6 February 2025 in bioRxiv
The restoration of degraded ecosystems is critical for mitigating climate change and reversing biodiversity loss. Depending on the primary objective – such as maximizing carbon sequestration or protecting threatened species – and within the boundaries of budget constraints, different spatial priorities have been identified at global and regional scales. Funding mechanisms to support such work comprise public sources, philanthropy, and the private sector, including the sales of carbon and biodiversity credits. However, effectively exploring tradeoffs among restoration objectives and estimating the price of biodiversity and carbon credits to design financially viable projects remain challenging. Here we harness the power of artificial intelligence in our software CAPTAIN, which we further develop to identify spatial priorities for ecological restoration that maximize multiple objectives at once and to allow a robust evaluation of biodiversity and climate outcomes. We find through a series of simulations that even low-to-moderate consideration of biodiversity in restoration projects leads to the selection of restored areas that disproportionately improve the conservation of threatened species, while resulting in a relatively smaller total amount of carbon captured. We propose a data-driven valuation of biodiversity credits in relation to carbon credits, enabling the design of a bundled financial model that could support restoration efforts even in areas previously excluded for economic reasons. Applying our methodology to plant diversity in the Atlantic Forest of eastern South America, one of the most biodiverse and threatened ecosystems globally, we demonstrate its practical utility in guiding real-world restoration and quantifying the essential trade-offs between climate and nature outcomes. Our study provides a robust, scalable methodological pathway to optimize the outcomes of restoration efforts for climate and nature.
28 October 2025 in Environmental Research Letters
The financing of tropical forest conservation projects through the sale of carbon credits remains a key opportunity to curb forest loss. Reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation (REDD)+ projects generate carbon credits by reducing forest loss within the project area compared with a counterfactual area that faces similar pressures (known as ‘additionality’). Several methods are available for constructing counterfactuals, but comparing their reliability is challenging. Here, we present an evaluation approach based on the creation of placebo projects, where there are no REDD+ activities and in which we would not expect project and counterfactual outcomes to diverge. We compare four methods based on pixel matching that estimate counterfactual deforestation rates. Using 27 placebo projects spread across the tropics, we found that pixel-matching is a reliable way of estimating a key element of additionality (i.e. deforestation in counterfactual areas) when based on data gathered at the end of an evaluation period after project start (i.e. ex-post estimation). However, forecasting counterfactual deforestation rates from information available at the start of a project (i.e. ex-ante estimation) is much less reliable, reinforcing existing concerns about ex-ante crediting mechanisms. We argue that systematic application of the placebo approach can accelerate the development and adoption of more credible counterfactual-estimating methods. As counterfactuals are the basis which underpins the validity claims of most nature credits, strengthening the credibility of counterfactuals will enhance the effectiveness of conservation finance, helping REDD+ and other nature-based solutions realise their full potential in delivering real, measurable benefits.
14 December 2024 in New Phytologist
Summary: Tropical cyclones (TCs) sporadically cause extensive damage to forests. However, little is known about how TCs affect forest dynamics in mountainous terrain, due to difficulties in modelling wind flows and quantifying structural changes. Typhoon Mangkhut (2018) was the strongest TC to strike Hong Kong in over 40 yr, with gusts > 250 km h−1. Remarkably, the event was captured by a dense anemometer network and repeated LiDAR surveys across natural forests and plantations. We mapped long‐term mean and extreme wind speeds using CFD models and analysed corresponding changes in canopy height, which uncovered TC‐forest dynamics at unprecedented scales (> 400 000 pixels, 1108 km2). Forest height was more strongly limited by wind exposure than by background topography, a limitation attributable to a dynamic equilibrium between growth and disproportionate TC damage to taller forests. Counterintuitively, wind‐sheltered forests also suffered heavy damage. As a result, canopies of wind‐sheltered forests were more rugged, which contrasted with flat‐topped forests at wind‐exposed sites. Plantations were more susceptible to TCs compared to natural rainforests of similar stature (canopy height change −0.86 m vs −0.39 m). Our findings highlight TCs as important, often overlooked factor that fundamentally shapes forest structure and dynamics.
18 December 2023 in Cambridge Open Engage
This draft document describes the methodology developed by the Cambridge Center for Carbon Credits (4C) for estimating the number of credits to be issued to a project in the tropical moist forest (TMF) biome. It expands on the methodology outlined in (Swinfield and Balmford, 2023). We welcome comments and suggestions in the associated online document at https://tinyurl.com/cowgreport.
9 November 2026 in Global Change Biology
The restoration of degraded ecosystems is critical for mitigating climate change and reversing biodiversity loss. Depending on the primary objective—such as maximizing carbon sequestration or protecting threatened species—and within the boundaries of budget limitations, different spatial priorities have been identified at global and regional scales. Funding mechanisms to support such work comprise public sources, philanthropy, and the private sector, including the sale of carbon and biodiversity credits. However, effectively exploring trade‐offs among restoration objectives and estimating the price of biodiversity and carbon credits to design financially viable projects remains scientifically challenging. Here we harness the power of artificial intelligence implemented in the software CAPTAIN to identify spatial priorities for ecological restoration that maximize multiple objectives at once and to allow a robust evaluation of biodiversity and climate outcomes. We find through a series of simulations that even low‐to‐moderate consideration of biodiversity in the design of restoration projects leads to the selection of restored areas that disproportionately improve the conservation of threatened species, while the carbon captured is only slightly reduced. We propose the bundling of biodiversity and carbon credits to support restoration efforts even in areas previously excluded for economic reasons. Applying our methodology to plant diversity in the Atlantic Forest of eastern South America, one of the most biodiverse and threatened ecosystems globally, we demonstrate its potential to guide restoration and to quantify trade‐offs between multiple optimization scenarios. Our study provides a robust, scalable method to maximize the joint benefits of ecological restoration for climate and nature.
11 October 2025 in Cambridge Open Engage
The financing of tropical forest conservation projects through the sale of carbon credits remains a key opportunity to curb forest loss. REDD+ projects generate carbon credits by reducing deforestation and degradation within the project area compared with a counterfactual area that faces similar pressures (known as “additionality”). Several methods are available for constructing counterfactuals, but comparing their effectiveness is challenging. Here, we present an evaluation approach based on the creation of placebo projects, in which there are no REDD+ activities and in which we would not expect any carbon credits to be generated. We compare four methods based on pixel matching to estimate counterfactual deforestation rates. Using 40 placebo projects spread across the tropics, we found that pixel-matching is a reliable way of calculating a key element of additionality (i.e. deforestation in counterfactual areas) when based on data gathered at the end of an accounting period (i.e. ex post estimation). However, forecasting additionality from information available at the start of projects (i.e. ex ante estimation) is much less reliable, reinforcing existing concerns about ex ante crediting mechanisms. We argue that systematic application of the placebo approach can accelerate the development and adoption of more credible counterfactual-estimating methods. As counterfactuals are the basis which underpins the validity claims of most nature credits, strengthening the credibility of counterfactuals will enhance the effectiveness of conservation finance, helping REDD+ and other nature-based solutions realise their full potential in delivering real, measurable benefits.