: BÄ unserer Studie thematisierten ein „status triangle dilemma“. Wir identifizierten fünf Strategien, mit denen sie das Dilemma navigieren: eine pragmatische Orientierung, die vertragliche Gestaltung der Rahmenbedingungen, das Bewerben des Nutzens der betriebsärztlichen Arbeit, die Selbstpositionierung als Ärzt*innen, und das Umdeuten des Dilemmas in eine einzigartige Kompetenz. Letzteres kann nicht nur als eine Einladung verstanden werden, die Zukunft der Arbeitsmedizin zu diskutieren, sondern auch der Frage nachzugehen, was andere medizinische Fachrichtungen von BÄ lernen können, um mit Rollenkonflikten umzugehen und Handlungsstrategien zu gestalten.

3 May 2022 in JMIR Preprints
Verified
Preprint
Open access
NRNatalia Radionova
Natalia Radionova
EÖEylem Ög
Eylem Ög
AWAnna-Jasmin Wetzel
Anna-Jasmin Wetzel
MRMonika A. Rieger
Monika A. Rieger
CPChristine Preiser
Christine Preiser
BACKGROUND Symptom checkers (SCs) for laypersons’ self-assessment and preliminary self-diagnosis are widely used by the public. Little is known about the impact of these tools on health care professionals (HCPs) in primary care and their work. This is relevant to understanding how technological changes might affect the working world and how this is linked to work-related psychosocial demands and resources for HCPs. OBJECTIVE This scoping review aimed to systematically explore the existing publications on the impacts of SCs on HCPs in primary care and to identify knowledge gaps. METHODS We used the Arksey and O’Malley framework. We based our search string on the participant, concept, and context scheme and searched PubMed (MEDLINE) and CINAHL in January and June 2021. We performed a reference search in August 2021 and a manual search in November 2021. We included publications of peer-reviewed journals that focused on artificial intelligence- or algorithm-based self-diagnosing apps and tools for laypersons and had primary care or nonclinical settings as a relevant context. The characteristics of these studies were described numerically. We used thematic analysis to identify core themes. We followed the PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews) checklist to report the study. RESULTS Of the 2729 publications identified through initial and follow-up database searches, 43 full texts were screened for eligibility, of which 9 were included. Further 8 publications were included through manual search. Two publications were excluded after receiving feedback in the peer-review process. Fifteen publications were included in the final sample, which comprised 5 (33%) commentaries or nonresearch publications, 3 (20%) literature reviews, and 7 (47%) research publications. The earliest publications stemmed from 2015. We identified 5 themes. The theme finding prediagnosis comprised the comparison between SCs and physicians. We identified the performance of the diagnosis and the relevance of human factors as topics. In the theme layperson-technology relationship, we identified potentials for laypersons’ empowerment and harm through SCs. Our analysis showed potential disruptions of the physician-patient relationship and uncontested roles of HCPs in the theme (impacts on) physician-patient relationship. In the theme impacts on HCPs’ tasks, we described the reduction or increase in HCPs’ workload. We identified potential transformations of HCPs’ work and impacts on the health care system in the theme future role of SCs in health care. CONCLUSIONS The scoping review approach was suitable for this new field of research. The heterogeneity of technologies and wordings was challenging. We identified research gaps in the literature regarding the impact of artificial intelligence– or algorithm-based self-diagnosing apps or tools on the work of HCPs in primary care. Further empirical studies on HCPs’ lived experiences are needed, as the current literature depicts expectations rather than empirical findings.

14 February 2024 in JMIR Preprints
Verified
Preprint
Open access
CPChristine Preiser
Christine Preiser
NRNatalia Radionova
Natalia Radionova
EÖEylem Ög
Eylem Ög
RKRoland Koch
Roland Koch
MKMalte Klemmt
Malte Klemmt
MRMonika A. Rieger
Monika A. Rieger
BACKGROUND Symptom checkers are designed for laypeople and promise to provide a preliminary diagnosis, a sense of urgency, and a suggested course of action. OBJECTIVE We used the international symptom checker app (SCA) Ada App as an example to answer the following question: How do general practitioners (GPs) experience the SCA in relation to the macro, meso, and micro level of their daily work, and how does this interact with work-related psychosocial resources and demands? METHODS We conducted 8 semistructured interviews with GPs in Germany between December 2020 and February 2022. We analyzed the data using the integrative basic method, an interpretative-reconstructive method, to identify core themes and modes of thematization. RESULTS Although most GPs in this study were open to digitization in health care and their practice, only one was familiar with the SCA. GPs considered the SCA as part of the “unorganized stage” of patients’ searching about their conditions. Some preferred it to popular search engines. They considered it relevant to their work as soon as the SCA would influence patients’ decisions to see a doctor. Some wanted to see the results of the SCA in advance in order to decide on the patient’s next steps. GPs described the diagnostic process as guided by shared decision-making, with the GP taking the lead and the patient deciding. They saw diagnosis as an act of making sense of data, which the SCA would not be able to do, despite the huge amounts of data. CONCLUSIONS GPs took a techno-pragmatic view of SCA. They operate in a health care system of increasing scarcity. They saw the SCA as a potential work-related resource if it helped them to reduce administrative tasks and unnecessary patient contacts. The SCA was seen as a potential work-related demand if it increased workload, for example, if it increased patients’ anxiety, was too risk-averse, or made patients more insistent on their own opinions.