This chapter elaborates on the relationship between genus-, species- and strain-specific and disease condition-specific effects, issues, and applications of probiotics. It discusses the significance of certain genera and strains of probiotic microbes over others, as well as their unique mechanisms of action in combating certain diseases. The chapter details the uniqueness of probiotics in the two different levels of taxonomy, focusing especially on Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium as traditional examples of probiotics, while also shedding light on their shared mechanisms and traits. Explanations of the therapeutic effects of probiotics across a range of different diseases are also provided, with reference to the genus and species to which each probiotic belongs. The chapter should ultimately enable the reader to identify and predict the effect of different probiotics when applied to the treatment of different disease conditions, based on the genus and species to which it belongs, while also relating the possible issues that may arise with the use of the same.