27 March 2019 in Seismological Research Letters
In different subsurface energy technologies, traffic light systems (TLSs) have been implemented for limiting the strength of induced seismicity. Despite their widespread application, fundamental assumptions regarding the controllability of induced seismicity were usually not reviewed. This is the focus of the current article, in which we discuss limitations of a TLS in the context of seismicity induced by fluid injection and gas production. Most existing TLSs are based on a critical earthquake magnitude or vibration level that should be prevented to occur. Operational measures are defined to be taken after an induced earthquake exceeds predefined threshold values. This concept rests on the tacit assumptions that induced earthquakes of a critical strength announce themselves by precursory events of smaller strength and that future earthquakes of a critical strength can be prevented by modifying or stopping subsurface operations. We investigate to what extent these assumptions can be justified by studying observation data from a dozen fluid‐injection operations in geothermal reservoirs as well as from gas production in 26 gas fields in The Netherlands. In our case studies, whereas fluid injection–induced seismicity generally starts at a low‐magnitude level and exhibits a gradual temporal increase of the maximum earthquake magnitude with the duration of the injection, the largest magnitude event frequently occurs postinjection. The temporal evolution of the seismicity induced by gas production in The Netherlands is less systematic. In some gas fields, seismicity started at a comparatively large‐magnitude level () without detectable precursors. A correlation between seismic activity and the gas production rate is only observed in the largest gas field. Our findings indicate that the precision to what an earthquake of a given strength can be prevented by a TLS has more limitations than typically assumed.
1 February 1999 in Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America
We study the nature of extremely narrow-band signals that appear in typical long-time spectra of seismic recordings. At the German Experimental Seismic System (GERESS) array, we observe several of these time-continuous spectral lines. The most prominent one has a frequency near 2.083 Hz. The close agreement of this frequency with one of the feasible rotation frequencies of synchronous machines (50 Hz /24) suggests an industrial origin of the signal. An observed signal gap of 11 h duration is thus interpreted as a temporary machine shutdown. Interestingly, the signal vanishes (or is at least strongly reduced in amplitude) in the whole eastern part of the German Regional Seismic Network (GRSN) suggesting (1) that a single source dominates the signal in that region and (2) that the narrow-band signal propagates to distances of more than 300 km. On the other hand, we study the character of the wave by performing a suitably adapted array analysis. Estimates of the propagation direction suggest a source location near the German-Czech border. We obtain an estimate of the apparent velocity near 4 km/sec. Comparison with transient arrivals from regional earthquakes suggests that the narrow-band energy propagates as regional phases of Lg and Sg type.
13 August 2020 in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
An approach is proposed for estimating in situ reservoir pressure changes based on induced earthquakes with overlapping slip patches. The approach is independent of absolute (tectonic) stresses and can also be applied in a scenario where the (unknown) tectonic stresses are strongly heterogeneous. Based on Coulomb friction, the approach makes use of the fact that stress‐strength conditions are in equilibrium at the time of seismic activation. Coseismic stress changes inferred from seismogram recordings provide the stress‐state relative to the failure stress immediately after seismic activation. If the same fracture patch is seismically activated again, relative changes of fluid pressure, that is, the fluid pressure change at which stress‐strength conditions reach equilibrium again, can be inferred from the stress‐deficit when accounting for stress re‐load from neighboring patches. The performance of the technique is demonstrated using a data set of 20,736 earthquakes induced during a hydraulic injection experiment in a geothermal reservoir in the Cooper Basin, Australia. The spatial hypocenter distribution indicates that the seismicity mainly occurred on a single‐layer structure with slip direction controlled by the regional stress field as evidenced by fault mechanisms. Due to the high earthquake density, interearthquake stress interaction is pronounced. The spatial stress impact associated with each earthquake is simulated using a slider‐block type propagation pattern based on Okada's analytical solutions. Using the scalar seismic moment determined from S‐wave spectra, the spatio‐temporal evolution of hydraulic pressure changes is inferred on a reservoir scale. Results indicate that hydraulic flow is most pronounced into NW‐SE direction.
19 September 2023 in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
28 June 2021 in International Journal of Geophysics
We apply a recently developed approach for inferring in situ fluid pressure changes from induced seismicity observations to datasets from geothermal reservoirs at St. Gallen (Switzerland), Paralana (Australia), and Cooper Basin (Australia), respectively. The approach, referred to as seismohydraulic pressure mapping (SHPM), is based on mapping the seismic moment of induced earthquakes. Relative fluid pressure changes are inferred from the stress deficit of fracture patches slipping repeatedly. The SHPM approach was developed for the specific scenario, where induced earthquakes occur on a single, larger-scale plane with slip being driven by the regional stress field. We demonstrate that this scenario applies to the three datasets under investigation, indicating that geothermal systems in crystalline rock could typically be fault-dominated. For all datasets, individual earthquake source geometry could not be determined from source spectra due to the attenuation of the high signal frequencies. Instead, SHPM was applied assuming a constant stress drop in a circular crack model. Absolute values of inferred pressure change scale with the assumed stress drop while the spatiotemporal pattern of pressure changes remains similar even when varying stress drop by one order of magnitude. We demonstrate how the associated mismapping of seismic moment tends to average out when hypocentres are densely spaced. Our results indicate that SHPM could provide important information for calibrating numerical reservoir models.