While the burden caused by air pollution in urban areas is well documented, the origin of this pollution and therefore the responsibility of the urban areas in generating this pollution is still a subject of scientific discussion. Source Apportionment represents a useful technique to quantify the city responsibility but the approaches and applications are not harmonized, therefore not comparable, resulting in confusing and sometimes contradicting interpretations. In this work, we analyze how different source apportionment approaches apply to the urban scale and how their building elements and parameters are defined and set. We discuss in particular the options available in terms of indicator, receptor, source and methodology. We show that different choices for these options lead to very large differences in terms of outcome. In average over the 150 EU large cities selected in our study, the choices made for the indicator, the receptor and the source each lead to an average factor 2 difference. We also show that temporal and spatial averaging processes applied to the air quality indicator, especially when diverging source apportionments are aggregated into a single number lead to favor strategies that target background sources while occulting actions that would be efficient at the city center. We stress that methodological choices and assumptions most often lead to a systematic and important underestimation of the city responsibility, with important implications. Indeed, if cities are seen as a minor actor, plans will target in priority the background at the expense of potentially effective local actions.
While the burden caused by air pollution in urban areas is well documented, the origin of this pollution and therefore the responsibility of the urban areas in generating this pollution is still a subject of scientific discussion. Source Apportionment represents a useful technique to quantify the city responsibility but the approaches and applications are not harmonized, therefore not comparable, resulting in confusing and sometimes contradicting interpretations. In this work, we analyze how different source apportionment approaches apply to the urban scale and how their building elements and parameters are defined and set. We discuss in particular the options available in terms of indicator, receptor, source and methodology. We show that different choices for these options lead to very large differences in terms of outcome. In average over the 150 EU large cities selected in our study, the choices made for the indicator, the receptor and the source each lead to an average factor 2 difference. We also show that temporal and spatial averaging processes applied to the air quality indicator, especially when diverging source apportionments are aggregated into a single number lead to favor strategies that target background sources while occulting actions that would be efficient at the city center. We stress that methodological choices and assumptions most often lead to a systematic and important underestimation of the city responsibility, with important implications. Indeed, if cities are seen as a minor actor, plans will target in priority the background at the expense of potentially effective local actions.
Air pollution is one of the main causes of damages to human health in Europe with an estimate of about 380 000 premature deaths per year in the EU28, as the result of exposure to fine particulate matter (PM2.5) only. In this work, we focus on one specific region in Europe, the Po basin, a region where chemical regimes are the most complex, showing important non-linear processes, especially those related to interactions between NOx and NH3. We analyse the sensitivities of PM2.5 to NOx and NH3 emissions by means of a set of EMEP simulations performed with different levels of emission reductions, from 25 % up to a total switch-off of those emissions. Both single and combined precursor reduction scenarios are applied to determine the most efficient emission reduction strategies and quantify the interactions between NOx and NH3 emission reductions. The results confirmed the peculiarity of secondary PM2.5 formation in the Po basin, characterised by contrasting chemical regimes within distances of few (hundreds of) kilometres, as well as strong non-linear responses to emission reductions during wintertime. One of the striking results is the increase of the PM2.5 concentration levels when NOx emission reductions are applied in NOx-rich areas, such as the surroundings of Bergamo. The increased oxidative capacity of the atmosphere is the cause of the increase of PM2.5 induced by a reduction in NOx emission. This process can have contributed to the absence of significant PM2.5 concentration decrease during the COVID-19 lockdowns in many European cities. It is important to account for this process when designing air quality plans, since it could well lead to transitionary increases in PM2.5 at some locations in winter as NOx emission reduction measures are gradually implemented. While PM2.5 responses to NOx and NH3 emission reduction show large variations seasonally and spatially, these responses remain close to linear, i.e. proportional to the emission reduction levels, at least up to −50 % because secondary aerosol formation chemical regimes are not modified by those relatively moderate ranges.