The existence of bulk nanobubbles has long been regarded with scepticism, due to the limitations of experimental techniques and the widespread assumption that spherical bubbles cannot achieve stable equilibrium. We develop a model for the stability of bulk nanobubbles based on the experimental observation that the zeta potential of spherical bubbles abruptly diverges from the planar value below . Our calculations recover three persistently reported—but disputed—properties of bulk nanobubbles: that they stabilize at a typical radius of , that this radius is bounded below , and that it increases with ionic concentration.
The remarkably long lifetime of surface nanobubbles has perplexed researchers for two decades. The current understanding is that both contact line pinning and supersaturation of the ambient liquid are strictly required for the stability of nanobubbles, yet experiments show nanobubbles surviving in open systems and undersaturated environments. We find that this discrepancy can be addressed if the effects of an attractive hydrophobic potential at the solid substrate on the spatial distribution of the gas concentration is taken into account. We also show that, in our model, only substrate pinning is strictly required for stabilization; while hydrophobicity and supersaturation both aid stability, neither is mandatory—the absence of one can be compensated by an excess of the other.
Many of the remarkable properties of surface nanobubbles, such as unusually small contact angles and long lifetimes, are related to the force that pins them onto their substrates. This pinning force is yet to be quantified experimentally. Here, surface-attached nanobubbles are pulled with an atomic force microscope tip while their mechanical responses are observed with total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy. We estimate that a pinning force on the order of is required to unpin a nanobubble from its substrate. The maximum force that the tip can exert on the nanobubble is limited by the stability of the neck pulled from the bubble and is enhanced by the hydrophobicity of the tip.
The theoretical understanding of surface nanobubbles—nanoscale gaseous domains on immersed substrates—revolves around two contrasting perspectives. One perspective, which considers gas transport in the nanobubbles’ vicinity, explains numerous stability-related properties but systematically underestimates the dynamical response timescale by orders of magnitude. The other perspective, which considers gas transport as the bulk liquid equilibrates with the external environment, recovers the experimentally observed dynamical timescale but incorrectly predicts that nanobubbles progressively shrink until dissolution. We propose a model that couples both perspectives, which is capable of explaining the stability, dynamics, and unexpected tolerance of surface nanobubbles to undersaturated environments.