The imperative of achieving net zero carbon emissions is driving the transition to renewable energy sources. However, this often leads to carbon tunnel vision, overlooking broader sustainability impacts. To enable these broader impacts to be considered, we have developed a generic approach to assist renewable energy project proponents and assessors with evaluating how project-level decisions (e.g., emissions management, water management, land use) impact the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). This is achieved via “yes/no” answers to a set of approximately 60 diagnostic survey questions, resulting in an assessment of (i) which SDGs are impacted by a proposed renewable energy project and (ii) which project-level decisions impact each SDG and whether this impact is positive, negative or neutral, highlighting any areas of concern and opportunities for improvement. To maximise the usefulness and impact of the approach, it is designed to cater to all major renewables (biomass, hydropower, solar, geothermal, wind, wave and tidal) and is implemented in a user-friendly ex-ante assessment tool in MS Excel that is freely available on GitHub. The utility of the approach and tool are illustrated via three case studies, including a large-scale solar farm, biogas production from wastewater plants, and an offshore wind farm. Results show that the case study projects impact the SDGs in different and unique ways and that different project-level decisions are most influential, highlighting the value of the proposed approach and tool to provide insight into specific projects and their sustainability implications, as well as which actions can be taken to increase project sustainability.