1 December 2022 in Jurnal Konstitusi
The position of the Constitutional Court Regulation (PMK) in the hierarchy of laws and regulations is not strictly regulated, so it is not known where it is located, or which institution has the right to conduct a judicial review of it. Therefore, this study will examine three things, namely: (i) the position of PMK; (ii) the implications of PMK that have not been promulgated; and (iii) the institution entitled to conduct a judicial review of PMK. The research method used is the normative legal research method. The result is that PMK has a "conditional" position equivalent to a presidential regulation because it has the same function. Despite having the same "conditional" position, the PMK has so far not been able to be tested by any institution because it has not been promulgated in the State Gazette, which should also imply that it cannot bind the public. Therefore, PMK should be promulgated in the State Gazette to bind the public, and the institution entitled to examine it is the Supreme Court. That way, the parties to the proceedings at the Constitutional Court will obtain legal certainty and protection.
21 March 2021 in Mimbar Keadilan
This study aims to analyze the application of morality to legal practice in Indonesia. This is because the reality of the rule of law today is dominated by a positivist-legalistic phenomenon that prioritizes text but darkens morality's meaning in law. Morality in law seems to be immersed in legal practice that deifies the textual law but neglects the law's moral essence. This research is juridical-normative research oriented towards coherence between the principles of law based on morality and legal norms and legal practice in society. This research's novelty is the development of morality in the rule of law practice by prioritizing two aspects, namely the integrative mechanism aspect of Harry C. Bredemeier with the progressive law of Satjipto Rahardjo. This study emphasizes that efforts to develop law must not forget the elements of morality development. This study's conclusions highlight that the development of law and morality will run optimally by upholding the law as an integrative mechanism and applying progressive law as a solution in facing the lethargy of the Indonesian nation.Keywords: integrative mechanism; morality; progressive lawAbstrak Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk menganalisis penerapan moralitas pada praktik berhukum di Indonesia. Hal ini dikarenakan bahwa realitas praktik berhukum saat ini didominasi oleh fenomena positivistik-legalistik yang mengutamakan teks tetapi menggelapkan makna moralitas dalam berhukum. Aspek moralitas dalam hukum seakan tenggelam dalam praktik hukum yang mendewakan tekstual undang-undang tetapi melalaikan esensi moral dalam undang-undang. Penelitian ini merupakan penelitian yuridis-normatif yang berorientasi pada koherensi antara asas-asas hukum yang bersumber pada moralitas dengan norma hukum serta praktik hukum di masyarakat. Kebaruan dari penelitian ini yaitu pembangunan moralitas dalam praktik negara hukum dengan mengedepankan dua aspek, yaitu aspek integrative mechanism dari Harry C. Bredemeier dengan hukum progresif dari Satjipto Rahardjo. Hasil dari penelitian ini menegaskan bahwa upaya membangun hukum tidak boleh melupakan aspek pembangunan moralitas. Simpulan dalam penelitian ini menegaskan bahwa, pembangunan hukum dan moralitas akan berjalan secara optimal dengan meneguhkan hukum sebagai integrative mechanism serta menerapkan hukum progresif sebagai solusi dalam menghadapi jagat kelesuan berhukum bangsa Indonesia.
31 December 2021 in Mulawarman Law Review
Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk mengetahui urgensi kriminalisasi pengguna jasa prostitusi online. Metode penelitian dalam tulisan ini adalah penelitian yuridis-normatif. Penelitian ini menghasilkan temuan adanya kekosongan hukum mengenai pengaturan kriminalisasi penggua jasa dan inkonsistensi hukum dalam penegakan dan penanggulangan prostitusi online. Pengguna jasa dalam praktek prostitusi online merupakan pihak yang terpenting karena telah menjadi prinsip dasar bahwa tidak akan ada penjual jika tidak ada pembelinya. Oleh karena itu, apabila pengguna jasa prostitusi online tidak segera dikriminalisasikan, maka pengguna prostitusi online akan tetap leluasa dan merasa aman melakukan praktek pelacuran yang pada akhirnya menyebabkan meningkatnya permasalahan sosial yang berdampak dalam bidang hak asasi manusia, social, agama, dan kesehatan karena prostitusi online merupakan perbuatan yang hina, immoral, dan tidak sesuai dengan nilai-nilai yang terkandung dalam Pancasila. Dengan demikian diperlukan pembaharuan hukum pidana dengan mengkriminalisasikan pengguna jasa prostitusi online demi menanggulangi permasalahan sosial serta terciptanya keadilan dan kepastian hukum untuk perlindungan dan kesejahteraan masyarakat.
17 July 2025 in Al-Adl : Jurnal Hukum
Press conferences involving suspects are frequently justified as mechanisms for ensuring accountability within law enforcement. However, these press conferences pose significant risks to the presumption of innocence and may lead to violations of human rights. This research seeks to establish normative limitations on the conduct of press conferences to safeguard the presumption of innocence. Utilizing a normative legal methodology, this study employs statutory, case, and conceptual approaches. The findings indicate that presenting a suspect in an open press conference tends to foster a presumption of guilt within the community, often before a court has rendered a legally binding decision. Moreover, the absence of explicit regulatory guidelines generates legal uncertainty and heightens the potential for abuse of authority by law enforcement officials. Consequently, stringent regulations are imperative to ensure that press conferences are conducted only when the suspect voluntarily agrees to appear in public, free from coercion, in the presence of legal counsel, and under the supervision of an independent oversight body. Such regulations would help balance the public's right to information with the protection of the suspect’s dignity and legal rights..
31 December 2025 in Jurnal Konstitusi
This article analyses the constitutional and procedural implications of the absence of pre-trial authority to review decisions to terminate preliminary inquiries (penghentian penyelidikan) in Indonesia’s criminal justice system. While suspects are afforded robust due process guarantees through pre-trial mechanisms, victims lack a commensurate judicial forum to contest unilateral police decisions to terminate proceedings at the preliminary inquiry stage. This procedural asymmetry engenders a structural lacuna, conceptualised herein as an “injustice gap.” Employing a normative legal research method, the study analyses the 1981 Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP 1981), the newly approved 2025 Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP 2025), relevant Constitutional Court decisions, and related judicial practices through the theoretical frameworks of John Rawls’s theory of justice and Lon L. Fuller’s concept of the internal morality of law. The analysis demonstrates that the current asymmetrical distribution of protections between suspects and victims is incompatible with the constitutional principles of equality before the law, legal certainty, and the right to an effective remedy. Accordingly, the article proposes three reform pathways: explicit regulation of Inquiry terminations as an object of pre-trial review, constitutional reinterpretation by the Constitutional Court, or the establishment of a Preliminary Examining Judge (Hakim Pemeriksa Pendahuluan, HPP) to reconstruct pre-trial proceedings as an effective remedy for victims.