1 November 2014 in Global Environmental Change
24 October 2016 in Transnational Environmental Law
Many multilateral environmental agreements have adopted differentiated rules for different countries, based on the recognition of the ‘common but differentiated responsibilities’ (CBDRs) of states. By establishing two rigid groups of countries with and without emissions reduction obligations, the intergovernmental climate regime represents the most extreme case of such differentiation. The regime has struggled to overcome this rigidity and the resulting political deadlock between developing and developed countries. Transnational climate governance (TCG) initiatives have emerged as an alternative to provide mitigation, adaptation or finance outside the multilateral process. By drawing on synergies between public and private actors, it is hoped that they overcome the paralysis of the intergovernmental process. Yet, they take place in the same world of unequal peers, with different levels of capacity and responsibility for climate change. This article investigates the extent to which such TCG initiatives reflect the CBDR principle. Do different types of initiative – involving different types of actor or with different climate-related goals – address differentiation in distinct ways? Does taking account of CBDRs affect the membership of transnational initiatives? This article explores these questions empirically by analyzing a sample of TCG initiatives in terms of how they include differential treatment of states and non-state members. It concludes that TCG initiatives address differentiation in a pragmatic way. Most frequently, they either offer participants flexibility in how to implement their commitments, or provide support to members from developing countries. Such support is, so far, still insufficient to address the limited involvement of developing country actors.
1 March 2014 in Global Environmental Change
1 March 2012 in Climate Policy
Under the Kyoto Protocol, developing countries can voluntarily participate in climate change mitigation through the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM), in which industrialized countries, in order to meet their mitigation commitments, can buy emission reduction credits from projects in developing countries. Before its implementation, developing-country experts opposed the CDM, arguing that it would sell-off their countries’ cheapest emission reduction options and force them to invest in more expensive measures to meet their future reduction targets. This ‘low-hanging fruit’ argument is analysed empirically by comparing marginal abatement cost curves. Emissions abatement costs and potentials for CDM projects are estimated for different technologies in eight countries, using capital budgeting tools and information from project documentation. It is found that the CDM is not yet capturing a large portion of the identified abatement potential in most countries. Although the costs of most emissions reduction opportunities grasped are below the average credit price, there are still plenty of available low-cost opportunities. Mexico and Argentina appear to use the CDM predominantly for harvesting the low-hanging fruit, whereas in the other countries more expensive projects are accessing the CDM. This evidence at first sight challenges the low-hanging fruit claim, but needs to be understood in the light of the barriers for the adoption of low-cost abatement options.
15 September 2020 in International Political Science Review
Coalitions play a central role in the international negotiations under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. By getting together, countries join resources in defending their interests and positions. But building coalitions may come at a cost. Coalition positions are a result of compromise between their members, and thus the increase in bargaining power may come at a price if the preferences of their members are heterogeneous. Relying on automatic text analysis of written position papers submitted to the negotiations, I analyze the extent to which coalitions represent the preferences of their members and discuss whether this contributes to disproportionate policy responses at the international level. I focus on a recently formed coalition: the Like-Minded Developing Countries, a large and heterogeneous group that brings together emerging, oil-dependent and poor developing countries.
25 May 2021 in International Studies Quarterly
Differential treatment is a key norm in multilateral environmental agreements. Its main objective is to increase compliance and reduce the free-rider problem by apportioning the costs and benefits of implementation more equitably across the parties in an agreement. The question of how to differentiate those burdens is inextricably linked to national interests, and while in some instances differential treatment is well designed and facilitates cooperation, in other cases a rigid divide—or cleavage—leads to a stalemate and constant conflict. This article studies the consequences of differential treatment as institutionalized under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). Previous research has shown that the separation of UNFCCC parties into two opposing groups has deepened the polarization in the negotiations. We identify two causal mechanisms that may have driven this polarization, namely socialization through material incentives and the formation of group identity. We draw on an original dataset that records (dis)agreements between country pairs, coded from negotiation summaries between 1995 and 2013. Using a relational events model, we show that the division of UNFCCC parties into Annex I (with obligations) and non-Annex I (without obligations) is related primarily to material incentives and less to group identity formation.El trato diferenciado es una norma fundamental en los acuerdos ambientales multilaterales. Su principal objetivo es aumentar el cumplimiento y reducir el problema de los oportunistas distribuyendo los costos y los beneficios de la implementación de forma más equitativa entre las partes de un acuerdo. La cuestión de cómo diferenciar esas cargas está inextricablemente vinculada a los intereses nacionales y mientras que en algunos casos el trato diferenciado está bien diseñado y facilita la cooperación, en otros casos, una división rígida o escisión conduce a un estancamiento o un conflicto constante. En este artículo se estudian las consecuencias del trato diferenciado institucionalizado en la Convención Marco de las Naciones Unidas sobre el Cambio Climático (CMNUCC). Investigaciones anteriores han demostrado que la separación de las partes de la CMNUCC en dos grupos opuestos ha profundizado la polarización en las negociaciones. Identificamos dos mecanismos causales que pueden haber impulsado esta polarización; a saber, la socialización a través de incentivos materiales y la formación de la identidad de grupo. Nos basamos en un conjunto de datos original que registra los (des)acuerdos entre pares de países, codificados a partir de resúmenes de negociación entre 1995 y 2013. Utilizando un modelo de eventos relacionales, demostramos que la división de las partes de la CMNUCC en Anexo I (con obligaciones) y no Anexo I (sin obligaciones) está relacionada principalmente con los incentivos materiales y no tan relacionada con la formación de la identidad de grupo.Le traitement différencié est une norme clé des accords environnementaux multilatéraux. Son principal objectif est d'accroître la conformité et de réduire le problème de bénéficiaire sans contrepartie en répartissant plus équitablement les coûts et les avantages de la mise en œuvre d'un accord entre les parties qui y sont impliquées. La question de savoir comment différencier ces « fardeaux » est inextricablement liée aux intérêts nationaux, et bien que dans certains cas, le traitement différencié soit bien conçu et facilite la coopération, dans d'autres cas, une séparation rigide—ou clivage—conduit à une impasse et à un conflit permanent. Cet article étudie les conséquences du traitement différencié tel qu'il est institutionnalisé dans la Convention-cadre des Nations unies sur les changements climatiques (CCNUCC). Une recherche précédente a monté que la séparation des parties de la CCNUCC en deux groupes opposés avait accru la polarisation des négociations. Nous avons identifié deux mécanismes causaux qui peuvent avoir entraîné cette polarisation: la socialisation par incitations matérielles et la formation d'une identité de groupe. Nous nous appuyons sur un jeu de données original retraçant les (dés)accords entre paires de pays, qui ont été codés à partir des résumés des négociations qui sont intervenues entre 1995 et 2013. Nous utilisons un modèle d’événements relationnels et montrons que la séparation entre parties de la CCNUCC en pays de l'Annexe I (avec obligations) et pays hors Annexe I (sans obligations) est principalement davantage associée à des incitations matérielles qu’à une formation d'identité de groupe.