This paper presents a user‐friendly rapid prediction tool of damage to struck and striking vessels in a ship collision event. To do this, the so‐called upper bound theorem is applied to calculate internal forces and energies of any substructure involved in the ships crushing process. At each increment of indentation, the total crushing force is transmitted to the external dynamics MCOL program, which calculates the global ship motion correction by solving the hydrodynamic force equilibrium equations. As a first step, the paper gives a brief description of the upper bound method originally developed for perpendicular collisions and recently enhanced for oblique ones. Then, the theory developed in MCOL program for large rotational ship movements is detailed. By comparing results obtained with and without MCOL, the importance of hydrodynamic effects is highlighted. Some simulation results are compared with results provided by classical nonlinear finite element calculations. Finally, by using the developed analytical tool, which mixes internal and external dynamics, different crushing scenarios including oblique collisions are investigated and the influence of some collision parameters like longitudinal and vertical impact location, impact angle, and struck ship velocity is studied.
This paper presents a literature review of analytical, numerical, and experimental methods for evaluating the structural response of Offshore Wind Turbines (OWT's) during ship collision events. The different energy transfer mechanisms involved throughout a collision against fixed or floating OWT substructures are examined, whilst documenting some of the most common procedures in the assessment of wind load effects, soil–structure interaction, mooring lines contribution and hydrodynamic coupling. A survey of internal mechanics and external dynamics approaches developed for ship-structures collision events is carried out with a discussion on their potential application in analyses involving different types of substructures. Moreover, different hydrodynamic coupling schemes found in the literature are studied, highlighting the importance of hydro-effects in the collision analysis. Common practices in the use of metallic and cementitious material constitutive models in ship-collision analysis are also presented, whereas the structural behaviour of reinforced concrete structures submitted to impact loads, which has been rarely studied outside high-velocity impact/blast applications, is discussed in the current context. Finally, some of the most important limitations of the analytical and numerical models used in ship-OWT collisions are identified, from which suggestions are provided for future research endeavors.
SOLAS2020 damage stability regulations are based on probabilistic damage distributions. Those originate from the pooled analysis of collision accidents across a fleet with bias towards cargo ships. This paper introduces a method that accounts for collision-based crashworthiness on ship damage distributions. The method reshapes statistical SOLAS damage distributions for a given ship or structural details for a reference ship section and her reinforced version. Damage reductions may differ depending on ship characteristics and operational scenarios. To mitigate this, a high number of collision scenarios was simulated using the super-element method. It is shown that risk control in terms of damage reduction over the whole range of damages is possible by adding a double hull or by deck reinforcement. Damage reduction is quantified by damage stability analysis of a cruise vessel. It is concluded that installing a double hull on ship vulnerable zones leads to increased A-index.