Quantum cascade lasers (QCLs) and interband cascade lasers (ICLs) are widely used as light sources in tunable laser absorption spectroscopy because they emit in the mid-infrared region where many strong and characteristic absorption bands are present. In this paper, we compare the performance of these lasers emitting at about 2310.1 cm –1 to determine an optimal light source for detecting isotopic ratios of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ). Our results show that the QCL has a higher relative intensity noise of up to 15 dBc/Hz compared to the ICL over the entire measured frequency range. In addition, it has a higher frequency fluctuation. However, the maximum tuning range of the QCL is up to 5.2 cm –1 compared to up to 3.8 cm –1 for the ICL. Both lasers lose more than half of their tuning range when the tuning rate is increased to 10 kHz. When measuring the isotope ratio of CO 2 , an uncertainty in the value of ‰ was achieved with the ICL and of ‰ with the QCL, both at an integration time of 0.2 s. In summary, the QCL is more appropriate for applications that require a larger spectral tuning range, such as the measurement of a complex gas mixture, while the ICL has an excellent signal-to-noise ratio and is therefore better suited for applications that require higher precision.
We present a mid-infrared dual comb spectrometer for the precise determination of the isotopic ratio of the stable CO2 isotoplogues 12C16O2 and 13C16O2 under atmospheric pressure. The spectrometer is based on electro-optic intensity modulation at 1550 nm wavelength and subsequent wavelength flexible conversion to the mid-infrared. Here, the fundamental absorptions of CO2 in the ν3 band around 4.3 μm wavelength (2300 cm-1) were accessed to achieve the needed sensitivity to investigate the isotopic composition at atmospheric concentrations. The high spectral resolution of 0.004 cm-1 and spectral coverage of 8 cm-1 enable the measurements of the three most abundant CO2 isotopologues 12C16O2, 13C16O2 and 16O12C18O at ambient pressure. The high average signal-to-noise ratio per comb mode of 51 dB and a noise equivalent absorption coefficient of 5.4(9)·10-6 cm-1 Hz-1/2 ensures high precision. After an integration time of 172 s a precision on the stable isotopic ratio (δ13C) of <0.1‰ is achieved according to Allan deviation analysis. A linearity analysis on the measured concentrations of the single isotopologues results in coefficients of determination (R2) of 0.999 for CO2 concentrations ranging from 300 to 450 ppm, whereas for the measurement of δ13C-values ranging from -36.5‰ and -5.4‰ a coefficient of determination of 0.998 was achieved. This linear behavior and the high precision on the measurements demonstrate the great potential of the presented dual comb spectrometer for atmospheric research. Especially, where measurements under low pressure must be avoided, the here presented system is a promising alternative to established quantum cascade laser-based systems.