23 April 2025 in Environmental Research: Health
This article showcases the relevance and complementarity of commonly used bioethics theories and frameworks for thinking about the challenges and moral tensions that (may) arise in efforts to move toward a more sustainable and ecological healthcare sector. It presents critical insights from deontology, consequentialism, virtue ethics, contractualism, modern casuistry, justice theories, and feminist approaches to bioethics, and points to important lessons from each of these for a green healthcare ethics in which acknowledging and dealing with potential, real, or apparent trade-offs is central. While ideal moral theories and frameworks such as deontology, consequentialism and virtue ethics can offer relevant normative principles to guide change at individual, organizational, and societal levels, other approaches such as contractualism and casuistry can offer practical and procedural guidance for addressing trade-off situations. In addition, justice theories and feminist approaches can offer normative grounds, respectively, for determining how to appropriately and equitably distributing the benefits, risks and burdens of specific initiatives or policies that are envisioned for transitioning to green healthcare sector, and for better understanding the role of complex human–human and human–environment relations and interdependencies in these discussions. These lessons provide foundations for the development of a comprehensive ethical framework, and we advocate for their future integration into a trade-off ethics.
11 April 2025 in Environmental Research: Health
The healthcare sector’s contribution to climate change and pollution more broadly is now widely recognised as problematic. Not only does it disrupt the ecosystems and the living environment, but it also paradoxically affects human health. In recent years, an increasing number of countries have committed to reducing the ecological footprint, or in other words, the ‘environmental cost’ of their healthcare system. Achieving a responsible transition toward a greener healthcare sector requires considering the perspectives and potential roles of various actors and stakeholders within the field. Thus far, very few studies have investigated the perspectives of (potential) healthcare consumers on challenges, ethical issues and social tensions that could arise during the transition to a greener healthcare system. To address this gap, we carried out five group interviews, exploring the views of 28 participants on climate change, healthcare pollution, and their sense of engagement in reducing healthcare pollution. Data were collected, coded and analysed using an inductive process. While most participants perceived climate change as a serious threat to human health, many were unaware of the healthcare sector’s significant contribution to it. Pharmaceutical waste and plastic pollution were identified as the main problems. Two promising avenues for reducing healthcare pollution emerged from the findings: promoting healthcare sobriety and improving education for actors and stakeholders on the sector’s contribution to global pollution. Participants defined healthcare sobriety through four key elements: adequate care, collective responsibility, ecological finance, and prevention. Regarding education, they underline that it should be done at the right time, by the right person and in an effective manner. Two important barriers to achieving these goals were identified: participants are less willing to accept trade-offs when it is health-related; and ethical concerns were raised about mobilizing vulnerable populations to achieve carbon neutrality in the healthcare sector.
18 May 2026 in The American Journal of Bioethics
Given the lack of clear guidelines for integrating environmental considerations into the design of health research protocols and their review by bodies at different stages (e.g., funding agencies, ...
6 May 2026 in Global Bioethics
Healthcare systems contribute significantly to environmental degradation (Lenzen et al., 2020), making their ecological transition increasingly urgent (Alami et al., 2023). While the environmental ...